Hi, On Tue, Oct 31, 2023, at 23:53, Ralph Goers wrote: > Deprecation and moving to separate modules are not the same thing at > all. I would be +1 to moving everything on this list that isn’t > outright removed to separate repos. I have stated that several times.
I am fully aware of that. This is about adding a deprecated label to 2.x components and schedule them for removal in 3.x. That why I quickly give my +1, because 3.x is still in alpha, and we can step back from this decision if needed. > Gary is strongly against doing that. > > If you are somehow equating deprecation with moving to a separate repo > then you are voting on the wrong thing. This vote is basically on what > will be removed and no longer supported in 3.x. No I am voting on the right thing. I am suggesting we are doing a separate vote to move out all JNDI related components to their own repo. I am aware Gary is opposed to this, but I am strongly in favor to such a move. Reading my message, I see where this confusion comes from; sorry for that. I should have made my two points more clear. Anyway, still voting +1 on deprecation for now > > Ralph > >> On Oct 31, 2023, at 2:00 PM, Christian Grobmeier <grobme...@apache.org> >> wrote: >> >> +1 to all - deprecation to me means we add a label that we plan to remove it >> in 3.x, but we are not removing it not. We can step back. >> >> Many of those modules don't look as if they need to belong in the main repo. >> I can accept kubernetes/docker stuff, but not in the main repo. >> >> I have a strong +1 on removing all JNDI features immediately, making them >> available for those poor souls in a separate repo. I opened another thread >> where I asked why we need this at all because it seems pointless to me. JNDI >> is also a hazardous word within this project. >> >> About the rest I don't have strong feelings >> >> On Mon, Oct 30, 2023, at 09:44, Piotr P. Karwasz wrote: >>> This is a vote to deprecate the following `2.x` modules and features >>> and remove them from the `3.x` release: >>> >>> * `log4j-cassandra`: >>> * CouchDB appender: >>> * `log4j-docker` >>> * GELF appender: >>> * Kafka appender: >>> * `log4j-kubernetes`: >>> * JeroMQ appender: >>> * JNDI-related features: >>> * `log4j-jpa`: >>> * Jackson based layouts (JsonLayout, XmlLayout, YamlLayout) >>> * `log4j-mongodb3`: >>> * `log4j-spring-boot`: >>> * Java EE SMTP appender: >>> * Jakarta EE SMTP appender: >>> * `log4j-taglib`: >>> >>> Please cast votes for each module/feature separately on this mailing list: >>> >>> [ ] +1, drop the artifact/module, >>> [ ] +/-0 >>> [ ] -1, keep the artifact/module, because... >>> >>> This vote is open for 168 hours (i.e. one week) and each deprecation >>> will pass unless getting a net negative vote count. All votes are >>> welcome, but only the Logging Services PMC votes are officially >>> counted. >>> >>> Piotr
