Doesn’t jlink require a *fully* modularized application? I.e. no non-module dependencies. The packaging tool should work with all runnable Java applications, not just fully modularized ones.
Modularization seems to be a bit of an effort and is one of the main reasons my application(s) are still stuck on Java 8. Scott > On Jun 27, 2018, at 6:30 PM, Kevin Rushforth <kevin.rushfo...@oracle.com> > wrote: > > We're aiming to get this into JDK 12 early enough so that an EA build would > be available around the time JDK 11 ships. That will allow you to take a > jlinked image with JDK 11 and package it up using (the EA) jpackager. > > We will create a development branch in the JDK sandbox [1] some time in the > next week or so so you can follow the development. > > Also, thank you to those who have provided feedback. I'll reply to feedback > soon and then incorporate it into an updated JEP. > > -- Kevin > > > On 6/27/2018 3:09 AM, Buchberger, Joerg wrote: >> Thanks for the info! And thanks for the efforts. [no irony, no sarcasm - I >> really mean it] >> >> But, to sum up my comprehension... >> >> anyone who placed their bets on javapackager, starting with last LTS Java 8 >> will be left in the rain with followup LTS Java 11, because their ain't >> neither javapackager (anymore), nor jpackager (yet). >> >> Is this correct? >> >> So, strategic choice boils down to either throw away all work done based on >> javapackager so far and the associated distribution concepts (reworking >> everything from scratch) >> or neglect Java 11 completely, thus placing all bets on jpackager really >> coming w/ Java 12 or even waiting for Java 14 as next LTS thereafter. >> >> Bam(!), I think, I first need a tiny shot now ;-) and let that info sink in >> ... >> >> Cheers >> Jörg >> >> >> On 5/31/2018 0:10 AM, Rushforth, Kevin wrote: >>> I would like to propose the following Draft JEP [1] for discussion. >>> >>> JDK-8200758: Packaging Tool >>> >>> This is intended as a JDK-scope replacement for the existing >>> javapackager tool that ships with Oracle JDK 10 (and earlier Oracle JDK >>> releases), and was delivered as part of the JavaFX build. The >>> javapackager tool has been removed from Oracle JDK 11 along with the >>> removal of JavaFX. >>> >>> Comments on this JEP are welcome. It is currently not targeted for a >>> specific release, but we are aiming for JDK 12. >>> >>> -- Kevin >>> >>> [1] https://bugs.openjdk.java.net/browse/JDK-8200758 >>> >
