Thanks Chris for the correctness. > Morris Tai however is a committer and not a PMC member, so his vote > counts as +1, but not as binding +1 vote.
Yes, Morris Tai is not a PMC member; I mistakenly included him. I will pay closer attention to the PMC status in the next vote. > And for Suyan, I couldn't > really find any PMC member or committer, that would fit that name. Suyan (Han Xu) is one of our PMC members. I will update our voting results template to instruct our release managers to always use the public names for PMC members instead of nicknames, which may not be familiar outside of the community. On Tue, Mar 19, 2024, at 22:00, Christofer Dutz wrote: > Hi all, > > while going through your projects activity as part of my process of > reviewing the board reports for this week's board meeting, I noticed > that I count 4 votes, however in the result these are all counted as > "binding" votes. > > Morris Tai however is a committer and not a PMC member, so his vote > counts as +1, but not as binding +1 vote. And for Suyan, I couldn't > really find any PMC member or committer, that would fit that name. > > So if Suyan happens to be a PMC member, then all is ok, but if he/she > is not a PMC member, you quickly need to add a third binding +1 vote to > that release, or the release will have to be taken offline. > > In the future it would generally be good, if for voting the names would > be used, that we have on file in whimsy as otherwise it is really > challenging to allign votes and PMC members. > > Chris -- Xuanwo
