* Bas Zoetekouw:

> s-nail/heirloom-mailx is not a proper alternative for mailx/bsd-mailx,
> as it uses different command line options (for example on a regulair
> mailx, -a means "add header, whereas for s-nail it means "add
> attachment").

We had some discussion about whether to provide a mailx alternative back
in the day when heirloom-mailx was still called nail, see #272256.

And at one time there was even a report about a missing -a option
although it seems that then the submitter decided otherwise, see #381575

> This breaks other packages (for example cron-apt) that rely on a
> mailx-dependency to send mails.  Therefore, I'm making this Serious
> severity.

The -a option was added to bsd-mailx by Debian more than 16 years ago.
However, there does not seem to be any clear definition that tells us
what to expect from a /usr/bin/mailx program.

Is this really s-nail's fault?

Steffen, would you consider changing the parameter for adding an
attachment to something else?

Cheers,
-Hilko

Reply via email to