-Caveat Lector-

from:
http://www.socresonline.org.uk/socresonline/3/3/7.html
<A HREF="http://www.socresonline.org.uk/socresonline/3/3/7.html">Stubbs:
Conflict and Co-Operation in the  Virtu
</A>
--[1]--

Paul Stubbs (1998) 'Conflict and Co-Operation in the Virtual Community:
eMail and the Wars of the Yugoslav Succession'
Sociological Research Online, vol. 3, no. 3,
<http://www.socresonline.org.uk/socresonline/3/3/7.html>

To cite articles published in Sociological Research Online, please
reference the above information and include paragraph numbers if
necessary

Received: 4/6/98      Accepted: 28/9/98      Published: 30/9/98



Abstract

This article focuses on the use of computer-mediated communication (CMC)
during the wars of the Yugoslav succession, through three case studies
of particular eMail networks, discussion groups and bulletin boards:
zamir; APC/Yugo/Antiwar; and the Soc/Culture/Croatia and
Soc/Culture/Yugoslavia newsgroups. The text addresses the relationship
between 'real' and 'virtual' communities and looks, in particular, at
the role of eMail as a tool for social, political and cultural change.
Despite the rhetoric of CMC as an inherently liberating and democrat
ising medium, the suggestion is that power relations remain crucial in
understanding all of the case studies. eMail may be most effective when
part of a local discourse and practice of social change. The article
concludes with a consideration of the link between different kinds of
trust, or social capital, within the eMail world.

------------------------------------------------------------------------
Keywords:
Activism; Conflict; Co-Operation; Email; Post-Yugoslav Countries

------------------------------------------------------------------------
Introduction


1.1
The Gulf War of 1991 may have been the first 'war by computer' as CNN
viewers, spared the horrors of real carnage, were able to marvel at the
pinpoint accuracy of sophisticated computerised weaponry. The wars of
the Yugoslav succession from 1991 are, perhaps, the first 'wars with
computers' in which reactions to a real war were multiplied immensely by
the possibilities of new communications technology, computer-mediated
communication (CMC), or popularly, cyberspace. A definition of
cyberspace, from a sociological perspective, is 'a realm of
computer-based communication processes that is completely decoupled from
the need to meet physically' (Schmidtke, 1998: p. 81). This paper is an
initial attempt to theorise and reflect upon the role of such 'virtual
communities', through case studies of different electronic mail (eMail)
groups and networks, in a time of conflict. The suggestion is that many
of the concepts used to understand spatially defined communities are
also applicable to globally dispersed eMail communities. Speaking
sociologically, then, there is a need to amend some of the core concepts
around conflict and co-operation, but not to jettison them, in order to
 understand the eMail phenomenon during the wars.

1.2
This article seeks to look, in general terms, at the similarities and
differences between 'virtual' and 'real' communities, at the importance
of power relations on-line, and at the possibility that eMail is a 'new
public sphere'. It examines some core theoretical constructs from the
extant literature, and looks at specific examples from the region of
post-Yugoslav countries. Three case studies in the eMail war are
addressed in detail: the zamir network; the APC/Yugo/Antiwar discussion
group; and the Soc/Culture/Croatia and Soc/Culture/Yugoslavia discussion
groups. These case studies seek to illuminate issues of conflict and
co-operation and also wider social issues in the use of eMail during a
war.

1.3
The case studies are followed by a return to theoretical considerations
and, in particular, an analysis of the significance of the material
presented for understanding the role of 'social capital' in the making
of communities, both virtual and real. To read the essay does not
require of the reader any in-depth computer knowledge - all terms and
the specifics of the technology are explained insofar as they are
important to the argument and insofar as I understand them. However, it
does require some understanding of the nature and dynamics of the wars,
since to digress in order to contextualise fully some of the examples
used would take far too much space (for useful introductions cf.
Thompson, 1992; Magas, 1993; Silber and Little, 1995).

