dgrinchenko commented on a change in pull request #1820: DRILL-7307: casthigh 
for decimal type can lead to the issues with VarDecimalHolder
URL: https://github.com/apache/drill/pull/1820#discussion_r300637551
 
 

 ##########
 File path: 
exec/java-exec/src/main/java/org/apache/drill/exec/expr/EvaluationVisitor.java
 ##########
 @@ -1126,327 +1131,159 @@ public HoldingContainer 
visitFunctionCall(FunctionCall e, ClassGenerator<?> gene
           + "It should have been converted to FunctionHolderExpression in 
materialization");
     }
 
-    @Override
-    public HoldingContainer 
visitFunctionHolderExpression(FunctionHolderExpression e, ClassGenerator<?> 
generator)
+    private <T> HoldingContainer visitExpression(T e, ClassGenerator<?> 
generator, GetHolderCall getHolder)
         throws RuntimeException {
       if (constantBoundaries.contains(e)) {
         generator.getMappingSet().enterConstant();
-        HoldingContainer c = super.visitFunctionHolderExpression(e, generator);
-        // generator.getMappingSet().exitConstant();
-        // return c;
-        return renderConstantExpression(generator, c);
+        HoldingContainer c = getHolder.call();
+
+        return renderConstantExpression(generator, c, e);
       } else if (generator.getMappingSet().isWithinConstant()) {
-        return super.visitFunctionHolderExpression(e, 
generator).setConstant(true);
+        return getHolder.call().setConstant(true);
       } else {
-        return super.visitFunctionHolderExpression(e, generator);
+        return getHolder.call();
       }
     }
 
+    @Override
+    public HoldingContainer 
visitFunctionHolderExpression(FunctionHolderExpression e, ClassGenerator<?> 
generator)
+        throws RuntimeException {
+     return visitExpression(e, generator, () -> 
super.visitFunctionHolderExpression(e, generator));
+    }
+
     @Override
     public HoldingContainer visitBooleanOperator(BooleanOperator e, 
ClassGenerator<?> generator)
         throws RuntimeException {
-      if (constantBoundaries.contains(e)) {
-        generator.getMappingSet().enterConstant();
-        HoldingContainer c = super.visitBooleanOperator(e, generator);
-        return renderConstantExpression(generator, c);
-      } else if (generator.getMappingSet().isWithinConstant()) {
-        return super.visitBooleanOperator(e, generator).setConstant(true);
-      } else {
-        return super.visitBooleanOperator(e, generator);
-      }
+      return visitExpression(e, generator, () -> super.visitBooleanOperator(e, 
generator));
     }
     @Override
     public HoldingContainer visitIfExpression(IfExpression e, 
ClassGenerator<?> generator) throws RuntimeException {
-      if (constantBoundaries.contains(e)) {
-        generator.getMappingSet().enterConstant();
-        HoldingContainer c = super.visitIfExpression(e, generator);
-        // generator.getMappingSet().exitConstant();
-        // return c;
-        return renderConstantExpression(generator, c);
-      } else if (generator.getMappingSet().isWithinConstant()) {
-        return super.visitIfExpression(e, generator).setConstant(true);
-      } else {
-        return super.visitIfExpression(e, generator);
-      }
+      return visitExpression(e, generator, () -> super.visitIfExpression(e, 
generator));
     }
 
     @Override
     public HoldingContainer visitSchemaPath(SchemaPath e, ClassGenerator<?> 
generator) throws RuntimeException {
-      if (constantBoundaries.contains(e)) {
-        generator.getMappingSet().enterConstant();
-        HoldingContainer c = super.visitSchemaPath(e, generator);
-        // generator.getMappingSet().exitConstant();
-        // return c;
-        return renderConstantExpression(generator, c);
-      } else if (generator.getMappingSet().isWithinConstant()) {
-        return super.visitSchemaPath(e, generator).setConstant(true);
-      } else {
-        return super.visitSchemaPath(e, generator);
-      }
+      return visitExpression(e, generator, () -> super.visitSchemaPath(e, 
generator));
     }
 
