I agree, something like this would be very much welcomed. regards,
Karl On Mon, Jul 27, 2009 at 8:36 AM, Felix Meschberger<fmesc...@gmail.com> wrote: > Hi, > > I would welcome a one-stop-shop solution for a standalone and bridged > environment. Currently, in Apache Sling, we are using either the > standalone Jetty based implementation or the Eclipse bridge depending on > how we build. > > Having a single-solution might come very handy. > > So to second Richard, I suggest you create a JIRA (ensure to check the > "ASF inclusion permission box" when uploading the tar or patch) so that > we can have a look and then discuss on how to proceed ? > > Thanks and Regards > Felix > > Richard S. Hall schrieb: >> I would certainly be happy to consider it for a replacement to the >> existing impl. However, since I am not a big user of the existing impl >> (even though I started it a long, long time ago), I guess we need to >> hear from people who work and rely on the current impl. >> >> What would be cool, is if you could create a tar ball and make it >> available so people could play with it. You could always create a JIRA >> issue and attach it to that...that's the best way to get the ball >> rolling to see if there is interest here for accepting it as a >> contribution. >> >> Thanks. >> >> -> richard >> >> On 7/26/09 4:13 PM, Sten Roger Sandvik wrote: >>> Hi. >>> >>> I have looked at the HttpService implementation in Felix and I had some >>> thoughts on how to improve the functionality. Over the past year I have >>> looked long and hard for a solution that has the following features: >>> >>> * Run inside a WAR on a 3rd part container. >>> * Run stand-alone (using jetty). >>> * Has servlet filter support. >>> * Using whiteboard pattern for registering servlets / filters. >>> >>> The road led me to Pax Web (supports filters, but only as a stand-alone >>> service) and Equinox Servlet Bridge (does not support filters). >>> Whiteboard >>> registering pattern is implemented by the Pax guys, but does not support >>> filters inside a "bridged" environment. >>> >>> So, eventually I was tired of looking for a solution out there and >>> created >>> my own. This supports servlets and filters in both stand-alone and >>> bridged >>> mode (WAR). Now I have come to a fork in the road. Should I donate the >>> code >>> or host my own. I prefer to donate the code. But is the right place under >>> Felix umbrella or Pax Web umbrella? I see that more and more is created >>> under Felix and this implementation would be (in my opinion) a great >>> addition. >>> >>> So, what do you guys think? >>> >>> BR, >>> Sten Roger Sandvik >>> >>> >> > -- Karl Pauls karlpa...@gmail.com