1.4
The article reflects my active involvement in a range of civil,
cultural, and political initiatives in Croatia and Bosnia- Herzegovina,
all of which, directly or indirectly, are reproduced in cyberspace
discussions. By October 1994, being based in the School of Social Work
at the University of Zagreb which had very few computer resources, I had
purchased a new lap top computer and a modem. This, combined with
sharing a Zagreb flat with one of the key proponents of eMail in
Croatia, allowed me to link up with the zamir network, of which I remain
a member. From then on, my concern with how to use eMail politically,
grew apace, as did my interventions in various discussion groups, some
of which are noted below.

1.5
Notwithstanding Clifford's recent suggestion that 'monitoring' eMail
discussion groups can be a form of anthropological 'fieldwork' (
Clifford, 1997; pp. 57 - 58), the article makes no claims to be
research-based in the sense of systematically gathering information for
the case studies. My computer remains full of texts posted on zamir and
on APC/Yugo/Antiwar and, remembering certain key dates, themes, issues,
and postings, I simply looked through my archives to pick them out. Some
texts were missing, others retained the capacity to 'surprise' and
disrupt my expectations, but many were, more or less, as I had r
emembered them. I resubscribed to Soc/Culture/Croatia and
Soc/Culture/Yugoslavia for a brief period in May 1998, and chose to
examine texts relating to one particular theme which dominated at that
time. In a sense, then, the article is less sociological research than
an intervention in the field of cultural politics, reflecting my wider
concern with the nature and dynamics of 'social praxis', or the attempt
'to produce reflexive, and useful knowledge, linked to, and indeed
breaking down somewhat, the distinction between 'theory' and 'practice'
(Stubbs, 1996: p. 32).

1.6
As appropriate for a text about electronic communication for
'publication' in an electronic journal, there are many hypertext links
to eMail addresses and Web sites incorporated in this on-line version.
However, as many authors have noted, hypertext does not lend itself to
the forms of citation which are most often utilised in print published
academic discourse. The links in the text may be to documents which have
changed locations or be irretrievable currently, and to eMail addresses
which have also changed or whose users have ceased to be traceable. As
Jones has suggested, the 'ever-shifting dynamics of the medium' may,
indeed, make it one that is 'out of control' (Jones, 1997: p. 28), or
seemingly so, in the longer term. However, the text is written so as to
be entirely comprehensible without the links and addresses although, at
the time of revising this text for publication, in early September 1998,
all the links were, in fact, accurate and operational. I have also used
plain ASCII text which means that some words in the languages of the
post-Yugoslav countries which contain characters specific to these
languages have been altered to their closest plain text equivalents.
Conceptualising the Virtual Community


2.1
The rapid growth of computer- mediated communication has produced an
increasingly significant body of print published work seeking to explore
the social implications of the new technology. Three core sociological
concepts, long debated and contested in line with different theoretical
and political approaches - those of 'community', 'power', and 'the
public sphere' - are discussed extensively in this literature and all
are pertinent to the topic of the role of eMail in the wars of the
Yugoslav succession. In this section, I explore each of these concepts
in turn.
Community


2.2
Whether eMail and Internet users form a 'community' has been the
principal preoccupation of most sociological on-line theorists.
Rheingold's seminal approach to the question contains within it a number
of assumptions which merit further exploration:
Virtual communities are social aggregations that emerge from the Net
when enough people carry on ... public discussions long enough, with
sufficient human feeling, to form webs of personal relationships in
cyberspace. (Rheingold, 1993: p. 5).

2.3
In this quote, Rheingold seems to be suggesting that some CMC
interactors constitute a community and others do not - hence virtual
communities rather than the singular term 'virtual community'. The
popularisation of the phrase 'virtual community' by his book is, in
fact, part of the problem as Watson has recently argued:

2.4
The distinction between 'virtual' community and 'real' community is
unwarranted. The term 'virtual' means something akin to 'unreal'. ... My
experience has been that people in the offline world tend to see online
communities as virtual, but the participants in the online communities
see them as quite real. (Watson, 1997: p. 129).

2.5
The debate takes on a new significance in the context of wider
discussions about globalisation processes which appear to compress both
time and space, themselves, at least in part, social constructs. EMail
and Internet are examples of this par excellence so that it is tempting
to see their use as the harbinger of a new transnational community not
fixed spatially. It is certainly true that a computer, a modem and a
telephone line are requirements to participate in eMail communication
and, therefore, to be capable of linking with tens of millions of others
all over the world. Moreover, none of these, in the age of lab tops,
PCMCIA cards (functioning as portable modems), and mobile phones, are
fixed spatially.

