-Caveat Lector-

from:
http://www.zolatimes.com/V3.13/pageone.html
<A HREF="http://www.zolatimes.com/V3.13/pageone.html">Laissez Faire City Times
- Volume 3 Issue 13</A>
-----
The Laissez Faire City Times
March 29, 1999 - Volume 3, Issue 13
Editor & Chief: Emile Zola
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Pentium Pandemonium

by Don Lobo Tiggre


Gary Allen, author of a book called None Dare Call It Conspiracy,
postulates two possible views of history: either things happen by
accident, or by design. It is dangerous and na�ve to think that all the
evils that befall us are mere freaks of coincidence�there has to be a
conspiracy!

But these two choices are not the only ones: what if there are reasons
for the quasi-rhythmic stupidity of certain social phenomena, but those
reasons have little to do with the intentions of malignant men bent on
world domination? The current uproar over Intel�s new Pentium chip
provides a good case study on the question of conspiracy versus
spontaneous order.

In case you haven�t heard what all the fuss is about, Intel�s new
Pentium III processor�soon to be the heart of most new PCs�is made with
a unique identifying number burned into the chip. This is not something
imprinted on the plastic covering of the chip, but an electronically
accessible number built into every Pentium III chip Intel plans to make.
Or, as Intel puts it:

The Intel� processor serial number feature is embedded into the chip
during the manufacturing process of the Pentium� III processor. The
Intel� processor serial number serves as an identifier for the
processor, and, by association, its system.

Privacy advocates are concerned that the processor serial number (PSN)
can be called up by other computers over the internet, even without the
user of a tagged chip�s knowledge.

Why would Intel even think of doing something like this? Well, according
to their web site:

The increased use of the Internet for communications and electronic
commerce is raising PC users' concerns about the confidentiality and
integrity of transaction-oriented data. Since computers are the primary
connections to the Internet, they are a logical place for companies to
add security features. Over the next several years, Intel is adding
security building blocks in order to move the industry forward in
developing secure solutions for our customers�.

In business, Corporate I.T. departments can use it to track assets and
manage systems in a more efficient manner to help reduce total cost
ownership. For consumers, the potential of the Internet promises new
ways to shop online, manage their lives, and access and share
information. Used in combination with other identifiers such as
passwords and user names, hardware features such as processor serial
number can provide added levels of confidence.

This sounds pretty benign. Helping companies keep track of their
computer equipment and helping people do business over the internet is
good, isn�t it? However, many people are unhappy about the aid that
processor ID numbers could be to government agencies and pettier
criminals that have their own reasons for wanting to keep track of
people.

Not to worry, says Intel. When you buy the computer, the electronic ID
feature will be turned off, and you�ll have to turn it on yourself if
you want people to be able to ID you.

Not so quick, respond the cypherpunks and privacy advocates�if the
number�s there, it can be hacked!

The Permanent Cookie

To prove the point, an electronic privacy concern called Zero Knowledge
Systems (ZKS) posted to their web page something they call a Pentium III
Processor Serial Number Exploit. This little demonstration extracts the
ID number from your Pentium III chip, even if the ID feature is turned
off. If you have a Pentium III already, and you are using Microsoft
Internet Explorer (or Netscape Navigator with the optional ActiveX
plug-in installed), you can try it out yourself by going to
http://www.zks.net/p3.

According to ZKS: "This exploit proves that Intel's Pentium Serial
Number control utility offers no practical protection against hostile
code activating or stealing your serial number." In other words, it
shows that the PSN can put user�s privacy at great risk, even if the
user hasn�t turned it on. "The processor serial number can be used to
create a permanent cookie that tracks your every move on the Internet,
even if you erase your cookies regularly. This ability to track users'
browsing habits creates a serious potential for violation of privacy."

But it gets worse�even the legitimate purpose the PSNs are said to be
for is called into question: "If Web sites use the PSN to authenticate
users, a hacker could steal your serial number and pretend to be you at
E-commerce sites. Authentication devices that can be read and stolen as
easily as the PSN should not be trusted as methods to authenticate
users."

(Quick side note: If you already have a Pentium III, ZKS says you
should, "Make sure the Pentium III computer you own has a BIOS that
allows you to turn off the serial number. There is currently no known
way to read the serial number if you have disabled it in the BIOS.")

Given all of these problems, it is easy for those so inclined to
speculate that maybe the PSN wasn�t Intel�s idea after all�maybe the
government leaned on Intel to implement their nefarious ID scheme. After
all, it was recently revealed that some versions of Microsoft products
implant unique identifier numbers in documents created with them,
enabling all sorts of documents to be traced back to individual software
license holders. Between that and the Pentium III PSN, Big Brother�s job
just got a whole lot easier!

Now, it would certainly be consistent with the past record of some
government agencies to attempt to manipulate Intel and Microsoft into
helping them implement a tagging scheme. After all, some government
officials seem to regard the people as cattle that need the tender
regulation of whips and barbed wire. And who can prove that it isn�t so?
However, failure to disprove is not the same as proving, and there are
other possible explanations.

