Em sáb, 2026-11-14 às 08:49 +0800, Maytham Alsudany escreveu: > Which is why I'm saying it's difficult to decide whether to sponsor > an RFS or not. I'm not saying that "every sponsee needs contribution > history", which is impossible, but I mean that we can't predict the > future, and no-one wants to make the wrong decision and waste time by > sponsoring someone who will end up abandoning the package later.
Sounds like we're agreeing on something, but coming from
different perspectives. Which is good, since it might have a better
chance at getting some ideas brewing.
> This is important considering that I as a sponsor have to spend a
> non-trivial amount of time reviewing every part of the package for
> problems, *especially* when it's NEW and the d/copyright will be
> scrutinized, as any problems that get through will end up reflecting
> on
> my ability to properly review as well. When I do an upload, I am
> signing
> off on the work with my own GPG key and saying "yes, this should go
> in
> the archive and be installed on people's computers." If the package
> is
> abandoned, there will also be time and effort spent either removing
> the
> package or finding a new maintainer.
Absolutely, I totally understand that concern. Which is why I
don't think every package should have the same treatment nevertheless -
the motivation behind it should matter.
>
> This is a problem with Debian in general, where people are afraid to
> RM
> a package so they orphan it instead, and then no-one touches it for
> years. People working on package QA RM these when they encounter
> them,
> but any mass removal of ancient orphaned packages is likely to start
> some toxic debate in debian-devel about "keeping historical packages"
> and "it's still useful" and what-not.
This is a very good point. Sometimes things get lost in
endless debate and end up not being properly addressed.
> >
--
[]'s
|
Francisco M Neto |
<[email protected]> | 3E58 1655 9A3D 5D78 9F90
| CFF1 D30B 1694 D692 FBF0
signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part