2.6
However, the relationship between new technologies and space is not as
simple as it first appears. Without a server or host (the terms convey
their technological and literal meanings), through which one's messages
are sent and others received, and to which one must join and register in
some way, there is no consistent access to the web of relationships
which is eMail and the Internet. Interestingly, most people are linked
to a server or host in the same geographical space, locally or at the
very least, nationally, which they themselves occupy. The main reason
for this is simple and concerns the low cost of local telephone calls as
against the prohibitive costs of international calls as well as ease of
registration, and so on. Many eMail addresses, indeed, specify not only
the name of the host server but, also, the country in which it is
located, with a globally recognised nomenclature for this: hu is
Hungary, ba Bosnia, si Slovenia, hr Croatia, and so on. In the zamir
 network discussed below, servers were indicated by their cities (zg is
Zagreb, sa Sarajevo, bg Belgrade, tz Tuzla, pr Pristina, and so on) as,
perhaps, a counter to this nation state fixedness. Indeed, the 'ztn' in
the address, lest we should have any doubts about the intentions of its
founders, stands for zamir transnational network. However, even in these
cases, the spatial fixedness of the server, and by extension usually,
the user, is assured within this nomenclature.

2.7
Similarly, questions of time remain highly complex in terms of eMail
discussions. Although there is an increasing interest in on-line
conferencing, or chat lines, in which the discussion happens live, as it
were, most eMail conferences and discussion groups remain diachronic
forms of communication rather than synchronic, in contrast to 'real'
conferences. Once an eMail user signs up for a conference, then she or
he is able to read all the messages sent to it by other subscribers, and
any messages she or he writes, unless the user specifies otherwise, also
reach all subscribers. Of course, not only are there differences in
global time zones but the time it takes for your message to reach others
depends on a number of factors: how often you and they make a netcall
(dialling your server to receive new messages), and how fast the
transfer between servers is. This means that whilst you may think you
are the first to reply to someone, when you complete your netcall, you
find that several others have beaten you to it and the thread you wished
to pursue has been lost.

2.8
In short, there are certain specifics of CMC which mean that space and
time are not, completely, transcended. This does not, of course, rule
out the possibility that eMail users can be constituted as a community.
Indeed, it may be far more useful to reframe the question about whether
particular eMail groups are or are not a community, and discuss,
instead, the complex identities which users present online and offline,
and the ways in which eMail participation satisfies some of their needs
for sociability, some of the time. All three of the case studies, in
part at least, gather together persons who share an interest in a
particular topic, being discussion groups which act as virtual meeting
places for those concerned, in some way, with the fate of former Yugosl
avia. Nevertheless, as we shall see, the nature of the interactions
within them are very different.
Power


2.9
Questions of power relations refer to who has access to the new
information technology and how interactions on-line relate to power
off-line. In terms of access, it remains true that most, although not
all, servers are commercially-oriented, for profit organisations,
charging membership fees and, often, also an on-line charge over and
above the cost of the telephone connection. Compared to the 'set up'
costs, of a computer, modem, and telephone line, this is unlikely to be
a major prohibitive factor limiting access. Nevertheless, the growth of
non-profit servers which subsidise users through the grants they receive
(zamir in post-Yugoslav countries and zpok in Hungary are examples of
these), does indicate an increasing awareness of the social limits to
the technology.

2.10
The virtual community is far from open and accessible to all. The growth
of internet cafes is a commercial exploitation of the wish of increasing
numbers of people to have eMail and internet access, or at least to 'try
it out', and there is also a growth of free public providers: in Central
and Eastern Europe these are usually funded by the Open Society
Foundation, and increasingly in some Western European cities they are
funded by the local city administration to promote 'cyberdemocracy' (
Tsagarousianou et al, 1998). Nevertheless, it remains true that most
users of eMail and internet are relatively young, relatively well
educated, read or speak some English, and are overwhelmingly male.
Reviewing a wide range of studies of internet use, Manuel Castells has
suggested:
CMC starts as the medium of communication for the most educated and
affluent segment of the population of the most educated and affluent
countries, and more often than not in the largest and most sophisticated
metropolitan areas. (Castells, 1996: p. 360).

