Hi,
* Vasudev Kamath <[email protected]> [2012-11-08 19:13]:
> > this package has not updated any of the tools included since two years.
> > Please package newer tools, especially but most important slock.
> 
> As per the freeze policy I can't really introduce new things into Wheezy
> so I didn't consider putting new versions into 38-2. I'm preparing 39
> version with all bugs closed and latest version of software but it will
> not be in wheezy and will be backported once wheezy is stable.

Sure, I'm not worried about wheezy too much.

> > The current version of slock has no indication whatsoever that a screen 
> > lock is active.
> > After a longer idle period of the display, it is therefore impossible to 
> > distinguish between a locked
> > screen and an inactive screen. As a result, it is not too difficult to 
> > write your password somewhere
> > you don't want to because you assumed the screen was locked.
> > Hence I marked this as grave, this happened to me multiple times.
> > 
> > Newer slock versions have a color indication once you hit the first key on 
> > the keyboard that shows
> > you that the lock is active.
> 
> But If I understand correctly it is not a bug but that is how slock was
> designed previously and patch was later submitted to colourise and give
> more features to slock which was later merged by Anselm to prepare 1.1
> version. So can you please reconsider on the severity of the bug?

Well yeah, if you look at it like that, it's more a feature request. However 
if you consider the security nature of this program, I rather consider this as 
hardening or even a bug given that this is not a hypothetical scenario but one 
that happens often (and certainly not only to me).

> Now coming to the colourising feature are you talking about this
> specific commit[1] or all the 3 new patches from the tip? If this is the
> single patch you meant then I will try to cherrypick it but again I
> don't know new unblock request will be entertained by release team [2]

I'm not sure to be honest. I've seen the new dualcolor patch in the recent 
tip, but that's not the one I had in mind, I haven't tested this one yet.
The one that initially implemented this in March was:
http://hg.suckless.org/slock/rev/0eade055cef0

> PS: I will be on vacation for a week from tomorrow so I'm really not
> sure if I will be able to finish this package soon. If you can prepare
> an NMU I'll be happy with that :-). Only thing is I don't want package
> to be removed from Wheezy because multiple packages depend on it.

No worries :)

Cheers
Nico
-- 
Nico Golde - http://www.ngolde.de - [email protected] - GPG: 0xA0A0AAAA

Attachment: pgp1JWT45gTM7.pgp
Description: PGP signature

Reply via email to