Ok, that was just long to use inline comments so... I agree with in principle. I think your definitions, basics and concerns are on point. I also think I agree with the rest of it but it will take a few more reads to make sure.
With that said here are a few of my thoughts along the same line as yours. 1) I agree completely that a container should be no more than a shell that provides "container" services using components. The trick here is being able to define the proper interfaces for those container components as well as for the normal framework interfaces. This might be easier said than done, but would allow for a completely customizable container. One issue we will run into with this approach is that there will still be things that are harder to "componentize" than to just layer into the container. If enough of these exist and they are implemented differently enough in each container/component we are back to the same problem. This is more of a dynamic container. 2) As to the proposed process in general I agree. One thing to consider is a time limit for discussion. Now before someone attacks me on this, I'm not talking about cutting people off after 10 minutes or something. What I mean is some upper limit that is reasonable to facilitate useful discussion. Without one someone could potentially stall the decision process by continually asking useless questions. Obviously is there is still constructive discussion continuing the time limit could be extended. 3) Also for the "Issue -> Proposal -> Discussion -> Decision" process a different format might be considered other than the mailing lists. Maybe have a section on the website for this process. That way the proposals/decisions can be accessible at a later date without having to search the mailing list archives. Not to mention it would help organization by not having to look for ever changing subject lines. --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
