OK, looks like you all agree to drop ELK together. I’ll remove them from Bigtop 3.2.0, Thank you all for the advice.
Best Regards, Zhiguo Wu > On Jul 22, 2022, at 18:09, Yuqi Gu <[email protected]> wrote: > > As we discussed on BIGTOP-3722, I think it makes sense to remove the whole > ELK, not just only logstash, from Bigtop stack for the license conflicts. > https://www.elastic.co/blog/licensing-change > https://www.cmswire.com/knowledge-findability/not-so-open-any-more-elasticsearch-relicensing-and-implications-for-open-source-search/ > > > 李帅 <[email protected]> 于2022年7月22日周五 17:45写道： > >> +1, I think remove elk so we could focus on Hadoop related components. Elk >> also have theirselve's rpm/deb packages. So, I support the division. >> >> <[email protected]> 于 2022年7月22日周五 17:21写道： >> >>> I also +1 to drop those components, including ES and Kibana. >>> A few month ago I added the patches for log4j to them, it was a little >> bit >>> difficult to patch because those products in Bigtop were far from the >>> latest versions. And as Masatake mentions currently ELK are not Apache 2 >>> license. >>> I think it is preferable to drop them, or to replace them to OpenSearch >> or >>> another projects which are maintained in Apache 2 license. >>> >>> Regards, >>> Leona Yoda >>> >>> From: Masatake Iwasaki <[email protected]> >>> Date: Friday, July 22, 2022 17:50 >>> To: [email protected] <[email protected]> >>> Subject: Re: Remove Logstash from Bigtop stack >>> I'm +1 to drop Logstash (and Elasticsearch and Kibana as well). >>> We can not upgrade them to upstream version due to incompatible license. >>> rpm/deb packages are officially provided on their own. >>> >>> Thanks, >>> Masatke Iwasaki >>> >>> On 2022/07/22 16:26, 吴治国 wrote: >>>> Hi community, >>>> >>>> as the ELK version in Bigtop is too old, and Logstash is rarely used in >>> bigdata related projects, I'd like to propose we remove Logstash from >>> Bigtop stack. >>>> >>>> Since Elasticsearch still has lots of users, I recommend we can upgrade >>> it to 6.1.4 which is the latest version support JDK8 compilation, once we >>> are supporting JDK9 compilation, we can upgrade it to 6.2.4 as our final >>> supported version, if the compilation is conflicted with other components >>> in the future, we can remove Elasticsearch too. >>>> >>>> Regarding the Kibana, I'll try to upgrade it too, but I'm not sure if I >>> can fix the compilation errors since it's a NodeJS project and I'm not >> very >>> familiar with it, if I cannot fix it, and no one can help, I'd like to >>> remove it too. >>>> >>>> Can you please tell me your opinion? Thanks. >>>> >>>> Best Regards, >>>> Zhiguo Wu >>> >>
