On 19.05.2007 14:28, Grzegorz Kossakowski wrote:

But a service generator without any post data makes absolutely sense since it might really be optional to post anything. And I find it quite strange to write

That's not true. If you don't post a data it's not the service any more but you can call it that way:
<map:generate src="servlet:test2:/extract-html"/>

Using normal FileGenerator.

Ah, ok. I think I already read this somewhere in this thread.

You can argue that it's strange that if service is called we put it as parameter and if it's casual GET it is put in the src attribute. I'd disagree then because GET and POST are so much different that even different sitemap syntax makes sense.

One more reason to always put the service URL into the src attribute as you don't need to discuss and differentiate between GET and POST. The sitemap was always GET/POST-unaware. Now you would need to change the "nature" of your generator by changing its type instead of just removing one parameter.

Joerg

Reply via email to