I did not veto this vote. I suggested a path to resolving a -1 from Cos. I'm not sure how that wasn't clear, but let me clarify. My vote here was officially 0, since I didn't vote. (smile) Fortunately this doesn't affect the outcome.
On Thu, Mar 19, 2015 at 2:20 AM, Bruno Mahé <[email protected]> wrote: > Hi, > > Here is the tally: > * +7 (binding) > * +3 (non-binding) > * -2 (binding) > > Therefore the vote has passed and we do now have a Social Media Guideline. > I will update the wiki to reflect its status and start a new vote to amend > the guidelines to build consensus with Cos and Andrew P. > > Thanks everyone for voting and helping Apache Bigtop grow up! > > Thanks, > Bruno > > > On 03/16/2015 01:10 AM, Bruno Mahé wrote: > >> Hi, >> >> As per discussion on [0] and [1], we seem to have built consensus on the >> need for some Social Media Guidelines as well as what these guidelines >> should be. >> >> >> This email is about voting the adoption of the guidelines as described on: >> https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/pages/viewpage.action?pageId=53740308 >> - v1 >> >> I will also attach the guidelines below my email for convenience and >> reference. >> >> >> +1 : To accept the Social Media Guidelines as currently described on the >> wiki and attached to this email >> 0 : No opinion one way or the other >> -1 : To reject the Social Media Guidelines as currently described on the >> wiki and attached to this email >> >> >> The vote shall be open for at least 72 hours and will be closed on >> Thursday, >> March 19th at 01:00 PST. >> >> Thanks, >> Bruno >> >> >> [0]http://mail-archives.apache.org/mod_mbox/bigtop- >> dev/201503.mbox/%3CCAGC%2B2MuPny%3D6HcO_OMRU-i-T% >> 2BDcE5-5CfGabrWMFM%3DU5P666qQ%40mail.gmail.com%3E >> [1]http://mail-archives.apache.org/mod_mbox/bigtop- >> dev/201503.mbox/%3C550131E4.2090802%40bmahe.net%3E >> >> >> ============================================================ >> ========================== >> >> >> Social Media Guidelines >> <https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/BIGTOP/ >> Social+Media+Guidelines> >> >> >> This document is a proposal currently under discussion - it has not yet >> been accepted by the Bigtop community. >> >> The original text was taken from Apache Cloudstack's Social Media >> Guidelines: Social Media Guidelines <https://cwiki.apache.org/ >> confluence/display/CLOUDSTACK/Social+Media+Guidelines> >> >> >> Apache Bigtop Social Media Guidelines >> >> The Apache Bigtop project has a Twitter account (@ASFBigtop) that it can >> use to spread news about the project and promote the project. >> >> * Apache Bigtop Social Media Guidelines >> <https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/CLOUDSTACK/ >> Social+Media+Guidelines#SocialMediaGuidelines- >> ApacheCloudStackSocialMediaGuidelines> >> >> o Access to Social Media Accounts >> <https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/CLOUDSTACK/ >> Social+Media+Guidelines#SocialMediaGuidelines-AccesstoSocialMediaAccounts >> > >> o Do's and Don'ts for Social Media >> <https://cwiki.apache.org/confluence/display/CLOUDSTACK/ >> Social+Media+Guidelines#SocialMediaGuidelines-Do% >> 27sandDon%27tsforSocialMedia> >> >> >> Access to Social Media Accounts >> >> Access to the social media accounts can be granted to any committer or >> PMC member who would like to participate. When possible, access will be >> through Hootsuite or another tool that does not require disseminating the >> login credentials. >> >> >> Do's and Don'ts for Social Media >> >> Before posting anything, you'll want to familiarize yourself with >> Apache's Media and Analyst Relations <http://www.apache.org/press/> page >> and brand management page <http://www.apache.org/foundation/marks/>. >> >> Whether you're posting from a personal account *about* Apache Bigtop or >> posting from one of the official accounts, there are a few things you want >> to keep in mind. >> >> * *Anything said in public is fair game for press.* >> o Never post anything via social media you wouldn't want to see >> reported on news sites. >> >> * Make sure what you're saying/sharing is appropriate for all >> audiences, and reflects well on Apache Bigtop. >> o Be polite when talking about Bigtop and responding to questions. >> o Informal voice is OK, unprofessional is not. >> o Absolutely no use of NSFW language, images, or scenarios when >> using official Apache Bigtop accounts – and avoid associating >> Apache Bigtop with anything that is likely to be considered >> offensive. >> >> * Share relevant, positive information. >> o Feel free to share stories about Bigtop, whether they come >> from the Bigtop community, tech press, or folks outside of the >> press and community. >> o Avoid sharing negative stories about "competing" projects. >> o Keep posts/reposts relevant. Everybody loves LOLCats, but it's >> probably best not to share them from the official Bigtop >> social media accounts. >> o Please share event information *so long as it's >> Bigtop-related*. /e.g./ Promoting an event where there are >> talks about Bigtop is spot-on. Promoting an event only because >> a vendor that has an interest in Bigtop is participating would >> be outside the scope of Bigtop social media accounts. >> >> * Be sure information is public >> o Companies sometimes discuss plans/ideas informally at events. >> It's often a good idea to ask before sharing information on >> social media if it might be considered non-public. (For >> example, information presented during a talk should be fair >> game. Information shared over dinner may not be for public >> dissemination.) >> >> * Bigtop does not have "sponsors", events and activities have sponsors. >> o Avoid language like /$foo_company is sponsoring the Apache >> Bigtop project/. >> o Companies *can* sponsor events and activities. For example, >> /$foo_company is hosting a Bigtop meetup in Atlanta this weekend/. >> >> * Don't use Apache Bigtop social media accounts to promote unrelated >> commercial activities. >> >> * *When in doubt, ask* >> o If you're unclear on whether a post or item is OK, ask on the >> project mailing list. The other contributors on the list will >> *always* be happy to discuss and guide other contributors on >> what is and isn't appropriate for our social media activities. >> >> > -- Best regards, - Andy Problems worthy of attack prove their worth by hitting back. - Piet Hein (via Tom White)
