IMO, I'm inclined to use Github wiki for several reasons: 1. The document hub is mainly used to maintain and centralize some development related things, like design doc, meeting minutes, we don't need some fancy functionalities for Confluence. 2. We already use Github to manage all the things, like issues, projects, CIs, it would be better also putting the docs on the Github, so that it will be easier for users to find out. On the contrary, Confluence is a different place, we need to manage one more place besides Github.
Thanks Jerry Xiaojing Fang <xiaoj...@datastrato.com> 于2024年8月19日周一 21:39写道： > +1 (binding) for GitHub wiki, Confluence offers more advanced features, > while Wiki is simpler and integrates with GitHub. Since our primary goal is > to organize documents and our requirements are straightforward, I prefer > using Wiki. > > > 2024年8月19日 20:30，roryqi <ror...@apache.org> 写道： > > > > After surveying on many Apache projects, only Superset uses Github wiki. > > Its wiki only shows simple information. > > ASF Confluence is adopted by many projects. It seems more formal. > > > > +1 (non-binding) for ASF Confluence. > > > > Rory > > > > Minghuang Li <mcha...@apache.org> 于2024年8月19日周一 19:11写道： > > > >> Hi Jerry, > >> > >> Thank you for bringing this up. I fully support establishing a hub for > >> developer and community > >> documentation. > >> > >> ASF Confluence is preferable due to its richer features, despite GitHub > >> wiki's proximity to our > >> codebase. > >> > >> I endorse moving forward with Confluence for better document management. > >> > >> Best regards, > >> Minghuang Li > >> > >> On 2024/08/19 10:15:18 Saisai Shao wrote: > >>> Hi team, > >>> > >>> Currently, we have user-facing docs for users, but we're lacking > >>> developer-facing docs for developers. By investigating other projects, > >> they > >>> typically use Github wiki or ASF confluence for developer/community > >> related > >>> things. > >>> > >>> So here are two questions: > >>> > >>> 1. Shall we have a developer/community face document hub to manage all > >> the > >>> docs? > >>> 2. If so, what is your preference, Github wiki or ASF confluence? > >>> > >>> Best, > >>> Jerry > >>> > >> > >
