Thanks for the reply, Barbie. For now, I’ve just uploaded Inline-0.54_03.tar.gz to CPAN, which will ensure that the reports I receive relate solely to the distro that I’ve uploaded ... for as long as no-one else uploads an Inline-0.54_03.tar.gz to CPAN, anyway :-)
Cheers, Rob From: Barbie Sent: Thursday, April 10, 2014 9:13 AM To: David Golden Cc: Sisyphus ; CPAN Testers Discuss Subject: Re: Baffling Inline-0.54_01 test failures. This is one area I would like to improve with the CPAN Testers Reports site. I often get questions about distributions with the same name, but due the legacy way this was handled, it's never been adequately resolved, such that older distributions couldn't be distinguished from each other (at least not reliably). Now that we have the metabase facts, we can. Once a few other projects out the way, I will take another look at this, and see what changes are necessary to use the AUTHOR as well as the version to differentiate between distributions and associated reports. Thanks, Barbie. -- Birmingham.pm - http://birmingham.pm.org CPAN Testers - http://cpantesters.org YAPC Surveys - http://yapc-surveys.org Perl Jam - http://perljam.info On Wed, Apr 9, 2014 at 2:50 PM, David Golden <x...@xdg.me> wrote: On Wed, Apr 9, 2014 at 2:49 AM, <sisyph...@optusnet.com.au> wrote: > Can I be sure that the tester reports I quoted were in response to the > latter ? .... or could they have been in response to the former ? Look at the "Dear XXXX" part of the email, as that is generated from the author's PAUSE ID. This is one of the big, historical problems in the CPAN ecosystem. Many, many services assume that a distribution name is unique and there was never any restriction on that. Recently, at the QA Hackathon, PAUSE now will not index a distribution tarball unless the uploader has permissions on a package corresponding to the distribution name, but that only keeps the problem out of the index file. Many smokers test all uploads regardless of indexing status. The Metabase that holds the CPAN Testers info actually captures AUTHOR/TARBALL, but that's not exposed downstream so the "Dear XXXX" is the best you've got. David -- David Golden <x...@xdg.me> Twitter/IRC: @xdg