     @Override
     public HoldingContainer visitLongConstant(LongExpression e, 
ClassGenerator<?> generator) throws RuntimeException {
-      if (constantBoundaries.contains(e)) {
-        generator.getMappingSet().enterConstant();
-        HoldingContainer c = super.visitLongConstant(e, generator);
-        // generator.getMappingSet().exitConstant();
-        // return c;
-        return renderConstantExpression(generator, c);
-      } else if (generator.getMappingSet().isWithinConstant()) {
-        return super.visitLongConstant(e, generator).setConstant(true);
-      } else {
-        return super.visitLongConstant(e, generator);
-      }
+      return visitExpression(e, generator, () -> super.visitLongConstant(e, 
generator));
     }
 
     @Override
     public HoldingContainer visitDecimal9Constant(Decimal9Expression e, 
ClassGenerator<?> generator)
         throws RuntimeException {
-      if (constantBoundaries.contains(e)) {
-        generator.getMappingSet().enterConstant();
-        HoldingContainer c = super.visitDecimal9Constant(e, generator);
-        return renderConstantExpression(generator, c);
-      } else if (generator.getMappingSet().isWithinConstant()) {
-        return super.visitDecimal9Constant(e, generator).setConstant(true);
-      } else {
-        return super.visitDecimal9Constant(e, generator);
-      }
+      return visitExpression(e, generator, () -> 
super.visitDecimal9Constant(e, generator));
     }
 
     @Override
     public HoldingContainer visitDecimal18Constant(Decimal18Expression e, 
ClassGenerator<?> generator)
         throws RuntimeException {
-      if (constantBoundaries.contains(e)) {
-        generator.getMappingSet().enterConstant();
-        HoldingContainer c = super.visitDecimal18Constant(e, generator);
-        return renderConstantExpression(generator, c);
-      } else if (generator.getMappingSet().isWithinConstant()) {
-        return super.visitDecimal18Constant(e, generator).setConstant(true);
-      } else {
-        return super.visitDecimal18Constant(e, generator);
-      }
+      return visitExpression(e, generator, () -> 
super.visitDecimal18Constant(e, generator));
     }
 
     @Override
     public HoldingContainer visitDecimal28Constant(Decimal28Expression e, 
ClassGenerator<?> generator)
         throws RuntimeException {
-      if (constantBoundaries.contains(e)) {
-        generator.getMappingSet().enterConstant();
-        HoldingContainer c = super.visitDecimal28Constant(e, generator);
-        return renderConstantExpression(generator, c);
-      } else if (generator.getMappingSet().isWithinConstant()) {
-        return super.visitDecimal28Constant(e, generator).setConstant(true);
-      } else {
-        return super.visitDecimal28Constant(e, generator);
-      }
+      return visitExpression(e, generator, () -> 
super.visitDecimal28Constant(e, generator));
     }
 
     @Override
     public HoldingContainer visitDecimal38Constant(Decimal38Expression e, 
ClassGenerator<?> generator)
         throws RuntimeException {
-      if (constantBoundaries.contains(e)) {
-        generator.getMappingSet().enterConstant();
-        HoldingContainer c = super.visitDecimal38Constant(e, generator);
-        return renderConstantExpression(generator, c);
-      } else if (generator.getMappingSet().isWithinConstant()) {
-        return super.visitDecimal38Constant(e, generator).setConstant(true);
-      } else {
-        return super.visitDecimal38Constant(e, generator);
-      }
+      return visitExpression(e, generator, () -> 
super.visitDecimal38Constant(e, generator));
     }
 
     @Override
     public HoldingContainer visitVarDecimalConstant(VarDecimalExpression e, 
ClassGenerator<?> generator)
         throws RuntimeException {
-      if (constantBoundaries.contains(e)) {
-        generator.getMappingSet().enterConstant();
-        HoldingContainer c = super.visitVarDecimalConstant(e, generator);
-        return renderConstantExpression(generator, c);
-      } else if (generator.getMappingSet().isWithinConstant()) {
-        return super.visitVarDecimalConstant(e, generator).setConstant(true);
-      } else {
-        return super.visitVarDecimalConstant(e, generator);
-      }
+      return visitExpression(e, generator, () -> 
super.visitVarDecimalConstant(e, generator));
     }
 
     @Override
     public HoldingContainer visitIntConstant(IntExpression e, 
ClassGenerator<?> generator) throws RuntimeException {
-      if (constantBoundaries.contains(e)) {
-        generator.getMappingSet().enterConstant();
-        HoldingContainer c = super.visitIntConstant(e, generator);
-        // generator.getMappingSet().exitConstant();
-        // return c;
-        return renderConstantExpression(generator, c);
-      } else if (generator.getMappingSet().isWithinConstant()) {
-        return super.visitIntConstant(e, generator).setConstant(true);
-      } else {
-        return super.visitIntConstant(e, generator);
-      }
+      return visitExpression(e, generator, () -> super.visitIntConstant(e, 
generator));
     }
 
