On Sun, Feb 22, 2015 at 07:58:19PM -0800, Jim Schaad wrote:

> I am on a case sensitive receiving domain.
> There are two recipients - JimSch and jimsch on the domain.
> jimsch has a record but JimSch does not.
> I now try and send mail to JimSch but get a key for jimsch.

You forgot to hash the tag with the case-folded name.

Speaking of which, IIRC neither the OPENPGPKEY nor the SMIMEA draft
explicitly mentions what to do about quoted localparts:

        "Sam.Jr."@example.com

The localpart is not a dot-atom, and thus requires double-quotes.
My contention is that in this case the input to SHA2-224 MUST
include the quotes:

        SHA2-224("Sam.Jr.")

not

        SHA2-224("Sam.Jr.")

In this case the simplest tagging scheme is:

        JimSch                  - unfolded hash input
        jimsch@lowercase        - folded hash input

any email address of the form:

        "jimsch@lowercase"@example.com

would be hashed together with the quotes!

I don't have a pointer to my original proposal handy,
check the archives.  It is something along these lines.

-- 
        Viktor.

_______________________________________________
dane mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dane

Reply via email to