Source: ghdl
X-Debbugs-Cc: dfsg-team, [email protected]
Version: 6.0.0+dfsg2-1
Severity: serious
Tags: upstream

Following stanzas in d/copyright are not DFSG compatible.

Files: libraries/mentor/*
Copyright: 1993 by Mentor Graphics
License: Mentor
 This source file is proprietary information of Mentor Graphics,Inc.
 It may be distributed in whole without restriction provided that
 this copyright statement is not removed from the file and that
 any derivative work contains this copyright notice.

It is explicit labeled as 'proprietary information'.
There is no explicit permission to use.
The text lacks the standard warranty and liability disclaimers
that are typical and necessary in established free software licenses.
So it is uncertainly legal. (Tentacle of Evil)

Files: libraries/synopsys/*
Copyright: 1990-1992, Synopsys, Inc.
License: synopsys
 This source file may be used and distributed without restriction
 provided that this copyright statement is not removed from the file
 and that any derivative work contains this copyright notice.

There is no explicit permission to modify, which is mentioned in DFSG #3

Following stanzas must be improved:

Files: testsuite/synth/issue1926/*ecp5pll.vhdl
       testsuite/synth/issue2334/*ecp5pll*.vhd
       testsuite/synth/issue2339/*ecp5pll.vhd
Copyright: EMARD
License: Unspecified-BSD

Files: testsuite/gna/issue283/Makefile.ghdl
       testsuite/gna/issue301/Makefile
Copyright: 2014-2015 Potential Ventures Ltd
License: BSD-3-clause-Potential-Ventures

It is enough to declare it as BSD-3-clause

--
Mechtilde Stehmann
## Debian Developer
## PGP encryption welcome
## F0E3 7F3D C87A 4998 2899  39E7 F287 7BBA 141A AD7F

Reply via email to