     @Override
     public HoldingContainer visitDateConstant(DateExpression e, 
ClassGenerator<?> generator) throws RuntimeException {
-      if (constantBoundaries.contains(e)) {
-        generator.getMappingSet().enterConstant();
-        HoldingContainer c = super.visitDateConstant(e, generator);
-
-        return renderConstantExpression(generator, c);
-      } else if (generator.getMappingSet().isWithinConstant()) {
-        return super.visitDateConstant(e, generator).setConstant(true);
-      } else {
-        return super.visitDateConstant(e, generator);
-      }
+      return visitExpression(e, generator, () -> super.visitDateConstant(e, 
generator));
     }
 
     @Override
     public HoldingContainer visitTimeConstant(TimeExpression e, 
ClassGenerator<?> generator) throws RuntimeException {
-      if (constantBoundaries.contains(e)) {
-        generator.getMappingSet().enterConstant();
-        HoldingContainer c = super.visitTimeConstant(e, generator);
-
-        return renderConstantExpression(generator, c);
-      } else if (generator.getMappingSet().isWithinConstant()) {
-        return super.visitTimeConstant(e, generator).setConstant(true);
-      } else {
-        return super.visitTimeConstant(e, generator);
-      }
+      return visitExpression(e, generator, () -> super.visitTimeConstant(e, 
generator));
     }
 
     @Override
     public HoldingContainer visitIntervalYearConstant(IntervalYearExpression 
e, ClassGenerator<?> generator)
         throws RuntimeException {
-      if (constantBoundaries.contains(e)) {
-        generator.getMappingSet().enterConstant();
-        HoldingContainer c = super.visitIntervalYearConstant(e, generator);
-
-        return renderConstantExpression(generator, c);
-      } else if (generator.getMappingSet().isWithinConstant()) {
-        return super.visitIntervalYearConstant(e, generator).setConstant(true);
-      } else {
-        return super.visitIntervalYearConstant(e, generator);
-      }
+      return visitExpression(e, generator, () -> 
super.visitIntervalYearConstant(e, generator));
     }
 
     @Override
     public HoldingContainer visitTimeStampConstant(TimeStampExpression e, 
ClassGenerator<?> generator)
         throws RuntimeException {
-      if (constantBoundaries.contains(e)) {
-        generator.getMappingSet().enterConstant();
-        HoldingContainer c = super.visitTimeStampConstant(e, generator);
-
-        return renderConstantExpression(generator, c);
-      } else if (generator.getMappingSet().isWithinConstant()) {
-        return super.visitTimeStampConstant(e, generator).setConstant(true);
-      } else {
-        return super.visitTimeStampConstant(e, generator);
-      }
+      return visitExpression(e, generator, () -> 
super.visitTimeStampConstant(e, generator));
     }
 
     @Override
     public HoldingContainer visitFloatConstant(FloatExpression e, 
ClassGenerator<?> generator)
         throws RuntimeException {
-      if (constantBoundaries.contains(e)) {
-        generator.getMappingSet().enterConstant();
-        HoldingContainer c = super.visitFloatConstant(e, generator);
-        // generator.getMappingSet().exitConstant();
-        // return c;
-        return renderConstantExpression(generator, c);
-      } else if (generator.getMappingSet().isWithinConstant()) {
-        return super.visitFloatConstant(e, generator).setConstant(true);
-      } else {
-        return super.visitFloatConstant(e, generator);
-      }
+      return visitExpression(e, generator, () -> super.visitFloatConstant(e, 
generator));
     }
 
     @Override
     public HoldingContainer visitDoubleConstant(DoubleExpression e, 
ClassGenerator<?> generator)
         throws RuntimeException {
-      if (constantBoundaries.contains(e)) {
-        generator.getMappingSet().enterConstant();
-        HoldingContainer c = super.visitDoubleConstant(e, generator);
-        // generator.getMappingSet().exitConstant();
-        // return c;
-        return renderConstantExpression(generator, c);
-      } else if (generator.getMappingSet().isWithinConstant()) {
-        return super.visitDoubleConstant(e, generator).setConstant(true);
-      } else {
-        return super.visitDoubleConstant(e, generator);
-      }
+      return visitExpression(e, generator, () -> super.visitDoubleConstant(e, 
generator));
     }
 
