-Caveat Lector- from: http://www.socresonline.org.uk/socresonline/3/3/7.html <A HREF="http://www.socresonline.org.uk/socresonline/3/3/7.html">Stubbs: Conflict and Co-Operation in the Virtu </A> ----- Apc/Yugo/Anti-War: 'Pseudo- Democracy' in the East-West 'Contact Zone'? 4.1 As already stated, zamir became a member of the Association for Progressive Communications, a global organisation linking groups in many different countries who combine eMail use with the pursuit of peace, social justice, women's issues and, by far the largest group of members, ecology. There are a number of conferences which members can subscribe to, usually mixing discussion with information and reposting of relevant news items. The conference /APC/YUGO/ANTIWAR/, as its name suggests, is the principal vehicle for APC members to discuss actions against the wars in post-Yugoslav countries. Whilst, occasionally, messages are posted from outside the /APC/ family - this can be done when someone reads a message copied to more than one conference and replies to them all - it is mostly a forum in which peace activists from Western Europe and, to an extent, the United States, exchange messages with those in the region of the conflict. 4.2 As such, it is a prime example of what anthropologist James Clifford, quoting Mary Louise Pratt (Clifford, 1997: p. 192; Pratt, 1992), terms a 'contact zone' or 'the space in which peoples geographically and historically separated come into contact with each other and establish ongoing relations'. The term is particularly apposite because, in Pratt and Clifford's usage, formally equal relationships actually cover situations of 'radical inequality' and 'asymmetrical relations of power' (Clifford, 1997: p. 192). Moreover, these power relationships are never simply 'subject-object' or 'oppressor-victim' hierarchies, but are highly complex and mediated, related to 'real world' dynamics, but taking on their own specific cyberspace forms. 4.3 One example is the postings on /APC/YUGO/ANTIWAR/ during the Croatian Army actions in Western Slavonia, described above, and, more particularly, the days in early May 1995 when, for the first time in the wars, Zagreb was shelled by 'cluster bombs' which killed and injured many civilians. Partly as a result of the obviously shocking newsreel pictures shown around the world, many outsiders assumed that things were much worse in Zagreb than they actually were, and sought to repost information which was in fact obtainable elsewhere, thus making the conference rather tedious to read. A Zagreb ecological and anti-war activist, Zoran Ostric ([EMAIL PROTECTED]), treated the conference to his thoughts on all aspects of the war, the shelling of the city, the decor of the restaurant he sheltered in, and his mother's cooking (Ostric, 1995). Whilst actually praising Ostric, a German peace activist went on to suggest that YUGO/ANTIWAR was a 'total failure' ( Hardten, 1995a), stating that 'we are very disappointed about the level of critical discussion we find here in this board' (ibid.), and in a subsequent posting, even questioning whether Zagreb had really been shelled (Hardten, 1995b). 4.4 Others, such as the co-ordinator of the HR Net Debra Guzman ([EMAIL PROTECTED]), criticised these comments and expressed solidarity and support for activists in Zagreb. Far more instructive is a posting by Wam Kat, which could have been written with the notion of 'contact zones' in mind: Aggression never has been a good start to get people helping you, since in this case, you need something from us, although we also need something from you, solidarity, hope, and help, but that on the side line. Of course you can say: we are helping you with money, so help us with information. It would be a fair deal, would it. ... YUGO:ANTIWAR a TOTAL FAILURE it is nice to read, maybe you are right, but what is a TOTAL SUCCESS, remember it NEVER HAVE BEEN DONE BEFORE. Let's just give it a try, don't put your expectations too high. You, me, we, all of us, are responsible if it works or not. Let's be happy that we run this conference for such a long time without having major flame wars in it going on, something what can't be said about the regular INTERNET confer ences on the same topic. (Kat, 1995). 