-Caveat Lector- from: http://www.zolatimes.com/V3.13/pageone.html <A HREF="http://www.zolatimes.com/V3.13/pageone.html">Laissez Faire City Times - Volume 3 Issue 13</A> ----- The Laissez Faire City Times March 29, 1999 - Volume 3, Issue 13 Editor & Chief: Emile Zola ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Are They Really Libertarian? by Sunni Maravillosa I first came across a curious attitude in someone�s e-mail signature, which read, "The people of [X state] are libertarian�they just don�t know it yet". At the time it seemed a rather presumptuous statement, particularly from someone who�s a libertarian. I attributed it to a somewhat na�ve optimism and didn�t give the matter any more thought. Then I saw it again. Kurt Russell said, "I�m a Libertarian. I think a lot of people are libertarians and are afraid to admit it�or don�t know". His statement also struck me as fairly cheeky. As it came from Kurt Russell, though, and not a libertarian intellectual (no disrespect intended, but Hollywood celebrities are not renowned for their intellect), I again dismissed the comment, this time on "consider the source" grounds. But I began to pay closer attention to what was being written and said about libertarians. Sure enough, I saw it again. And again. And these references were by respected libertarians, and intellectuals to boot. For example, David Boaz, Vice President of the Cato Institute contends in Left, Right, and Babyboom: America's New Politics that baby-boomers don�t fit neatly into liberal and conservative labels. Boaz concludes that therefore, many baby-boomers are actually libertarian. But this doesn�t match with the number of members of the Libertarian Party, nor with the number of votes cast for libertarian candidates, which is probably a better indicator of libertarianism than joining the political party. So, I was puzzled. Who are these poor benighted libertarians who don�t even know that they are libertarian? How can it be that they�re out there, but those of us who value freedom and try to educate others as to the benefits of self-government don�t seem to find them in our travels? I found a clue to my conundrum on the Advocates for Self-Government web site. On the "Results" page of their famous quiz, I noticed this definition of libertarians: "Libertarians are self-governors in both personal and economic matters. They believe government's only purpose is to protect people from coercion and violence. They value individual responsibility, and tolerate economic and social diversity." That isn�t the definition I would choose. Several other clues presented themselves in the text of Boaz�s book titled Libertarianism: A Primer. In the first chapter, he states: "In the libertarian view, all human relationships should be voluntary; the only actions that should be forbidden by law are those that involve the initiation of force against those who have not themselves used force�actions like murder, rape, robbery, kidnapping, and fraud. Most people habitually believe in and live by this code of ethics" (pp.2-3). While this does define the non-aggression principle (which Boaz discusses later, under the name "nonaggression axiom"), the key element of this statement is in the words "habitually believe". Most people do agree that those actions are wrong, and avoid them. But that recognition is not equivalent to understanding the principle that makes them wrong. This is why many people who consider themselves honest don�t hesitate to pocket extra change from a clerk at a store. Because it�s habit to think of robbery in a limited context�someone with a weapon demanding money and jewelry�the failure to rectify a mistake is not seen as the theft that it is. The Libertarian Party�s web site was quite informative, as much as for what was there as what wasn�t. The introductory informational pages are warm and friendly, talking about the libertarian philosophy as "live and let live". While that�s one way to describe it, many libertarians would probably call that an oversimplification of the philosophy. Many people would say that that is their approach to living, but examination of their actions would demonstrate that they are anything but libertarian. On another page, a Gallup poll is described as showing that 20 percent of the American population is philosophically libertarian. There might be some justification in claiming that Americans are politically libertarian because of certain attitudes on specific issues, but to say that those individuals are philosophically libertarian is akin to trying to cross the Grand Canyon in one step. This leap clearly demonstrated the missing element from the Advocates for Self-Government�s and LP�s introductory information. The Non-Aggression Principle Where are the principles? More accurately, where is the principle? None of the pages I saw mentions what separates true libertarians from others who have similar positions on many issues: the non-aggression principle. Without the non-aggression principle, all the rest falls apart. That lack allows people to do the double-thinks that are all too common, and which contribute to many of the problems facing our society today. Many individuals, for example, might label themselves "socially tolerant," and call for certain government reforms. Yet many of these same people have no difficulty proposing government monitoring, or intervention in lifestyles or activities that they themselves do not engage in. One can find evidence of this even among today�s "liberals," in that they might grumble about laws which make consensual acts of intimacy between husbands and wives illegal, but have no qualms about circumscribing the private choices of smokers and hunters. Similarly, conservative "free marketeers" might advocate lifting of restraints and subsidies for domestic products, yet look to government to protect certain goods or industries from that dastardly monster, foreign competition. Someone cannot be "philosophically" anything until principles are considered, and taken as a basis for one�s life. Given the prevailing climate in today�s society, it�s apparent that many Americans do not take those