Hmm difficult topic. Please allow me a few questions:
a.) Trinidad components would still work with using either Orchestra conversations or CODI? b) You are not relying on other components or the users using your conversation stuff if they don't like? c) if the user doesn't make use of this feature, it will not pollute the viewRoot or cause heavy performance hits? If all this is ok, then there is imo no argument against adding it to Trinidad. This doesn't mean I like it either, but it doesn't hurt at least ;) LieGrue, strub > >From: Gerhard Petracek <[email protected]> >To: MyFaces Development <[email protected]> >Sent: Wed, July 21, 2010 10:16:23 AM >Subject: Re: [Trinidad][api]TRINIDAD-1857 Add a Map associated with each >window > >or tab that the user is interacting with > >i agree with martin. > > >regards, >gerhard > >http://www.irian.at > >Your JSF powerhouse - >JSF Consulting, Development and >Courses in English and German > >Professional Support for Apache MyFaces > > > > > >2010/7/21 Martin Marinschek <[email protected]> > >Hi Matthias, >> >> >>> Not everybody is using CDI and/or Spring. >> >>well, in the real world and a little while in the future, there is not >>many people who will not have one of these frameworks in their >>applications. >> >> >>> I think, on long term we may want one clean and independent API, where >>> all these projects offer an implementation for a window/event system: >>> -CODI >>> -Orchestra >>> -Trinidad >>> -etc >>> >>> However, right now, Trinidad has the base already and adding a new >>> toolset to the belt feels kinda wrong. >>> Again +1 on this to be inside of Trinidad. >>> >>> This does not mean that we could work on a better future version of a >>> more unified API, for this. Right? >> >>yes, this is what we could and what we should. Why not take this >>addition as a reason to do this right now? If we don´t take such >>additions as a reason to do this, what else will be our reason? >> >>best regards, >> >>Martin >> >>-- >> >> >>http://www.irian.at >> >>Your JSF powerhouse - >>JSF Consulting, Development and >>Courses in English and German >> >>Professional Support for Apache MyFaces >> >