2.11
His phrasing is important, denying total closure, and anticipating a
relative democratisation of access as the medium expands, but suggesting
that these early elites continue to hold power and tend to frame the
future direction of CMC as it becomes more widely available. His image
of a 'revolution of concentric waves' (Castells, 1996: p. 360) unable to
reach large segments of the population in the West and the vast majority
of people in poor countries, is a salutary one. It should also not be
forgotten that the first wave of CMC use was military-industrial and not
leisure based, much less designed to be socially useful, and its role in
restructuring industrial enterprises and the ways in which work can be
imagined, are legion (Breslow, 1997). Castells argues that the history
of CMC has been about the competing visions of 'the military/science
establishment' and 'the personal computing counterculture' (Castells,
1996: p. 355), with these two different sets of users continuing to
diverge sharply. In addition, whilst the global social effects of CMC
may well be 'the reinforcement of the culturally dominant social
networks' and 'the social cohesion of the cosmopolitan elite' (Castells,
1996: pp. 363 - 364), this does not preclude the possibility of
localised uses of the medium which are far more progressive.

2.12
The idealistic suggestion that eMail interactions, because of their
relative anonymity and the 'paucity of electronic cues' (Schmitz, 1997:
p. 85), provide more of a level playing field in terms of power
relations, compared to face-to-face interactions, has been rigorously
critiqued on a variety of grounds. There are even suggestions that
technological innovation demands new sets of 'capabilities' and may
widen the gap between the CMC 'haves' and 'have nots' (Buffoni, 1997:
pp. 114 - 5). Certainly, eMail use demands relatively high levels of
linguistic, textual and word processing competencies, even though its
standards of typographical exactitude are, certainly, less than those of
much print published communication. In the absence of face-to-face cues
for stereotyping, participants in some eMail discussion groups may,
indeed, overcompensate in their disapproval of misspellings, clumsy
formatting, or messages which go wrong in some way because the user has
not (yet) grasped the fine detail of the software programme. Educational
capital converted into what might be termed 'computer cultural capital'
is, therefore, no less exclusionary than other forms of cultural capital
(Bourdieu, 1984). Above all, in the context of eMail use across
linguistic communities, the use of the English language as the dominant
form, also sets real limits to participation on a 'level playing field'.


2.13
Studies show that, even when significant numbers of women do join mixed
gender discussion groups, their participation remains much lower. In
part at least, this can be explained by the complex inter-relationship
between online and offline identities or, rather, the projection of the
former into the latter:
In other words, as the female users wrote themselves into this virtual
community, they did so in an imagined social space very much defined by
their experiences in a patriarchal culture. As a result their discourse
patterns were 'gendered', meaning ... that the female users were less
participatory than their male counterparts, and often silent. (Dietrich,
1997: p. 181)

2.14
Indeed, just as in parts of the offline world, this has led to a growth
of all-women discussion groups and a range of other strategies to
promote women's participation and empowerment online, some of which are
noted in the first case study, below, of the zamir network. The
complexities of power, inequality and resistance in the new, relatively
autonomous 'socioscapes' (Appadurai, 1990, quoted in Eade, 1997: p. 7)
of contemporary global culture, including CMC, lead directly into
questions of the transformations of political interventions, of civil
society, and the public sphere.
A New Public Sphere?


2.15
The role of eMail as a political tool also touches on complex
relationships between online and offline life. Indeed, just as one might
feel oneself to be a member of a community but never go to a public
meeting, the 'activists' of the eMail world - those who use the
technology extensively, or primarily, to act politically - are a small
group, even less representative of the general population along all of
the axes noted above. Despite vast efforts by some Western European and
North American cities to 'democratise' their political processes through
computer connectivity, the unsurprising fact that it is the 'politicos'
- those already politically active in other ways; and the 'teckies' -
those primarily interested in the technological advances which
participation allows for; who come to dominate political cyberspace (
Francissen and Brants, 1998: p. 30), must make those who argue for the
essentially liberating impact of new technologies at least pause for
thought. Indeed, the rise of the 'politico-teckie', a fusion of the two
phenomena, may be an important side effect of the political use of
eMail, adding yet another layer of exclusionary 'capabilities'.

