-Caveat Lector-

from:
http://www.engr.utexas.edu/cofe/governance/sovereignty.html
Click Here: <A
HREF="http://www.engr.utexas.edu/cofe/governance/sovereignty.html">Does
National Sovereignty</A>
-----
Notice--Murchison Chair of Free Enterprise.
Om
K
-----
Does National Sovereignty
Have a Future?


------------------------------------------------------------------------

As international bodies gather power unto themselves to solve imaginary
problems, the future of national sovereignty is threatened
by Kenneth Minogue
The story is told of how Charles II, back in the 1660�s presented to the
Royal Academy an interesting problem: why does a dead fish weigh more than a
living one? the scientists thought long and hard about this problem, coming
up with many ingenious solutions. The actual solution lay in a different area
altogether: the initial premise was wrong. Dead fish don�t weigh more than
living ones. There was no problem to begin with.
This abstract idea needs a concrete focus, and I shall take mine from a paper
put out by the UN Committee on Natural Resources -- CNR to its friends, of
whom, given its prose style, it can�t have many. CNR belongs to a world of
acronyms so powerful that we might well posit as their homeland the greatest
power in the world of ideas: ACRONYMIA. The CNR is an �expert� committee of
24 members. Its mandate was formally approved by ECOSOC (UN Economic and
Social Council) in July 1992 -- basing itself on earlier resolutions going
back into the mists of bureaucratic time.
CNR believes that the issue of the supply of minerals ought to be considered
as a part of an �integrated approach to the planning and management of land
resources.� In pursuance of this approach, it offers to those who mine metals
-- let us call them �metalkind� -- �an overall global partnership for
sustainable development.� Offers of partnership here resemble the Mafia�s
offers of protection: devices for forcing yourself into the act.
Decisions on sustainable development must, we learn, �be based on the best
possible information,� and then follows this eye-catching sentence: �The kind
of holistic and global view that is necessary is not readily acquired by
individual enterprises and countries.� This leads immediately to a
conclusion: �The Committee therefore believes that the UN (alias the
Committee itself!) has a critical role to play in coordinating and
integrating information on key issues on a global scale.� The Committee is
going to �provide the new global links to improve the basis for global
management strategies integrating environmental and development concerns.�
The art of diplomacy was once described as saying �Nice doggie� while
searching for a big stick. �Nice doggie� in this document is soothing talk of
planning, integration, coordination, and �partnership.� Self-defense, on the
other hand, is locating the stick -- often a slim twig that will soon grow
into a big stick. In this case, the twig is the simple sentence that
metalkind (and nationkind) are incapable of acquiring �the kind of holistic
and global view� that is necessary. Only an international committee of
experts can do that. I am reminded of a cartoon character who remarks to the
drunk: �What we all admire is the way you have acquired megalomania without
losing common touch.�
The UN project, then, is to find a solution to one big problem, and it is
this style of thought -- instrumental rationality it is often called -- which
we must consider. Solving problems is of course, often a sensible thing to
do. But earlier civilizations were parsimonious in construing the world as a
nest of problems. Some things, they thought, just had to be endured. And
sometimes even moderns like us feel that way. Back in the 1950s, the days of
Dr. Dichter the great market psychologist, men and women were surveyed about
what they most disliked in life. Men said shaving, women said menstruation.
They were then offered an (as it turned out) imaginary pill which could
dispense these problematic inconveniences. Most rejected the offer. This
response, like the dead fish, is a parable about the human condition.
A great deal of salesmanship, alias propaganda, consists in persuading people
that they have a terrible problem which only the propagandist can solve.
Hitler on Jews, or Marx on the bourgeoisie, persuaded many to believe in a
dead-fish problem. But there are many other forms of the dead-fish problem.
Unemployment for example, poses a famous rationality problem because our
natural response to it is to say: how absurd that many of able bodied people
should be sitting around idle when there are so many important things
(renewing the infrastructure, etc.) that need to be done. When the question
is posed in this way, the natural solution is to use the powers of government
to create a natural labor force. That way leads to central planning of the
economy. It is a perfect case where abstract instrumental rationality takes a
lot of small problems and creates one great big disaster.
That example gives us a clue to the many dangerous assumptions concealed in
our natural instinct for collectively instrumentally rational solutions to
grand problems. We should be particularly critical of the assumption that
small problems agglomerate together into One Big problem which requires One
Big solution and consequently, One Big Solver. And what is clearly assumed in
the bid for international regulation of metalkind is that the One Big Solver
must have the power to impose a solution. Concealed beneath the euphemistic
language is a doctrine quite explicit in many reports with an environmental
slant: The very essence of global governance is the capability to ensure
compliance.
The inventor of the One Big solution to the One Big Problem was the
philosopher Plato, who imagined humanity trapped in a cave of shadowy
illusions. Salvation could only come from the philosopher-king who had
emerged from the cave and seen what things looked like in the sunlight. The
test of understanding was reality; the difficulty was that the only person
who could test whether the philosopher was actually in contact with reality
was -- well, the philosopher himself. The philosopher-king solution, when
transferred to politics, ends up with that most vacuous of political demands:
put your trust in me.
With the Committee on Natural Resources we have something only marginally
different from Plato: the philosopher committee has replaced the
philosopher-king. And instead of Plato�s subtle theory of ideas, we have �the
best possible information� to provide the �information links� that will in
turn provide the basis for �global management strategies integrating
environmental and development concerns.�
Or will it? It is not easy to sustain a questioning frame of mind when
reading words which are bureaucratically exciting but intellectually void. In
construing the meaning of this argument, I might take as my text a remark by
an American Deputy Secretary of State for Environment. His name is Tim Wirth
and, when a Senator, he made a striking comment which comes from the heart of
the internationalist movement:


