On Tue, 6 Sep 2022 12:32:46 GMT, Markus KARG <d...@openjdk.org> wrote:
>> BIS dates from JDK 1.0 and it's not hard to find examples that extend it.
>> The HexPrinter test reminds us that it has been possible for 25+ years to
>> override the read methods and snoop on all bytes that are read. Adding an
>> override of the transferTo method that bypasses the read methods might break
>> these subclasses. So I think Daniel is right that we have to be cautious.
>>
>> So I think the feedback that you have now is that bypassing the buffer is
>> problematic when using mark, when there are buffered bytes, or when BIS has
>> been extended. It may be that the starting point is something very
>> conservative like this:
>>
>>
>> @Override
>> public long transferTo(OutputStream out) throws IOException {
>> if (getClass() == BufferedInputStream.class
>> && ((count - pos) <= 0) && (markpos == -1)) {
>> return getInIfOpen().transferTo(out);
>> } else {
>> return super.transferTo(out);
>> }
>> }
>>
>>
>> There is also the issue of locking and async close to look into.
>
> Thank you for your decision about this issue, so instead of fixing the
> existing bugs I will implement as you outlined.
>
> BTW, locking and rebasing is on the way.
Rebased and fixed locking, using your proposed code now.
@AlanBateman Async close leaves BIS in an invalid state. The JavaDocs say `
The behavior for the case where the inputand/or output stream is asynchronously
closed, or the thread interrupted during the transfer, is highly input and
output streamspecific, and therefore not specified.`. So there is seems to be
no *essential* need to do something *particular* in that case (the caller
cannot further use the BIS, just like after an IOE: `It is strongly recommended
that both streams be promptly closed if an I/O error occurs.` -- which is what
*I personally, as a user of BIS* would do after async close), but if you *want*
that we reach a particular outcome, then just tell me what outcome you envision.
-------------
PR: https://git.openjdk.org/jdk/pull/6935