2.16
Many authors have explored whether the activist use of cyberspace
involves, in Habermas' terms (Habermas, 1994), a new 'public sphere',
replacing the coffee houses and salons of the eighteenth century and the
streets and barricades of the nineteenth, as the privileged locations of
civil society (Breslow, 1997: p. 241). This privatisation of public
participation, as it were, as one usually uses a computer alone, even if
not in the 'privacy of one's own home', makes the use of eMail
politically different from many other forms of political action,
suggesting that cyberspace may be conceived as both public and private
space (Fernback, 1997: p. 39).

2.17
An extension of this debate concerns the globalisation of civil society
as supranational agencies and, above all, the large International Non
Governmental Organisations (INGOs) tend to transform local social
movements into technicised bureaucracies (Demirovic, 1996). One part of
this transformation involves an emphasis on new computer technology and
global networking via eMail as necessary for even the smallest local
grassroots organisation. There is a complex relationship between
different levels of activism and, indeed, the possibility of merging the
coffee house, street meeting and eMail in a new conglomeration of
activism. Again, this is a key theme to be explored later in this
article.
eMail and War


2.18
Several features of 'wars in general', and the wars of the Yugoslav
succession in particular, are important in terms of the theoretical
considerations outlined above. All wars, of course, involve a kind of
'saturation effect' in Geerz's terms (cf. Geerz, 1988), in which all
aspects of previously taken-for-granted everyday life become contested,
complex and politicised (cf. Cale Feldman et al, 1993). When the wars
occur in a region with high levels of computer and other literacy and a
sophisticated communications infrastructure, it is very likely that
communications use will heighten and change (cf. Kolar-Panov, 1997).

2.19
In the wars of the Yugoslav succession, however, we are studying the use
of a new communications form since, outside of a few specialist milieus,
eMail use was largely unheard of in 1991 but by 1995 had reached massive
proportions. In a sense, eMail and war developed alongside each other so
that there was both 'no war without eMail' and 'no (normalised) eMail
use outside of war' in post-Yugoslav countries. Clearly, war is a prime
example of a 'politically charged situation' (Clifford, 1988: p. 10) in
which previously taken-for-granted notions of community, of power, and
of what is public and what is private, are shattered.

2.20
The notion that modern wars, far from being purely local, domestic, or
internal conflicts, as they are sometimes made to appear, are almost
always 'intermestic' (Pugh, 1998) insofar as they are always structured
in the context of global social relations, is an important one. The
involvement of a wide range of international agencies, of activists and
volunteers and, indeed, of various Diaspora communities, are key
features of the wars of the Yugoslav succession. Indeed, in their
different ways, the three case studies are testimony to this and
represent different aspects of the global amplification and
restructuring of the conflicts, and their assimilation into various
kinds of transnational discourse.
Zamir Net: eMail for Peace


3.1
The zamir network (the term za mir is Bosnian/Croatian/Serbian for peace
), established in 1992, was an explicit attempt to use eMail in peace
building and conflict resolution. Its origins, in fact, derived from
workshops with anti-war groups in Zagreb and Belgrade who, because of
the war, were no longer able to have any telephone, fax, or letter
contact with each other, except via third countries. By setting up
servers in both cities, and connecting them to a server in Germany, the
need for a third country remained, but the process of communication
exchange was made much faster. Later, servers were added in Sarajevo,
Ljubljana, Pristina, Tuzla, and Pakrac. A wide range of anti-war groups,
particularly associated with the Anti-war Campaign in Croatia
([EMAIL PROTECTED]), based in Zagreb, and the Centre for Anti-War Action in
Serbia, based in Belgrade, but also women's groups, ecology groups,
humanitarian agencies, and countless individuals, used zamir during the
war years and, indeed, it still exists today although, for reasons
discussed below, it is not quite the force it once was.