What we�ve got to do in energy . . . is . . . ride the global warming issue.
. . . Even if the theory is wrong . . . (it) means doing the right thing . .
. in terms of economic policy and environmental policy.

Here is a dramatic illustration of my argument that any problem-solution
nexus of argument must be treated with extreme suspicion. What is here
revealed is a powerful moral drive riding on a theory whose very truth and
reliability is relegated to a secondary place. So much for that �best
possible information.�
There is, in fact, nothing like the cynicism of the well-intentioned. Thus
Stephen Schneider of the National Center of Atmospheric Research in Colorado
comments on global warming:


. . . we have to offer up scary scenarios, make simplified dramatic
statements and make little mention of doubts we might have . . . . Each of us
has to decide what the right balance is between being effective and being
honest.

It was George Orwell who warned us that vague and pompous language could
conceal specific and unpompous political ambitions. But leaving language
aside, and leaving aside also the fact that for many internationalists the
actual truth of the theory is a secondary issue, we as rational critics must
consider the logical question of what such a committee might actually be in a
position to know. One striking example can be found even in the memorandum of
the CNR. In looking to what it calls the �horizon of sustainability� the
Committee measures �Demonstrated Economic Resources� (p. 3). To know the
unknowable is a cute trick, but by no means the cutest in this field.
It might seem that I am being merely pedantic, a bit carping, in treating the
Committee proposal in this way. For surely, it will be said, we are dealing
with a real problem here. Is it not unjust that rich Western countries gobble
up more that �their share� of scarce minerals -- ought not metalkind think
more of mankind? And do we really want to leave our children a planet looking
like an old abandoned mine shaft?
While the point of this rhetoric is to create a stirring sense of urgency in
the listener, it cannot obscure the serious question, namely: do we have the
knowledge available to solve this problem? Does it not raise very large
questions of politics which will lead to major conflicts? And if we push our
question even further we might ask: Are we not dealing with another of those
dead-fish questions?
Such questions are neither frivolous nor pedantic. As Dipak Lal has pointed
out, acid rain, the nuclear winter and oil fires of Kuwait have all had their
moment of glory as global problems and disappeared from sight. We in the West
love to have our bowels chilled by tales of imminent catastrophe. Men telling
about the end of the world used to operate from pulpits, or go about in
sandwich boards. Today they work from the Lab, and instead of recommending
prayer, they demand an international committee and urgent action. And as for
future generations -- well, one cannot but wonder at the selfishness of the
British Admiralty at the turn of the nineteenth century in cutting down all
those oak trees to build ships to protect them against Napoleon, when they
should have been conserving oak forests for ship building in the twenty-first
century. There is at least one highly significant affinity between
environmental activists and Communists of yesteryear: both are dependent for
their assumptions upon existing -- usually an already outmoded-technology.
Some of you may remember the cartoon figure of Mr. Magoo, whose myopia never
interfered with his confident sense of his own infallibility. He was forever
walking along the edges of precipices under the illusion that it was the
center of the road; he was the classic searcher for a gas leak with a lighted
taper. Observing the marvelous combination of confidence and ignorance in the
proposals of inter-national regulatory committees, the figure of Magoo is
never far frommy mind. As Alice remarked in another cartoon: �Don�t just do
something. Stand there.�
Immobilism is not, of course, a particularly heroic policy, nor is it quite
what I am advocating. No doubt it is prudent to respond even to such
imperfect understanding as we have of the impact of industry on the
environment. But it would seem plausible to believe that the world is better
served by many intelligent people in different sovereign states responding to
a variety of situationally different problems than by a single committee of
experts imposing one big solution on everybody.
International problems often provoke us to this insidious kind of false
rationality. We respond eagerly to famine pictures, only to discover that the
food is being diverted to war lords, or that we are destroying the market on
which the long-term future of these people will depend.