4.5 'Flame wars' are arguments in cyberspace which escalate out of control. Wam Kat here is clearly hinting at the complexities of the relationships between local activists and Western European erstwhile 'supporters'. There have been many points of tension in this relationship. The earliest were concerns by some from Slovenia and Croatia that the European peace movements played down repeated warnings about instability in Yugoslavia in the late 1980s, in part at least, because of their extensive connections with oppositionalists in Belgrade many of whom, by this time, were articulating nationalist ideas. Later, there was a clear disagreement about whether the use of military force, by the UN and subsequently NATO, was justifiable and/or useful. In addition, there we re always many civic positions, not least from different post-Yugoslav countries, so that it was unclear which should be supported. 4.6 However, these structuring debates are rarely explicitly discussed in the conference. Currently, most postings to the conference concern the situation in Kosova, reflecting the increased tension and renewed use of force by Milosevic in this predominantly Albanian, former autonomous, province. These are mostly news briefs from Kosova Albanian sources or repostings of news reports, so that there is little real debate or analysis about alternative civic solutions. In addition, a Croat living in the United States, where he is appealing against his asylum application being refused, Ivo Skoric ([EMAIL PROTECTED]; http://www.peacenet.org/balkans/ivo.htm), tends to fill the conference with his essays, some quite pertinent, others simply self-indulgent, on a wide range of issues, from corruption within the Croatian political elite, through support for independent media, to a long-running story about a parking fine he received in the US! The fact that anyone can post a text to an eMail conference, regardless of its content, is often seen as a progressive feature, given the narrowness of content which mainstream media carry. However, as Zoran Ostric's postings during the shelling of Zagreb, Ivo Skoric's postings and, indeed, the daily diary of Wam Kat which appeared on numerous conferences over a three year period, illustrate, the failure of particular users to ration their contributions, or to seek the advice of a good editor before pressing the 'send' button, is a rather lamentable side effect of the 'no censorship' position. 4.7 Unlike zamir which was, at least embryonically, a participatory democracy in the making, /APC/YUGO/ANTIWAR/ is far more of a 'pseudo-democracy'. The real civic dialogue is occurring elsewhere, in a large number of 'alternative Parliaments', 'citizen's assemblies', 'gras sroots conferences', and so on, which are sometimes advertised in the conference, but rarely reported on in a manner conducive to genuine feedback. There are a number of other eMail conferences and, more recently, Internet web pages, where those looking for information on civic opposition to the wars can go (for example http:www.igc.apc.org/balkans). However, the wasted potential of /APC/YUGO/ANTIWAR/, perhaps reflecting the wider problems of dialogue between civic groups regarding the wars, is a sad conclusion. Soc/Culture Newsgroups: 'Noise' from the Diaspora 5.1 Diasporic communities can be defined as groups separated physically from their 'homeland' but maintaining some kinds of intellectual, cultural, even spiritual, sense of belonging to it. In this sense, it is clear that new modes of global communication can facilitate a more active engagement of Diaspora in events 'back home', as 'separate places become effectively a single community' (Clifford, 1997: p. 246). Benedict Anderson, who noted the phenomenon of 'long-distance nationalism' in his seminal 'Imagined Communities' (Anderson, 1983), suggested in a later essay that transnational Diaspora were enabled to 'play identity politics by participating ... in the conflicts of ... (their) imagined Heimat - now only fax time away' (Anderson, 1992: p. 13). Whilst it is difficult to envisage the fax machine having this effect, other media such as satellite tv, videos (cf. Kolar-Panov, 1997), and eMail, are certainly important in this context. 