Hi Jiunn-Yang, A few more comments I'm afraid. AS12: I see that you've added the group creation time to bin/kafka-consumer-groups.sh --describe --state. This seems to me like a very detailed piece of information which clutters the output for normal users. Would it be more appropriate to add the new information to the --state --verbose output instead, as was done with the epochs?
AS13: Looking at the change for bin/kafka-consumer-groups.sh --reset-offset, I think --to-start-time would be better than --by-start-time. We do have by-duration but that's relative to the current time. For the start time, you're setting to an absolute time which is the group's creation time. I know this would change the config, the command-line flag, and so on, so it's quite a pervasive change. This is just an opinion of course, so feel free to ignore it. AS14: I expect that it's appropriate to make the same additions to bin/kafka-streams-groups.sh as in AS12/13. Thanks, Andrew On 2026/04/10 17:41:33 黃竣陽 wrote: > Hello chia, > > Thanks for your suggestions, > > I have added following changes for kafka-consumer-groups.sh > * --describe --state gains a GROUP-CREATION-TIME column displaying > the group creation timestamp in ISO-8601 UTC format. > > * --reset-offsets gains a new --by-start-time option that uses the group > creation timestamp as the reference point for ListOffsets. > > Best Regards > Jiunn-Yang > > > Chia-Ping Tsai <[email protected]> 於 2026年4月11日 凌晨12:54 寫道： > > > > should `kafka-consumer-groups.sh` support the new policy? > >
