On Sun, Mar 18, 2018 at 8:05 PM David Blevins <[email protected]> wrote:
> Two votes are up in the TomEE community on what to do with PR #123 ( > https://github.com/apache/tomee/pull/123 ). The first vote is if TomEE > should merge it. The second vote is if TomEE should attempt to extract it. > > Ok, this helps a lot. Thanks David! > It was said 3-4 times in the discussion between both communities "geronimo > will have a jwt-auth impl." This is absolutely ok, there is no rule that > two projects cannot do the same or similar thing. Apache Tamaya exists and > there is a Geronimo Config, both aim at MicroProfile Config compliance. > This is OK by ASF standards and one community is not judged good or bad for > choosing to also implement something. > Yes, and with that said its even completely valid for us to take the code from TomEE and drop it in to a separate Geronimo library, if that's the route we take. However, we would need to figure out what that dividing line is in the code between standalone library & TomEE specific integration. > > That said, decisions like this should be made by the project clearly. > Some people may want to move ahead now. Some people may want to wait and > see how things go with TomEE. > > Vote: Move ahead with creating a reusable JWT module > > +1 Let's get on this, now. There may be two impls, but that's ok. > -+0 > -1 Let's wait / maybe later / other > > > +1 for what you've said. > -David > >