5.2 The role of various Diaspora in the wars of the Yugoslav succession is not well covered by political accounts of the break-up, despite the existence of large 'Croat' and 'Serb' populations in the United States, Australia, Canada, and elsewhere. Certainly, the connection between new national movements within Croatia, and aspects of the Diaspora which had been courted explicitly from the mid-1980s onwards, including massive funding for Franjo Tudjman's party HDZ and, later, the return of Canadian pizza millionaire Gojko Susak as Minister of Defence in the independent Croatia, should not be understated. Even so this is not, as popularly argued in some anti-nationalist circles, a simple reconnection of primitive, frozen, nationalism with a new national movement (cf. Kaldor, 1996), but is a much more complex process of identity formation incorporating both 'old' and 'new' elements, and resonating differently in different places, with different age groups, levels of education, and so on (Kolar-Panov, 1997; Skrbis, 1995). To quote Clifford again, 'whatever their ideologies of purity, Diasporic cultural forms can never, in practice, be exclusively nationalist' (Clifford, 1997: p. 251 ). 5.3 Looking closely at the interventions of Diaspora in two eMail discussion groups, /SOC/CULTURE/CROATIA and /SOC/CULTURE/YUGOSLAVIA/, could lead one to reject Clifford's strictures, however. The /SOC/CULTURE/ newsgroups, on Usenet, are very popular conferences containing, as their name suggests, items of cultural, political, and social significance regarding a particular country. Whilst, many postings are from a hard core of in- country or out-of-country respondents, there is usually a fair smattering of tourism and travel related enquiries and advice. The two conferences, and to a lesser extent /SOC/CULTURE/BOSNIA/, are marked by a smaller range of frequent posters, usually members of the Diaspora and, often, university students in the United States. A typical week will find many of the same 'threads' in both the Croatia and Yugoslavia conferences, with a large number of crosspostings, similar to that noted in a recent review of SOC/CULTURE/INDIA and related newsgroups (Mitra, 1997). The post-Yugoslav conferences have fewer postings than Mitra's conferences, but display the same characteristics of divisive conflict, and most often consist of a series of statements and counter statements, together with mutual name-calling, in which either Chetnik or Ustase crimes from the Second World War are judged to be of continuing relevance to contemporary events. 5.4 These conferences are available to members of zamir, although I know of few users who subscribed for very long, unless undertaking a piece of research. Nevertheless, some zamir-based groups have copied their analyses and reports to these conferences. Usually, these stand alone and are ignored although, occasionally, as when the Croatian branch of the Balkan Peace Team, Otvorene Oci, posted their report of a visit to Knin, then the 'capital' of the self-styled 'Republic of Serbian Krajina' ('RSK'), which was well- meant and set out an important, if contentious, position, the public and private response was extreme. Indeed, the eMail address used, that of one of the team members, was bombarded with eMails which, effectively, amounted to death threats. The widespread use of crude nationalist invective, by users who appear in many other respects to be 'normal' citizens - many 'footers' (id entification markers at the end of an eMail) suggest successful business people or students of science and technology - is a phenomenon certainly worthy of further exploration. 