Hello Andres, I wish you a happy new year!

Andres Cimmarusti a écrit :
> Package: kicad
> Version: 0.0.20100314-1
> Severity: wishlist
> 
> I just wanted to bring the maintainers' attention to the fact that there 
> is a new upstream stable release since december (2011-12-28):
> 
> http://iut-tice.ujf-grenoble.fr/cao/

The release dated 29/12/2011 is currently located in the subdirectory 
sources/old_versions/

the directory http://iut-tice.ujf-grenoble.fr/cao/ provides some files
which were uploaded more recently (20/01/2012).

My guess is that I should use either
http://iut-tice.ujf-grenoble.fr/cao/kicad-2012-01-19-BZR3256-stable-UBUNTU_10.10_full_with_components_doc.tgz
or
http://iut-tice.ujf-grenoble.fr/cao/kicad_sources-2012-01-19-BZR3256-stable.zip

Those archives are very different in size (201 MB, 13.4 MB) and their
size is different from the size of the archive wich was packaged for
wheezy last time (97 MB).

Which archive should I consider? Have you some documentation summarizing
the changes, and specially the changes in the components set, and the
embedded documents? I rememeber that there have been a few license issues
in the past about sourceless documents.

... hmmm.

I browsed both archives in a viewer. 

- The biggest one comes with sourceless executable binaries, many
  documents and resources.  Only a few documents come with a clearly
  declared license (for example French documents are correctly
  licensed), and tracking the ownership and the licenses in components
  appears as quite impossible.

- the smaller archive unfolds into a directory KiCad-sources. This one
  has a valid documentation about ownership and licensing.

I think that I should split the packaging effort in two: make the
package for KiCad's programs now, and begin an ITP (Intention To
Package) for a second package, probably named kicad-common or
kicad-share, based on
kicad-2012-01-19-BZR3256-stable-UBUNTU_10.10_full_with_components_doc.tgz

For the second package, I shall remove many stuff due to license
incertitude, and repack its source into a file
kicad-common_2012.01.19+dfsg1.orig.tar.gz, the suffix "dfsg1" standing
for "in application of the Debian Free Software Guidelines", which
preclude the distribution of sourceless or ill licensed materials.

Do you agree with such a proposition?

Best regards,                   Georges.

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: Digital signature

Reply via email to