steps. The blank-out on the non-aggression principle also means that individuals fail to make a crucial recognition about the legitimacy of governmental action. As was stated before, many people recognize that if they were to steal from another individual, it would be wrong. Yet, because the underlying principle�that initiating the use of force is always wrong�has not been considered, much less understood, these same individuals believe that it�s acceptable for local, state, and federal governments to forcibly take around one half of a person�s earnings through taxes and fees. The dubious justification often given�that the funds are needed to provide for our protection, as well as certain services the free market "can�t"�ignore the point, which is that a different standard is being applied to a large group of individuals, acting as the US Government, than to a single individual. For many individuals, it�s even more difficult to see another parallel: that of government intrusion into private lives and choices. It isn�t uncommon to hear a person declare that she wants government to keep its hands off her body when it comes to reproductive choices, yet she accepts without question the practice of mandated discrimination by hiring laws and quotas. Without a thorough understanding of the non-aggression principle and how it generalizes from one person to an entire society, from specific instances to a general way of being, all of the libertarian ideals become simple pragmatics. Self-government and individual responsibility are things that most humans would agree are virtues to be taught and maintained. They are practical. To most people, the idea of avoiding force conjures up images of weapons, threats, and arm-twisting of various sorts. There are better ways, most everyone agrees, to try to get someone�s cooperation. These are important ideas to understand and live by, but without a solid grounding in essentials, in what�s right and wrong for everyone, little "exceptions" start to creep in, or the magnitude of an action (such as the US government butting into another government�s affairs uninvited) masks that it�s wrong. Blurring the definition of libertarianism may make it seem that the number of individuals who truly value freedom is on the rise, yet what does that gain us? I submit that it actually hurts our cause, in several ways. It can give rise to a false sense of complacency among those who are truly libertarian, enabling us not to give our best effort in pursuit of freedom. It also includes in those numbers people who aren�t libertarian, and who probably never will be, because they see a government�s use of force as an acceptable means of regulating society. And for those individuals who don�t like the label libertarian (certain Objectivists come to mind), saying that they "don�t know it" or "are afraid" to identify themselves thusly is arrogant and insulting. Definitions like the Association for Self-Government�s seem to accept implicitly that some kind of government of some over others is necessary, and it alienates those who apply the non-aggression principle consistently, calling themselves anarchists (or anarcho-capitalists). Hiding the non-aggression principle in the fine print on a web site may make it easier to claim that more people are thinking like we do, but when nonlibertarians discover it, they�ll likely balk, because they haven�t been prepared for it. Principles matter. Especially in the realm of politics, one must be clear about why something is right or wrong. The non-aggression principle is the linchpin of the libertarian philosophy. We forget�or ignore�that at our own peril. References: Quotation from the Advocates for Self-Government web site: http://www.self-gov.org/results.shtml Boaz, David. Libertarianism: A Primer, published 1997 by The Free Press. Poll information from the Libertarian Party web site: http://www.lp.org/intro/Dasbach.html ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Sunni Maravillosa is a psychology professor, a writer, and the web mistress for the Liberty Round Table. -30- from The Laissez Faire City Times, Vol 3, No 13, March 29, 1999 ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Published by Laissez Faire City Netcasting Group, Inc. Copyright 1998 - Trademark Registered with LFC Public Registrar All Rights Reserved Disclaimer The Laissez Faire City Times is a private newspaper. Although it is published by a corporation domiciled within the sovereign domain of Laissez Faire City, it is not an "official organ" of the city or its founding trust. Just as the New York Times is unaffiliated with the city of New York, the City Times is only one of what may be several news publications located in, or domiciled at, Laissez Faire City proper. For information about LFC, please contact [EMAIL PROTECTED] ----- Aloha, He'Ping, Om, Shalom, Salaam. Em Hotep, Peace Be, Omnia Bona Bonis, All My Relations. Adieu, Adios, Aloha. Amen. Roads End Kris DECLARATION & DISCLAIMER ========== CTRL is a discussion and informational exchange list. Proselyzting propagandic screeds are not allowed. Substance�not soapboxing! These are sordid matters and 'conspiracy theory', with its many half-truths, misdirections and outright frauds is used politically by different groups with major and minor effects spread throughout the spectrum of time and thought. That being said, CTRL gives no endorsement to the validity of posts, and always suggests to readers; be wary of what you read. CTRL gives no credeence to Holocaust denial and nazi's need not apply. Let us please be civil and as always, Caveat Lector. ======================================================================== Archives Available at: http://home.ease.lsoft.com/archives/CTRL.html http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/ ======================================================================== To subscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email: SUBSCRIBE CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED] To UNsubscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email: SIGNOFF CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED] Om