5.5 Recent exchanges following the death of Gojko Susak are typical of the genre, not least for the absence of any real argument, beyond that of repetitious assertion of 'the truth': The death of the Republic of Croatia's Minister of Defence, Gojko Susak, and his vital role in Croatia's fight for independence should be remembered by future generations of Croatians as the United States today still remembers and honors the memory of its Revolutionary War Generals, Nathaniel Greene and Henry Knox ... The fact that Croatia had its own history, language, culture and identity from the ninth century provided, in addition to its right to freedom and sovereignty, even more justification for a 'nationalist' like Susak than 'nationalists' like Greene and Knox. ... ('Susak Like U.S. Revolutionary War Generals', eMail from [EMAIL PROTECTED] in SOC/CULTURE/CROATIA, 5 May 1998) The Nazi War Criminal Gojko Susak is dead and burning in Hell. The man who helped resurrect Croatia's Nazi Ustasha past never got to stand trial for war crimes against humanity at the Hague. He now stands before a higher judge. Susak will be remembered in the press and in history as the racist, neo- Nazi leader who helped exterminate Croatia's minority Serb community. A born Ustasha, Susak openly praised Croatia's horrific Nazi past when in WWII the country was one of Hitler's greatest allies. Today's Nazi Croatia is neither democratic nor free. Susak's brand of hate is today being taught to a new generation of Croat youth - a pure hate which does not tolerate anything non-Croat. That is Susak's legacy to the world. ('War Criminal Susak Dead', eMail from [EMAIL PROTECTED] in SOC/CULTURE/CROATIA, 5 May 1998). So miracles do happen after all. More than 30,000 dead Serbs, and still they are marching back to Ustasha state of Croatia. What urges them to go back? were they born Ustashe as Gojko Susak too. ('Re: War Criminal Susak Dead', eMail from [EMAIL PROTECTED] in SOC/CULTURE/CROATIA, 5 May 1998). It's quite simple. We do not live in 1941, so today's Croatian Ustase do not have freedom to commit such genocide as they were. Secondly, some people like their homes that much that they can't live without them and because of that, they would accept living in a nasty racist state. ('Re: War Criminal Susak Dead', eMail from [EMAIL PROTECTED] in SOC/CULTURE/CROATIA, 6 May 1998). Dead is the creator victorious army that swept chetniks into garbage can of history, but his acomplishments live forever. May eternal glory be with him! ('Re: Susak Dead', eMail from [EMAIL PROTECTED] in SOC/CULTURE/CROATIA, 6 May 1998). 5.6 One feature which is noteworthy in these, and the majority of similar messages, is that the English language is used, although most of the writers probably have Croatian/Serbian language skills. The first message seeks explicit comparison with the United States' War of Independence, which also indicates that the authors are seeking to have a wider influence. There are few other signs of 'openness', in the sense of participating in a debate, about these messages, however. Indeed, one other reply, to the second posting, simply quotes part of the message and then states: 'An old Serbian saying: "Say the lie twice and it will become the truth."'. Statements such as 'we do not live in 1941' could, of course, lead to an interesting and illuminating discussion on the pertinent differences between then and now but, of course, they do not. Indeed, by explicitly responding to a question, and breaking the code which states that 'then' and 'now' are identical or homologous moments, this posting is unusual. 5.7 The two /SOC/CULTURE/ conferences are more of a 'noise', then, in the sense that the threads go nowhere other than into and against themselves in a series of endless repetitions. The space, presumably, exists for an explicit challenge to this dominant framework but, to my knowledge, this has not been systematically attempted, from within zamir or elsewhere. It is as if a group of people with a particular position have, also, not unlike other eMail groups, found their virtual home and are happy in the acrimonious exchange of ideologies. Conclusions: Trust, Social Capital and the Maintenance of Virtual Communities 6.1 In assessing the lessons from the three case studies, my own explicit ideological and political commitment to the zamir network clearly informs what follows. However, I hope to have shown that zamir is most effective as part of a localised repertoire of counter hegemonic meanings. As soon as zamir meets a wider discourse, that of the peace movements in Western Europe and North America, in the /APC/YUGO/ANTIWAR/ conference, some of its critical edge is lost. The conference shows, acutely, the difficulty of constructing a peace discourse in a wider are na marked by radical asymmetry of power and of understanding. Real debates are doubly removed from the conference - in terms of both the formal, top-down, political level, and the oppositional, civic, voice. The latter is, therefore, by no means as democratic, or process-oriented, as it appears. 