3.2
The network received funding from a number of Western donors, mainly
from strands of the European peace movement, and from George Soros' Open
Society Fund, which was never of a level to allow for the latest
technology to be used but which did allow for a cheap service, for most
of the time and in most of the sites, actually free at the point of use,
which was comparatively efficient compared to any other system locally
available. Perhaps more importantly, zamir became the most visible part
of an experimental social movement, articulating a kind of
'globalisation from below' (Deacon et al, 1994; Turmir, 1998), seeking
grassroots civil solutions to a conflict in which, patently, top down
political solutions were thin on the ground and likely to prove
disappointing. I would argue that, at its best moments, it was a kind of
experimental participatory democracy, in which Western peace activists,
most notably Wam Kat (Kat, 1993; [EMAIL PROTECTED]), Erich Bachmann (Bachmann,
1994; [EMAIL PROTECTED]), and Kathryn Turnipseed, formed
relationships with local activists such as Ognjen Tus
([EMAIL PROTECTED]) which were very different from the
exploitative ones often found in such encounters.

3.3
As Turmir rightly points out, a key zamir constituency was the network
of women's groups throughout the post-Yugoslav countries so that, in
fact, women accounted for far more of zamir's subscribers than was
normal with eMail nets. Through the training and networking of groups
such as the 'Electronic Witches', these groups came to use the
technology extensively, although in ways which often differed from men's
usage, with more interpersonal networking than formal conference
participation, again not unlike 'real' political communities. Even so, a
zamir conference /ZAMIR/WOMEN/, perhaps reflecting the fact that women's
groups had maintained an all-Yugoslav dialogue, in contrast to many
other, Republic-based, initiatives, throughout the 1980s (Jalusic, 1994
), was often the site of important debates, and, unusually for zamir,
was dominated by the languages of the region and not by English.

3.4
In assessing the impact of zamir, it has to be said that it never really
achieved its goal of being a genuine transnational movement producing
and reflecting civic dialogue across post-Yugoslav countries and beyond.
In some ways, this should not be surprising since, as already noted, and
as Srdjan Dvornik ([EMAIL PROTECTED]), a leading zamir activist
expressed it to me, 'these groups had stopped talking to each other in
the 1980s, it would take more than zamir to get them talking to each
other now' (Dvornik, 1994). The voices of zamir were, far more, the
non-nationalist voices of 'the other Croatia', particularly from
Zagreb-based groups, than they were a reflection of a wider movement.
Nevertheless, the Belgrade scene, centred on the Centre for Anti-War
Action and Women in Black, was a significant presence in many of the
conferences.

3.5
One of the side effects of the economic crisis and sanctions in Serbia
was that, ironically, zamir was one of the few avenues available through
which messages could be sent to friends around the world, so that
zamir-bg had a much larger number of users who were not committed to its
broader social goals and used it, simply, as a vehicle to maintain their
social networks. The use of zamir in Bosnia, particularly in the height
of the war, faced the obstacle of the fact that, even if your laptop did
not need electricity, which was often cut, then your modem almost
certainly did and, of course, you needed a telephone line to last long
enough to make a netcall. This made access to eMail extraordinarily
difficult. The modems donated from the West, as was the case with much
humanitarian aid, were old and slow and, therefore, required more time
to download messages than would have been the case with state-of-the-art
technology.

3.6
It can still be argued that the continuance of an alternative cultural
space which zamir had represented was crucial in orchestrating global
coverage of the protests in Belgrade in late 1996 and early 1997
although, apart from excellent on-the-spot reporting from peace activist
Dorie Wilsnack with the Balkan Peace Team (cf. BPT_BG, 1997), it was not
zamir-bg, already virtually finished, but the new wave of 'real audio'
and internet representations of Radio B92 and others, which dominated
the oppositional discourse (Turmir, 1998).

