Hi Francesco, I checked points 2. and 3. Which you have mentioned.
For 2. Point I can not find the difference. I downloaded http://people.apache.org/~mibo/olingo4/4.0.0-beta-01-RC01/Olingo-OData-4.0. 0-beta-01-RC01-source-release.zip And compared it to https://git-wip-us.apache.org/repos/asf?p=olingo-odata4.git;a=commit;h=825b 7db6b1b03ea2d3a97c221810094187cf88ce And both does not contain to "old" "...olingo-..." parts. For 3. Point I'am not sure. In Olingo for OData V2 we had those additional license mentioned within the DEPENDENCIES and LICENSE files. So for Olingo for OData V4 we also mentioned it there. If you take a look into those files within the: http://people.apache.org/~mibo/olingo4/4.0.0-beta-01-RC01/Olingo-OData-Clie nt-for-Android-4.0.0-beta-01-RC01-lib.zip http://people.apache.org/~mibo/olingo4/4.0.0-beta-01-RC01/Olingo-OData-Clie nt-for-Java-4.0.0-beta-01-RC01-lib.zip http://people.apache.org/~mibo/olingo4/4.0.0-beta-01-RC01/Olingo-OData-Serv er-for-Java-4.0.0-beta-01-RC01-lib.zip So IMHO I think this is Ok with http://apache.org/legal/resolved.html#required-third-party-notices Kind regards, Michael On 15.09.14 09:01, "Bolz, Michael" <[email protected]> wrote: >Hi Francesco, > >Thanks for validation and feedback. >I will check point 2. and 3. and if necessary prepare a RC02. >Point 1. will be fixed with next announcement mail ;o) > >Kind regards, >Michael > > > > > >On 15.09.14 08:42, "Francesco Chicchiriccò" <[email protected]> wrote: > >>Hi Michael, >>few notes: >> >> 1. the URL for KEYS is wrong: it should be >>https://dist.apache.org/repos/dist/release/olingo/KEYS (e.g. without >>'incubator') >> >> 2. if I compare the content of >>'Olingo-OData-4.0.0-beta-01-RC01-source-release.zip' with the tag >>'4.0.0-beta-01-RC01' I can find the following differences: >> >>4c4 >>< <artifactId>odata-ext</artifactId> >>--- >> > <artifactId>olingo-ext</artifactId> >>6c6 >>< <version>4.0.0-beta-01-RC01</version> >>--- >> > <version>4.0.0-beta-01-SNAPSHOT</version> >>9c9 >>< <artifactId>odata-client-android</artifactId> >>--- >> > <artifactId>olingo-client-android</artifactId> >>35,39c35,39 >>< <include>org.apache.olingo:odata-client-proxy</include> >>< <include>org.apache.olingo:odata-client-core</include> >>< <include>org.apache.olingo:odata-client-api</include> >>< <include>org.apache.olingo:odata-commons-core</include> >>< <include>org.apache.olingo:odata-commons-api</include> >>--- >> > <include>org.apache.olingo:olingo-client-proxy</include> >> > <include>org.apache.olingo:olingo-client-core</include> >> > <include>org.apache.olingo:olingo-client-api</include> >> > <include>org.apache.olingo:olingo-commons-core</include> >> > <include>org.apache.olingo:olingo-commons-api</include> >> >>while they are supposed to be *exactly* the same >> >> 3. I have seen that NOTICE files for (at least) >> * Olingo-OData-Client-for-Android-4.0.0-beta-01-RC01-lib.zip >> * Olingo-OData-Client-for-Java-4.0.0-beta-01-RC01-lib.zip >> >>are empty: are you sure that no one of their dependencies is requiring >>Third-party Notices [1]? >>I know, for example, that SLF4J requires an explicit notice [2]: " The >>above copyright notice and this permission notice shall be included in >>all copies or substantial portions of the Software.", so I would expect >>that the relevant NOTICE files in Olingo contain the text >> >>"This products includes