6.2 The 'noise' from nationalist discourses in the /SOC/CULTURE/ conferences, clearly mitigates against any meaningful debate. I last subscribed to the conference in 1995 but, resubscribing to gather material for this paper, I was struck by the essential sameness of the postings, and of the people who posted. Perhaps in some ways, with some notable exceptions, the same could be said for zamir and, certainly, for /APC/YUGO/ANTIWAR/. In a sense, this is the profound problem about all of the eMail conferences on the wars: they depend upon, and themselves construct, a notion of fixed positions, in which the professed and profound 'anti-nationalism' of some conferences becomes weakened by being little more than a mirror image of the nationalism, no less assured, of others. 6.3 As Maja Povrzanovic, in a series of perceptive essays, has argued (cf. Povrzanovic, 1993a; 1993b), such fixed categorisations are unhelpful when discussing the shifting concerns of ordinary people and, indeed, intellectuals, in war conditions. In terms of the conferences discussed above, there seems to be no place for the profane, the dubious, the dou bting, or the simply confused - into which categories most of the population, even most of the eMail using population, probably fall, at least some of the time. For all its post-modern apparel, then, eMail may be revealed as the last refuge of a peculiarly modernist discourse and politics. 6.4 I would suggest that one way of developing a framework for discussing eMail conferences in times of conflict would involve a reassessment of work on forms of trust or what Putnam has termed 'social capital' defined as 'features of social organization such as networks, norms and social trust that facilitate co-ordination and co-operation for mutual benefit' (Putnam, 1995: p. 67). As Putnam defines it, social capital is clearly meant to be a 'public good', existing in a series of virtuous circles as trust builds upon trust, in contrast to Bourdieu's concept of 'cultural capital' (cf. Bourdieu, 1984), which is far more fractured, individualistic and defined through indefinable competition (in which someone is allowed to say: 'I have it, you don't'). 6.5 For me, both 'cultural' and 'social capitals' exist at very different levels, from the small group, through the nation state, to the global level. Indeed, elsewhere, I have made much of the ways in which the fashion for particular kinds of NGO networking has done little more than perpetuate the 'global cultural capital' accumulation of a group I have defined as the 'new globalised professional middle-class' (cf. Stubbs, 1997b; 1997c). This may be too cynical and pessimistic a position to hold, however. The conversion of cultural capital accumulation into social capital, or general trust and co- operation, is likely to be a much longer-term process than I have previously suggested. I would continue to assert, however, that this move from 'the cultural' to 'the social' is far more likely at local levels than at global levels, and also requires a degree of openness, inclusivity, and commitment to articulating alternative common sense, and being heard, within the wider community. 6.6 It is certainly the case that, within any of the post-Yugoslav countries in conflict, outside support for particular kinds of 'anti-nationalist' discourses have, at best, had little wider effect and, at worst, have been used by dominant forces to spread mistrust of any such movement. This is the greatest problem with Turmir's optimism regarding the 'distributive and emancipatory' claims of cultural capital within the globalisation process. The idea that eMail, to be an effective tool, should be one part of a localised battle for hearts and minds is a radical challenge to current understandings and suggests that globalisation