Mimi Yin wrote: > https://bugzilla.osafoundation.org/show_bug.cgi?id=6134 >> What is your expectations for clicking 1) same collection in sidebar, 2) >> different collection in sidebar when the initial focus is: >> >> a. focus in in-place event editor in calendar >> b. focus in event in calendar >> c. focus in calendar (but not any event) >> d. focus in detail view field >> e. focus in toolbar search box > > Are you asking if the behavior should be different depending on the > context? > > I'm not sure that there's a difference between any of these contexts.
If there is no difference, then we need to file more bugs because we currently have different behavior. Focus does NOT move to sidebar when you have focus in the in-place editor in calendar. In all other cases focus does move. > Thus far, we've identified 3 use cases for switching focus to the sidebar: > > 1. Deleting a collection from the sidebar > 2. Using your keyboard to navigate up and down collections > 3. Renaming a collection (which you can do in today's paradigm with a > d-click) I don't think 2. counts, since the focus must already be in the sidebar before you can do that. Of course the focus should remain there, though. >> f. focus in in-place editor in sidebar > > I would expect to exit out of edit mode. That did not answer if the focus should stay on that sidebar entry or what. >> g. focus in sidebar entry > > I'm not sure I understand your question in the context of f and g. If you can move between sidebar entries with arrow keys then you have focus in the sidebar, in the entry that is highlighted. The question here is, if you then click another sidebar entry should the focus shirt to that entry, or to the calendar, or somewhere else. My expectation is that it stays in the sidebar, on the active entry. >> What is the expectation when clicking menu? > > Focus shifts to the menu because you are indeed changing your mental > focus to the menu items. When you are trying to launch the account > creation dialog, you're not longer looking at the main UI. I actually did some experimentation and menus are different. You do get the focus into the menu, but when you select a menu entry the focus goes back to where it was. That seems fine. -- Heikki Toivonen
signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ Open Source Applications Foundation "Design" mailing list http://lists.osafoundation.org/mailman/listinfo/design