Spontaneous Order

One other explanation lies in the "spontaneous order" the Austrian
economists found at work in human action. You could call it the
invisible hand, as Adam Smith did, but Smith�s invisible hand (with a
firmer grip than Hari Seldon�s) only led the selfish actions of
profit-seeking individuals to produce the wealth of nations. Spontaneous
order is a bigger idea, of which the invisible hand can be viewed as
being just a particular instance. Evolution can be viewed as another
example of spontaneous order; the marvelous adaptations of living beings
and the effectiveness of other systems honed by evolutionary pressures
can make it look as though the results were planned. But they�re not;
they are the result of chaotic trial and error, contained by the laws of
physics, chemistry, and (for people) human psychology�whatever those
laws might be.

Spontaneous order tells us that if we take a step back and look at some
apparently chaotic systems from a great enough vantage point, we may see
patterns. It doesn�t guarantee that we�ll like all those patterns.
Smith�s benevolent hand may please us, but then there�s Buchanan�s
"rent-seeking behavior" to bedevil us (given our current political
environment). Ask the dinosaurs if they think evolution is benevolent.
Spontaneous order can be a many-edged sword.

If it wasn�t pressure from cloak-and-dagger types (like the NSA), what
"environment" caused these computer giants to takes such drastic steps
with such dire consequences for privacy, and hence possibly for liberty
itself?

How about: the profit motive of programmers.

You see, programmers work in a peculiar environment, similar to that of
authors, but even more precarious. They can work for years on something,
only to have a competitor or ungrateful user copy the work without
permission or compensation, all at the click of a button. This doesn�t
happen to a bricklayer, and it�s a relatively new problem in the human
environment. What to do?

Microsoft tries to contract individually with every user, and threaten
the bejesus out of anyone who violates the terms of the contract. Most
software manufacturers try similar approaches, with varying degrees of
success, but the problem remains. It�s just too easy for people to take
all that hard work and steal it or give it away, greatly reducing the
profits of programmers.

One prominent programmer, a fellow who even called himself a
libertarian, proposed a solution some years ago: pay-per-use. You have
the software available for download like shareware, but with built in
counters�like the boxes you plug into photocopiers at copy shops�that
periodically report back to the manufacturer for billing. This would
necessitate the creation of vast databases on the part of the
manufacturers to keep track of all users of their software (not just who
they were, but what they were using, how, and how often). When asked if
such databases wouldn�t endanger the privacy of users, the programmer
replied that, of course, steps would have to be taken to keep the
information out of the hands of the state.

Uh-huh.

So much for that idea� But the point here is that it is entirely
conceivable that Intel and Microsoft could have reasons of their own for
what they do. Microsoft might try to track down people using pirated
copies of their software for prosecution and Intel might have a problem
with employees pilfering chips from their plants. Cigarette
manufacturers keep track of every gram of tobacco that comes into and
goes out of their factories with the same care diamond mines keep track
of what goes into and comes out of their mines. Is it so surprising that
the computer industry should find similar security precautions
appealing?

This does not prove, of course, that there are no conspiracies. That is
not my intention. There certainly are many conspiracies among people
around the world�there sure seem to be a lot of them bubbling up in the
White House! But how likely is it that a small group of people can
really control this vast, surging, non-linear biomass we call humanity?

Occam�s Razor is merciless. It makes no sense to accept a more
complicated and improbable explanation when there is a simpler and more
likely one at hand.



------------------------------------------------------------------------
Don Lobo Tiggre is the author of Y2K: The Millennium Bug, a suspenseful
thriller. Tiggre can be found at the Liberty Round Table and The Liberty
Channel.

-30-

from The Laissez Faire City Times, Vol 3, No 13, March 29, 1999

------------------------------------------------------------------------
Published by
Laissez Faire City Netcasting Group, Inc.
Copyright 1998 - Trademark Registered with LFC Public Registrar
All Rights Reserved

Disclaimer
The Laissez Faire City Times is a private newspaper. Although it is
published by a corporation domiciled within the sovereign domain of
Laissez Faire City, it is not an "official organ" of the city or its
founding trust. Just as the New York Times is unaffiliated with the city
of New York, the City Times is only one of what may be several news
publications located in, or domiciled at, Laissez Faire City proper. For
information about LFC, please contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]
-----
Aloha, He'Ping,
Om, Shalom, Salaam.
Em Hotep, Peace Be,
Omnia Bona Bonis,
All My Relations.
Adieu, Adios, Aloha.
Amen.
Roads End
Kris

DECLARATION & DISCLAIMER
==========
CTRL is a discussion and informational exchange list. Proselyzting propagandic
screeds are not allowed. Substance�not soapboxing!  These are sordid matters
and 'conspiracy theory', with its many half-truths, misdirections and outright
frauds is used politically  by different groups with major and minor effects
spread throughout the spectrum of time and thought. That being said, CTRL
gives no endorsement to the validity of posts, and always suggests to readers;
be wary of what you read. CTRL gives no credeence to Holocaust denial and
nazi's need not apply.

Let us please be civil and as always, Caveat Lector.
========================================================================
Archives Available at:
http://home.ease.lsoft.com/archives/CTRL.html

http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/
========================================================================
To subscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SUBSCRIBE CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]

To UNsubscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SIGNOFF CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Om

Reply via email to