It is in fact the very logic of rationality which deceives us. The moment we
have constructed a situation in problem terms, we have moved into a world of
abstractions which conceals from us important aspects of a situation. Those
in America early in the century who thought that drunkenness was a problem,
to be solved by constitutional prohibition, did not recognize in the power of
a forbidden desire the potentiality to create whole gangster empires which
plague America to this day. The philosopher Kant, like many of his
generation, thought war was a problem, and the removal of kings and
aristocrats -- the only people who he believed who had an interest in war --
was the solution. It was this idea which paved the way for the infinitely
more deadly mass mobilization of wars of recent times.
The problem of unintended consequences is well-illustrated in the Aesop fable
of Horse which was being tormented by a boar, and called on Man to help.
�Certainly,� said Man, �I shall help you, but first you must let me saddle
you up.� The horse solved the problem of the boar, but was lumbered ever
after with the saddle. My basic question is whether metalkind will allow
itself to be similarly saddled.
The international world is the natural habitat of instrumental rationality in
its extreme form, because there�s nothing else out there except talking
shops, so they talk things up using standard moves. One, for example, is to
attribute all conflict between states to �nationalism� which is actually
something highly specific. This move undermines states by suggesting that
they are always blind and selfish, and that enlightenment can only be found
at the international level.
Another device is to tell us, as Marx did and many others before him, that we
have now entered a new world of interdependence in which frontiers are
permeable and the old values don�t apply. It was no doubt an opinion that
occurred to the Emperor Hadrian as he contemplated the barbarians on the
borders of Rome. Today the doctrine is called �globalization.� National
Sovereignty, it is said, cannot deal with modern problems, because problems
-- ah, those pesky problems again -- don�t stop at the borders of states.
What we must do is �pool sovereignty.� National sovereignty is an anachronism
-- like monarchy, the family, honor, fountain pens, and pleasing architecture.
What we have is a new ideology for an emerging class of internationalists,
and global problems are ways of talking up its power and increasing its
leverage over the national state. Power is to selfless international
committees of the enlightened.
Don�t think that I am sentimentalizing the national state. It is in many ways
a vile old brute, and the misuses of instrumental rationality have been
lavishly used by states to aggrandize their own power. The state is a
monster, but it is our monster, in the sense that it must endure some sort of
accountability, in democracies, to us. In a perfect world one would want to
focus on diminishing its power, which is certainly one of the virtuous causes
of our time. But then, it isn�t a perfect world, and as the famous Irishman
said -- he is one of the tragic but realistic conservatives of our time --
�If I wanted to get there, I wouldn�t have started from here.�

1996 by national review, Inc., 215 Lexington Avenue, New York, NY 10016.
Reprinted by permission.

Table of
Contents19 April 1999
Murchison Chair of Free Enterprise
College of Engineering at UT Austin
Send comments to: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
-----
Aloha, He'Ping,
Om, Shalom, Salaam.
Em Hotep, Peace Be,
Omnia Bona Bonis,
All My Relations.
Adieu, Adios, Aloha.
Amen.
Roads End

DECLARATION & DISCLAIMER
==========
CTRL is a discussion and informational exchange list. Proselyzting propagandic
screeds are not allowed. Substance�not soapboxing!  These are sordid matters
and 'conspiracy theory', with its many half-truths, misdirections and outright
frauds is used politically  by different groups with major and minor effects
spread throughout the spectrum of time and thought. That being said, CTRL
gives no endorsement to the validity of posts, and always suggests to readers;
be wary of what you read. CTRL gives no credeence to Holocaust denial and
nazi's need not apply.

Let us please be civil and as always, Caveat Lector.
========================================================================
Archives Available at:
http://home.ease.lsoft.com/archives/CTRL.html

http:[EMAIL PROTECTED]/
========================================================================
To subscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SUBSCRIBE CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]

To UNsubscribe to Conspiracy Theory Research List[CTRL] send email:
SIGNOFF CTRL [to:] [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Om

Reply via email to