     @Override
     public HoldingContainer visitBooleanConstant(BooleanExpression e, 
ClassGenerator<?> generator)
         throws RuntimeException {
-      if (constantBoundaries.contains(e)) {
-        generator.getMappingSet().enterConstant();
-        HoldingContainer c = super.visitBooleanConstant(e, generator);
-        // generator.getMappingSet().exitConstant();
-        // return c;
-        return renderConstantExpression(generator, c);
-      } else if (generator.getMappingSet().isWithinConstant()) {
-        return super.visitBooleanConstant(e, generator).setConstant(true);
-      } else {
-        return super.visitBooleanConstant(e, generator);
-      }
+      return visitExpression(e, generator, () -> super.visitBooleanConstant(e, 
generator));
     }
 
     @Override
     public HoldingContainer visitUnknown(LogicalExpression e, 
ClassGenerator<?> generator) throws RuntimeException {
-      if (constantBoundaries.contains(e)) {
-        generator.getMappingSet().enterConstant();
-        HoldingContainer c = super.visitUnknown(e, generator);
-        // generator.getMappingSet().exitConstant();
-        // return c;
-        return renderConstantExpression(generator, c);
-      } else if (generator.getMappingSet().isWithinConstant()) {
-        return super.visitUnknown(e, generator).setConstant(true);
-      } else {
-        return super.visitUnknown(e, generator);
-      }
+      return visitExpression(e, generator, () -> super.visitUnknown(e, 
generator));
     }
 
     @Override
     public HoldingContainer visitQuotedStringConstant(QuotedString e, 
ClassGenerator<?> generator)
         throws RuntimeException {
-      if (constantBoundaries.contains(e)) {
-        generator.getMappingSet().enterConstant();
-        HoldingContainer c = super.visitQuotedStringConstant(e, generator);
-        // generator.getMappingSet().exitConstant();
-        // return c;
-        return renderConstantExpression(generator, c);
-      } else if (generator.getMappingSet().isWithinConstant()) {
-        return super.visitQuotedStringConstant(e, generator).setConstant(true);
-      } else {
-        return super.visitQuotedStringConstant(e, generator);
-      }
+      return visitExpression(e, generator, () -> 
super.visitQuotedStringConstant(e, generator));
     }
 
     @Override
     public HoldingContainer visitIntervalDayConstant(IntervalDayExpression e, 
ClassGenerator<?> generator)
         throws RuntimeException {
-      if (constantBoundaries.contains(e)) {
-        generator.getMappingSet().enterConstant();
-        HoldingContainer c = super.visitIntervalDayConstant(e, generator);
-
-        return renderConstantExpression(generator, c);
-      } else if (generator.getMappingSet().isWithinConstant()) {
-        return super.visitIntervalDayConstant(e, generator).setConstant(true);
-      } else {
-        return super.visitIntervalDayConstant(e, generator);
-      }
+      return visitExpression(e, generator, () -> 
super.visitIntervalDayConstant(e, generator));
     }
 
     /*
      * Get a HoldingContainer for a constant expression. The returned
      * HoldingContainder will indicate it's for a constant expression.
      */
-    private HoldingContainer renderConstantExpression(ClassGenerator<?> 
generator, HoldingContainer input) {
-      JVar fieldValue = generator.declareClassField("constant", 
generator.getHolderType(input.getMajorType()));
+    private <T> HoldingContainer renderConstantExpression(ClassGenerator<?> 
generator, HoldingContainer input,
 
 Review comment:
   it makes no sense, as we need `DrillFuncHolderExpr` to get information about 
null handling for the expression. The override logic is applied only for 
NULL_IF_NULL functions. With the suggested changes, the only way would be to 
override `mode` for each `FunctionHolderExpression` or do the same check inside 
render for the `FunctionHolderExpression` 

----------------------------------------------------------------
This is an automated message from the Apache Git Service.
To respond to the message, please log on to GitHub and use the
URL above to go to the specific comment.
 
For queries about this service, please contact Infrastructure at:
[email protected]


With regards,
Apache Git Services

Reply via email to