I just placed tomahawk 1.1.3 in with core 1.1.3 .  I found that each formless 
commandLink threw an exception.  I have not been following the tomahawk stuff 
as closely as I should - I take it this was done in order to increase 
inter-operability?

Yes disallowing formless command link is necessary for use with the
RI.  I'm not the expert on this topic but those who have looked into
this tell me as much.

If this is the plan, I think there are going to be a lot of confused developers 
- even if the release announcement and the MyFaces home page warns about this.  
Remember how many messages there were even after Martin had specifically 
mentioned the last tomahawk release could not be used with the older versions 
of MyFaces?

Yes release notes and website notes are a minimum but probably not sufficient.

I don't want to hold up the tomahawk release, but I actually think a better 
logging would be needed here.  It is especially difficult to track this down 
when the logs tell you to find the control _idJsp0 .  Can we give the path to 
component, as well as a suggestion to change h:commandLink to t:commandLink ?

No problem.  Can you add this code now?  If you can't do svn commit
just send your patch to this thread and someone will apply it to the
branch.

Dennis Byrne

Sean

Reply via email to