Hi, I checked: - incubating in artefact names - signatures and hashes fine - LICENSE and NOTICE are OK - Found an unexpected comped fine in the source release [1] - ASF files don’t have correct headers - Had some issues compiling
From the ASF side there some minor things, most of them are likely to get a -1 vote with a WIP disclaimer. One may do as some IPMC members may question the lack of ASF headers without that being explicitly called out. For the Nuttx package: - It's a good idea to publish your keys to a public server - It’s a good idea to sign it with your apache.org email address - It would be nice to see more than " * Releases may have incomplete licensing conditions.” in the WIP disclaimer - In NOTICE I’d move "This product includes software developed at” to the top - There is a large number of files without ASF headers that have been donated to the ASF (this should also be mentioned in the disclaimer) - The source release contains what looks to be compiled code [1] (I would also mention this in the disclaimer) - LICENSE is missing some licenses (again should be mentioned in the disclaimer) - README needs updated e.g "Download and unpack” section, the word Apache is not used once even though it’s now teh project is “Apache Nuttx (incubating)” not “Nuttx”, and you usually have some pointers to the community where you can go for for help or to submit patches. "Downloading from Repositories” is also still referring to bitbucket. Some of the above also applies to for the app package as well. What a good board to try on OSX? I tried a few at random that are popular or that I know but couldn't get the config script to work. Thanks, Justin 1. ./boards/arm/sama5/sama5d3-xplained/boot/uImage