3.7
Postings on zamir from Tuzla in Bosnia-Herzegovina, on the occasion of
the massacre of young people in the centre of town on what, in the
previous system, would have been the Day of Youth, in May 1995, perhaps
showed the network at its best. Three young people linked to zamir,
Damir Kapidzic, Emir Prcic, and Adnan Demirovic, posted a number of
simple messages portraying the horror or war, listing the names and ages
of those who died, and translating appeals by the Mayor of Tuzla, Selim
Beslagic. The day after the massacre, Beslagic wrote to the UN security
council thus:
Today in the early morning at 8.30 the new missiles again hit the town
centre. The insane intention is obvious: the killing of innocent people
continues. This morning's grenade hit the place near by last night's
massacre point. The citizens of Tuzla have nothing to say to you.
Because you are quietly watching the killing of innocent people, and you
do have the means to stop it. Your behaviour is nothing else but
collaboration in this crime against humanness. ... Between you and the
killers of our children here will be no difference. Because even in the
international legal justice the collaboration in the crime is the crime
itself too. (posted by D. KAPIDZIC to /ZAMIR/FORUM, /APC/YUGO/ANTIWAR,
and other eMail conferences, 26 May 1995).

3.8
EMails from Belgrade, Zagreb and elsewhere followed and expressed the
collective grief and anger of a community, in which the virtual became
real, at the attack on young people in the city that was the symbol of
anti-nationalism. A year later, in memoriam, Croatian peace activist
Goran Bozicevic ([EMAIL PROTECTED]) wrote this:
Tuzla's Youth a year after.
I'm an atheist. (Am I?)
I'm a phycisist.
There exist laws of preservation on energy, preservation on momentum and
so on.
Where are seventy one lives now? If they are not in our actions, could
we live with our shame?
WHAT I DID FOR THEM TODAY? YESTERDAY?
WHAT AM I GOING TO DO TOMORROW?
THE DAY AFTER?
We got their lives as heritage.
Don't we feel their power?
I do. (GORAN.BOZICEVIC posting to /APC/YUGO/ANTIWAR, 25 May 1996).

3.9
This internal 'witnessing' (the term is used by Large, 1997: p. 144 in a
different context), is one of the strengths of the virtual community of
zamir. At times such as the Tuzla massacre it conveys the horror to a
reluctant wider public and news media. During the Croatian military and
police actions in early May 1995 which recaptured Western Slavonia from
'rebel' Serbs, the more strategic value of zamir was demonstrated. One
part of the Croatian anti-war movement was heavily involved in Volunteer
Project Pakrac, working in a divided town in Western Slavonia, which had
already used eMail in pioneering ways, in work with schools, for
example. After the volunteers had been evacuated, some returned and, via
eMail, posted important news of the general state of affairs and, in
particular, on human rights and other abuses which were occurring. The
quality of this reporting, and its speed, was far superior to anything
produced by expensive, official, monitors, such as those from the
European Union and may even have had real effects in curbing abuses in
certain locations (Stubbs, 1997a: p. 43).

3.10
The local role of an eMail network like zamir, as opposed to its wider
impact, is a relatively understudied phenomenon. One aspect of zamir
which is not widely discussed is the existence of closed discussion
groups on specific topics, which are termed internal conferences, read
by and written to by a smaller number of agreed people and
organisations. Examples of these which I have had access to, for various
reasons, are discussion and decision-making fora for ARK, for the Pakrac
project, and for the Centre for Peace Studies. They allow for real
democracy between meetings, and for safe discussion of complex or taboo
themes, as well as being a useful vehicle for the expression of a
process of consensual decision-making.

3.11
In addition, using zamir was one part of the repertoire of the
alternative or oppositional scene in Zagreb, linking explicitly with
specific real events, such as petitions, actions, demonstrations, or
happenings, and often being covered by, or prefiguring coverage in, the
alternative journal Arkzin ([EMAIL PROTECTED]; http://www.arkzin.com).
The November 1997 issue of Arkzin, for example, gives extensive coverage
to an eMail campaign which began on the /ZAMIR/WOMEN/ conference against
sexist advertising to promote a concert by Zabrenjeno Pusenje (No
Smoking), a band which normally would be given favourable coverage in
the journal. The whole scene then was, in effect, greater than the sum
of its parts, through an explicit multiplication of what Mark Dery (
http://www.factory.org/nettime/archive-1996/0119.html, and
http://www.factory.org/nettime/archive-1996/0214.html), quoted by Turmir
(1998), terms 'culture jamming' or 'guerrilla semiotics, directed
against ... the manufacture of consent through the manipulation of
symbols'. In this way, the globalised nature of zamir's intervention is
less acutely experienced than its specific, 'other Croatian' meaning. It
became, amongst its core users, a kind of cultural code, whose meanings,
and indeed sense of humour, could not easily be read from 'outside',
although its original stated purpose was precisely the ability to
explain these inside events to a wider public.