processes cannot be assumed to operate linearly. References ANDERSON, B. (1983) Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origins and Spread of Nationalism. Verso: London. ANDERSON, B. (1992) 'The New World Disorder', New Left Review, no. 193, pp. 3 - 13. APPADURAI, A. (1990) 'Disjuncture and Difference in the Global Cultural Economy' in M. Featherstone (editor) Global Culture: Nationalism, Globalisation and Modernity. Sage: London. BACHMANN, E. (1994) 'Zana-PR in Wonderland', Koha, 1994. BOURDIEU, P. (1984) Distinction: A Social Critique of the Judgement of Taste. Harvard University Press. BPT_BG, (Balkan Peace Team) (1997) 'Protests in Belgrade, FRY', eMail to /APC/YUGO/ANTIWAR, 5 February 1997. BRESLOW, H. (1997) 'Civil Society, Political Economy and the Internet' in S. Jones (editor) Virtual Culture: Identity and Communication in Cyberspace. Sage: London. BUFFONI, L. (1997) 'Rethinking Poverty in Globalized Conditions' in J. Eade (editor) Living the Global City: Globalization as a Local Process. Routledge: London. CALE FELDMAN, L. (editor) Fear, Death and Resistance: An Ethnography of War, Croatia 1991-1992. Institute of Ethnology and Folklore Research: Zagreb. CASTELLS, M. (1996) The Rise of the Network Society. Blackwell: Oxford. CLIFFORD, J. (1988) The Predicament of Culture. Harvard University Press: London. CLIFFORD, J. (1997) Routes: Travel and Translation in the Late Twentieth Century. Harvard University Press: Cambridge, Mass. DEACON, B., STUBBS, P. and SOROYA, B. (1994) 'Globalisation, Post-Communism and Social Policy: Issues in Croatia', Croatian Journal of Social Policy, vol. 1, no. 4. DEMIROVIC, A. (1996) 'NGOs: Social Movements in Global Order?', paper presented to the American Sociological Association Annual Conference, (New York, August 1996). DIETRICH, D. (1997) '(Re)-Fashioning the Techno-Erotic Woman: Gender and Textuality in the Cybercultural Matrix' in S. Jones (editor) Virtual Culture: identity and communication in cyberspace. Sage: London. DVORNIK, S. (1994) Interview with the Author, November 1994. EADE, J. (1997) 'Introduction' in J. Eade (editor) Living the Global City: Globalization as a Local Process. Routledge: London. FERNBACK, J. (1997) 'The Individual within the Collective: Virtual Ideology and the Realisation of Collectivist Principles' in S. Jones (editor) Virtual Culture: Identity and Communication in Cyberspace. Sage: London. FRANCISSEN, L. and Brants, K. (1998) 'Virtually Going Places: Square-Hopping in Amsterdam's Digital City' in R. Tsagarousianou (editor) Cyberdemocracy: Technology, Cities and Civic Networks. Routledge: London. GEERZ, C. (1988) Works and Lives: The Anthropologist as Author. Stanford University Press: Stanford. HABERMAS, J. (1994) 'The Emergence of the Public Sphere' in The Polity Reader in Cultural Theory. Polity: London. HARDTEN, E. (1995a) 'YUGO/ANTIWAR - TOTAL FAILURE', eMail to /APC/YUGO/ANTIWAR, 3 May 1995. HARDTEN, E. (1995b) 'Zagreb under shelling?', eMail to /APC/YUGO/ANTIWAR, 4 May 1995. JALUSIC, V. (1994) 'Troubles with Democracy: Women and Slovene Independence' in J. Benderley and E. Kraft (editors) Independent Slovenia. St Martin's Press: New York. JONES, S. (1997) 'The Internet and its Social Landscape' in S. Jones (editor) Virtual Culture: Identity and Communication in Cyberspace. Sage: London. KALDOR, M. (1996) 'Cosmopolitanism versus Nationalism: The New Divide?' in R. Caplan and T. Feffer (editors) Europe's New Nationalism: States and Minorities in Conflict. Oxford University Press: Oxford. KAT, W. (1993) 'Introduction to the Zagreb Diary', Arkzin, December 1993. KAT, W., 'And Now Something Completely Different', eMail to /APC/YUGO/ANTIWAR, 6 May 1995. KOLAR-PANOV, D. (1997) Video, War and the Diasporic Imagination. Routledge: London. LARGE, J. (1997) The War Next Door: A Study of Second-Track Intervention during the War in ex-Yugoslavia. Hawthorn Press: Stroud. MAGAS, B. (1993) The Destruction of Yugoslavia: Tracing the Breakup 1980-1992. Verso: London. MITRA, A. (1997) 'Virtual Community: Looking for India on the Internet', in S. Jones (editor) Virtual Culture: Identity and Communication in Cyberspace. Sage: London. OSTRIC, Z. (1995) 'Re: Zagreb Under Shelling' 