Hi Maytham,

you post some interesting points here for me as someone looking for a sponsor, that I 
thought "okay, I'll check myself against the list".

And I noticed that I don't check some boxes and wonder if you would consider those 
non-compliances "acceptable":

On 2026-11-14 01:49:33, Maytham Alsudany wrote:
I should also mention that, for me personally when I am looking through
RFS bugs, there are a handful of indicators that signal whether someone
is willing to actually maintain the package long-term. I don't know how
accurate they are, but it's the only heuristic I can use. It includes
stuff like:
- Properly formatted ITP and RFS bugs, with correct name

[x]

- Packaged in a Git repo

[x]

- Packaged in a team (if applicable) - much lower chance of abandonment

No, being new to debian, I am on my own, for my first ever submission.

- Upstream != downstream

No, I am the main upstream maintainer (not the project author): I worked a long 
time (since 2024) on the project and saw that it has quite an active userbase, 
while also myself finding it as the *only* suitable C++ library for the purpose 
of manipulating OOXML spreadsheet (XLSX) files.
Accordingly I thought it would be a valuable contribution to any linux distro - 
and with proper dependency management, the install process would be much easier 
for the users.

- Notable userbase (usually based off GitHub stars if available)

OpenXLSX has 1.8k stars on github, but we migrated to codeberg to get away from 
the LLM scraping and generally github being bad. So my Debian submission links 
to the new codeberg repository, where of course those old stars don't show.

The library has however already been packaged for microslop's vcpkg: 
https://vcpkg.io/en/package/openxlsx and has been accepted by the official 
vcpkg team:
  https://github.com/microsoft/vcpkg/pull/51263

- Genuinely useful

[x] (Manipulating XLSX files from C++ - do I need to elaborate? :)

- Updates to existing packages & ITAs have greater value than ITPs

Well - our library is entirely new, so there's nothing to adopt with this 
functionality.

- If outside a team, am I interested enough in the package to keep tabs
        on it or add myself to Uploaders?

Based on recommendation from the debian-mentors review, I have specified
Maintainer: Debian Commons <[email protected]>

I am not sure if that counts?


Interested in your feedback :)


   /Lars

Reply via email to