software developed by SLF4J >>(http://www.slf4j.org) >>Copyright (c) 2004-2013 QOS.ch." >> >>Regards. >> >>[1] http://apache.org/legal/resolved.html#required-third-party-notices >>[2] http://slf4j.org/license.html >> >>On 12/09/2014 15:04, Bolz, Michael wrote: >>> Hi All, >>> >>> This is a vote on first release candidate (RC01) for Apache Olingo >>>release version "4.0.0-beta-01". >>> The vote will be open for at least 72 hours (it will closed on Monday >>>15/09/2014 on 4pm CET) and passes if no vote is (-1). >>> >>> [ ] +1 Release this package as Apache Olingo 4.0.0-beta-01 >>> [ ] -1 Do not release this package because... >>> >>> >>> The release candidate is available here: >>> http://people.apache.org/~mibo/olingo4/4.0.0-beta-01-RC01/ >>> >>> The release candidate has been signed through the key 15AB5637 in: >>> http://keyserver.kjsl.org:11371/pks/lookup?search=0x15AB5637&op=vindex >>> >>> The release candidate is based on the sources tagged with >>>4.0.0-beta-01-RC01: >>> >>>https://git-wip-us.apache.org/repos/asf?p=olingo-odata4.git;a=commit;h=8 >>>2 >>>5b7db6b1b03ea2d3a97c221810094187cf88ce >>> >>> and is based on the following commit id: >>>825b7db6b1b03ea2d3a97c221810094187cf88ce >>> >>> The Olingo keys file can be found here: >>> https://dist.apache.org/repos/dist/release/incubator/olingo/KEYS >>> >>> To perform a RAT check please use the following parameters: >>> mvn clean install -Pbuild.quality >>> This will assure that the RAT check is performed with the necessary >>>excludes. >>> >>> Release distribution files: >>> // compilable sources >>> Olingo-OData-4.0.0-beta-01-RC01-source-release.zip >>> Olingo-OData-4.0.0-beta-01-RC01-source-release.zip.asc >>> Olingo-OData-4.0.0-beta-01-RC01-source-release.zip.md5 >>> Olingo-OData-4.0.0-beta-01-RC01-source-release.zip.sha512 >>> >>> // javadoc distribution >>> Olingo-OData-JavaDoc-4.0.0-beta-01-RC01-javadoc.zip >>> Olingo-OData-JavaDoc-4.0.0-beta-01-RC01-javadoc.zip.asc >>> Olingo-OData-JavaDoc-4.0.0-beta-01-RC01-javadoc.zip.md5 >>> Olingo-OData-JavaDoc-4.0.0-beta-01-RC01-javadoc.zip.sha512 >>> >>> // odata client distribution for Android with dependencies >>> Olingo-OData-Client-for-Android-4.0.0-beta-01-RC01-lib.zip >>> Olingo-OData-Client-for-Android-4.0.0-beta-01-RC01-lib.zip.asc >>> Olingo-OData-Client-for-Android-4.0.0-beta-01-RC01-lib.zip.md5 >>> Olingo-OData-Client-for-Android-4.0.0-beta-01-RC01-lib.zip.sha512 >>> >>> // odata client distribution for Java with dependencies >>> Olingo-OData-Client-for-Java-4.0.0-beta-01-RC01-lib.zip >>> Olingo-OData-Client-for-Java-4.0.0-beta-01-RC01-lib.zip.asc >>> Olingo-OData-Client-for-Java-4.0.0-beta-01-RC01-lib.zip.md5 >>> Olingo-OData-Client-for-Java-4.0.0-beta-01-RC01-lib.zip.sha512 >>> >>> // odata server distribution for Java with dependencies >>> Olingo-OData-Server-for-Java-4.0.0-beta-01-RC01-lib.zip >>> Olingo-OData-Server-for-Java-4.0.0-beta-01-RC01-lib.zip.asc >>> Olingo-OData-Server-for-Java-4.0.0-beta-01-RC01-lib.zip.md5 >>> Olingo-OData-Server-for-Java-4.0.0-beta-01-RC01-lib.zip.sha512 >>> >>> Kind Regards, >>> Michael >> >>-- >>Francesco Chicchiriccò >> >>Tirasa - Open Source Excellence >>http://www.tirasa.net/ >> >>Involved at The Apache Software Foundation: >>member, Syncope PMC chair, Cocoon PMC, Olingo PMC >>http://people.apache.org/~ilgrosso/ >> >>
smime.p7s
Description: S/MIME cryptographic signature