5 eMails to /APC/YUGO/ANTIWAR, 3 May 1995. POVRZANOVIC, M. (1993a) '"New Ethnography" in the Situation of Radical Cultural Change: Croatia 1991-1992', Journal of Area Studies, no. 3, pp. 161 - 168. POVRZANOVIC, M. (1993b) 'Ethnography of a War: Croatia 1991-1992', The Anthropology of East Europe Review, vol. 11, nos. 1 - 2, pp. 138 - 148. PRATT, M. (1992) Imperial Eyes: Travel Writing and Transculturation. Routledge: London. PUGH, M., 'Post-Conflict Rehabilitation: The Humanitarian Dimension', paper to be presented to the Third International Security Forum, (Zurich, 19 - 21 October, 1998). PUTNAM, R. (1995) 'Bowling Alone: America's Declining Social Capital', Journal of Democracy, vol. 6, no. 1, pp. 65 - 78. RHEINGOLD, H., (1993) The Virtual Community: Homesteading on the Electronic Frontier. Addison Wesley: Reading, MA. SCHMIDTKE, O. (1998) 'Berlin in the Net: Prospects for Cyberdemocracy >From Above and From Below' in R. Tsagarousianou (editor) Cyberdemocracy: Technology, Cities and Civic Networks. Routledge: London. SCHMITZ, J. (1997) 'Structural Relations, Electronic Media, and Social Change: The Public Electronic Network and the Homeless' in S. Jones (editor) Virtual Culture: Identity and Communication in Cyberspace. Sage: London. SILBER, L. and LITTLE, A. (1995) The Death of Yugoslavia. Penguin: London. STUBBS, P. (1996) 'Creative Negotiations: Concepts and Practice of Integration of Refugees, Displaced Persons and Local Communities in Croatia' in R. Jambresic Kirin and M. Povrzanovic (editors) War, Exile, Everyday Life: Cultural Perspectives. Zagreb: Institute for Ethnology and Folklore Research. STUBBS, P. (1997a) Social Reconstruction and Social Development in Croatia and Slovenia: The Role of the NGO Sector . Leeds Metropolitan University: ISPRU Occasional Papers in Social Studies, no. 7. STUBBS, P. (1997b) 'NGO Work with Forced Migrants in Croatia: Lineages of a Global Middle Class?, International Peacekeeping, vol. 4, no. 4, pp. 50 - 60. STUBBS, P. (1997c) 'Heretical Thoughts on NGOism, Uncle George, and the "New Feudalism"', Arkzin, no. 2, pp. 38 - 39. SKRBIS, Z. (1995) 'Long Distance Nationalism? Second Generation Croatians and Slovenians in Australia' in A. Pavkovic (editor) Nationalism and Post-Communism. Dartmouth: Dartmouth Press. THOMPSON, M. (1992) A Paper House: The Ending of Yugoslavia. Hutchinson: London. TSAGAROUSIANOU, R. (editor) (1998) Cyberdemocracy: Technology, Cities and Civic Networks. Routledge: London. TURMIR, V. (1998) Techno-Activism and Post-Nationalism: The Case of ex-Yugoslavia. Mimeo, Institute of Language and Culture, Humber College: Toronto, Canada. WATSON, N. (1997) 'Why We Argue About Virtual Community: A Case Study of the phish.net Fan Community' in S. Jones (editor) Virtual Culture: Identity and Communication in Cyberspace. Sage: London. Copyright Sociological Research Online, 1998 ----- Aloha, He'Ping, Om, Shalom, Salaam. Em Hotep, Peace Be, Omnia Bona Bonis, All My Relations. Adieu, Adios, Aloha. Amen. Roads End Kris DECLARATION & DISCLAIMER ========== CTRL is a discussion and informational exchange list. Proselyzting propagandic screeds are not allowed. Substance�not soapboxing! These are sordid matters and 'conspiracy theory', with its many half-truths, misdirections and outright frauds is used politically by different groups with major and minor effects spread throughout the spectrum of time and thought. That being said, CTRL gives no endorsement to the validity of posts, and always suggests to readers; be wary of what you read. CTRL gives no credeence to Holocaust denial and nazi's need not apply. Let us please be civil and as always, Caveat Lector. ======================================================================== Archives Available at: http://home.ease.lsoft.com/archives/CTRL.html http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/ ======================================================================== To subscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email: SUBSCRIBE CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED] To UNsubscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email: SIGNOFF CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED] Om
