On Fri, Jun 7, 2013 at 5:32 PM, Guenter Marxen <guenter.mar...@googlemail.com> wrote: > Hi Rob, > > you invited all to vote (although only pmc member votes are binding). > > You did not report the non-pmc-votes. Are they not worth to be reported or > was there a complete other (perhaps unwanted) result? >
I did not tally those votes since they were non-binding. However, all votes were echoed to the mailing list and are available in the archives, if anyone wants to analyze them further. Regards, -Rob > Günter Marxen > > Am 06.06.2013 19:11, schrieb Rob Weir: >> >> Here are the binding votes, with names abbreviated as: >> >> CR = Chris Rottensteiner >> KGa = Kevin Grignon A >> KGb = Kevin Grignon AB >> SM = Samer Monsour >> none = none of the above >> >> >> PMC 1st 2nd 3rd 4th 5th >> robweir CR KGa KGb SM >> regina none CR Logo-39 Logo-28 >> rgb-es none SM CR KGa KGb >> arist SM CR KGa none >> kschenk Logo-28 Logo-31 KGb CR none >> pescetti CR SM none KGa KGb >> hdu KGa KGb Logo-11 SM CR >> khirano none KGa CR SM KGb >> mayongl none CR KGa >> alg none CR SM KGb KGa >> orw CR SM none >> jsc CR none SM KGa >> af CR SM KGa none >> arielch none >> pj CR Logo-04 >> >> We have 15 ballots, so 8 votes are required to win. >> >> With Instant Runoff Voting we proceed in multiple rounds. In each >> round we tally the votes, see if anyone logo has the majority. If >> none do, then we drop the lowest scoring logo and reallocate the votes >> for those who picked the lowest scoring logo to their next ordered >> preference. Ties are broken by "looking forward" to next level >> preferences. >> >> Round 1 >> ------------ >> >> CR: 6 votes >> none: 6 votes >> SM: 1 vote >> Logo-28: 1 vote >> >> There is a tie for last place (SM and Logo-28) so we look forward to >> 2nd place preferences as a tiebreaker and see that SM has 4 votes and >> Logo-28 has zero. So we drop Logo-28 and move to Kay's 2nd preference >> (Logo-31) for Round 2. >> >> Round 2 >> ------------ >> >> CR: 6 votes >> none: 6 votes >> SM: 1 vote >> Logo-31: 1 vote >> >> Again, no logo has a majority, so we drop the lowest scoring logo. >> Again, a tie, so we look forward at next preferences where SM has 4 >> votes and Logo-31 has zero. So we drop Logo-31 and move to Kay's next >> preference (KGb) for Round 3. >> >> Round 3 >> ------------ >> >> CR: 6 votes >> none: 6 votes >> SM: 1 vote >> KGb: 1 vote >> >> Again, no logo has a majority, so we drop the lowest scoring logo. >> Again, a tie, so we look forward at next preference where SM has 4 >> votes and KGb has 1. So we drop KGb and move to Kay's next preference >> (CR) for Round 4. >> >> Round 4 >> ------------ >> >> CR: 7 votes >> none: 6 votes >> SM: 1 vote >> >> Again, no logo has a majority, so we drop the lowest scoring logo, SM, >> and reallocate Andrew's vote to his next choice, CR for round 5. >> >> Round 5 >> ------------ >> >> CR: 8 votes >> none: 6 votes >> >> CR now has the majority and wins. Note this is intuitively obvious as >> well, since 75% of the ballots rated CR higher than none. >> >> Regards, >> >> -Rob >> >> --------------------------------------------------------------------- >> To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscr...@openoffice.apache.org >> For additional commands, e-mail: dev-h...@openoffice.apache.org >> > > -- > Grüße > > Günter Marxen > > > --------------------------------------------------------------------- > To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscr...@openoffice.apache.org > For additional commands, e-mail: dev-h...@openoffice.apache.org > --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: dev-unsubscr...@openoffice.apache.org For additional commands, e-mail: dev-h...@openoffice.apache.org