3.12
Of course, as I shall discuss in the concluding section, this production
of localised meanings has both positive, solidaristic, effects, and more
negative consequences, at least in terms of attracting wider interest
and impact. In-jokes and hidden codes are, often, key definers of
specific oppositional movements, but these same characteristics can
exclude others. This is precisely why actions linking eMail use with
wider social change are so important. Examples would include 'Electronic
Witches'' training of diverse women's groups in all post-Yugoslav
countries, and the pilot Peace Studies programme run by the Centre for
Peace Studies, which attracted almost forty students from much wider
than the normal Zagreb scene, who studied, as one stream, a course on
'Technology and Communication', led by Ognjen Tus, which linked
explicitly the politics of eMail and the possibility of progressive use
of technology.

3.13
zamir has also been important in supporting independent media in
Croatia, particularly the satirical political weekly Feral Tribune which
has faced various financial and other controls from the state. It is
certainly true that eMail is much less easy to censor than other forms
of communication, although it is also, of course, not a particularly
secure medium for message transmission (one's eMails can be intercepted
and read far more easily than one's telephone conversations, for
example). zamir has faced little public opprobrium although, in an
interesting piece of attempted sabotage, an encoded Serbian nationalist
song, itself over 10 MB long, was placed on the network and almost
brought down the server. In general terms, levels of trust and co-o
peration were high, marked by sufficient, and sufficiently positive,
human feelings in Rheingold's terms, to be seen as a community (
Rheingold, 1993: p. 5). In exactly the same terms described by Schmitz
to describe The Public Electronic Network's treatment of homelessness (
Schmitz, 1997), zamir exhibited 'a shared commitment to supply
information and act in concert' (Schmitz, 1997: p. 90). Moreover, I am
aware of many occasions when private censorious eMails were sent but
there was no public comment in a conference or where 'persons might
critically respond with a public comment about a previous entry but
privately send a conciliatory message' (Schmitz, 1997: p. 90).

3.14
As with all politicised social movements, zamir has been marked by very
different personalities with different perceptions of what is
politically possible or achievable, and how an eMail system can
contribute to this. Debates in 1995 between Srdjan Dvornik and Wam Kat,
for example, seem to me now like an echo of broader debates on modern
versus post- modern political options, with Dvornik emphasising formal
realistic options, and Wam Kat attracted by more surrealistic
possibilities or a kind of digital anarchism. The burgeoning of new
commercial options in all of the post-Yugoslav countries, and the
relative technological inferiority of the zamir system, also led to its
demise in much of the region. Today, zamir still works most effectively
in Croatia, with the Zagreb and newly established Rijeka servers
offering internet connectivity, continuing to have a core of loyal
users, and also attracting a new generation of activists eager to learn
more about how the network works. However, new debates about the
relationship between commercial sustainability and its broader social
goals are beginning to surface.
--[cont]--
Aloha, He'Ping,
Om, Shalom, Salaam.
Em Hotep, Peace Be,
Omnia Bona Bonis,
All My Relations.
Adieu, Adios, Aloha.
Amen.
Roads End
Kris

DECLARATION & DISCLAIMER
==========
CTRL is a discussion and informational exchange list. Proselyzting propagandic
screeds are not allowed. Substance�not soapboxing!  These are sordid matters
and 'conspiracy theory', with its many half-truths, misdirections and outright
frauds is used politically  by different groups with major and minor effects
spread throughout the spectrum of time and thought. That being said, CTRL
gives no endorsement to the validity of posts, and always suggests to readers;
be wary of what you read. CTRL gives no credeence to Holocaust denial and
nazi's need not apply.

Let us please be civil and as always, Caveat Lector.
========================================================================
Archives Available at:
http://home.ease.lsoft.com/archives/CTRL.html

http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/
========================================================================
To subscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SUBSCRIBE CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]

To UNsubscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SIGNOFF CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Om

Reply via email to