> At this point, I think 2.3.0 will be around early Feb to get AIP-42 in. We 
> can reassess how the progress is moving ahead with the AIP mid-Jan and based 
> on that we can either release 2.3.0 end of Jan without AIP-42 changes and 
> mark it for 2.4.0.

Yeah Agree here. I do not think we need to make a decision now - we
can do it later. But I'd love to hear various opinions - from our
users, various stakeholders (Amazon/Google/Astronomer who run it as a
service for one).

Just to be clear - I am not fully convinced myself if this is the
right time to do it already (but there are some good indicators that
we should at least start discussing it).

This is more opening the discussion and gathering feedback/feelings of
people. I think such decisions should be discussed (and their
consequences realized) well in-advance so that at the time of decision
we have all arguments and opinions and know the consequences.

 And it is not "strictly" necessary. It's just (like with all similar
cases) an increased burden for maintenance and extra/boilerplate code
that might be removed. In those cases there is rarely a "0/1" decision
that can be made "here we know for sure that we should increase
min-version" - it's more of the collective thinking: "Are the
burden/overhead heavy enough we don't want to carry it any more as a
community".

J.

Reply via email to