Hello André,
Le 16 sept. 08 à 12:29, Andre Schnabel a écrit :
Hi Charles,
-------- Original-Nachricht --------
Von: "Charles-H. Schulz" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
+1 from my side. I would however appreciate a discussion on my
proposal on the eligibility of Category leads and more NLC
representatives (in the Talk section of the charter proposal).
Sorry, I found you comments in the talk section just a few days ago
and did not comment on it yet.
no problem. John also wrote some comments there I think.
For eligibility of Cathegory leads:
they are eligible, as *everey* community member is eligible.
(if this is not obvious in the current draft, feel free to change
the wording)
Thank you, but I have to say that not only this is not obvious, but I
wouldn't even know where to change the wording in the proposal. Could
you please elaborate on this? Your help would be much welcome.
more NLC representatives:
I second your opinion, that NLC is a vers strong and important part
of the OOo community, doing a lot of work. And (as I still feel "at
home"
in the NLC) I'm in favour of a strong position of the NLC in the
council.
But - every part of the OOo community is important and needs a good
representation within the council. If we do not want a "unlimited"
number of
council members, we had to remove some other seats. No matter how you
deal with this - it would be somewhat unfair to any of the groups.
I think, two "NLC" representatives are ok, as there is one good thing
about NLC: we are used to be multitalents :)
Means - people from NLC do not only work in NLC projects, but do a lot
of work in other projects (documentation, qa, marketing,
development ...)
I think, all these can perfectly be represented by other council
members
(Code / Project contribution reps). The NLC-Representatives may focus
on the very special situation of NLC teams (e.g. multi cultural
topics,
language barriers ...)
Hope this answers some of your concerns.
I agree with what you said. We are not anymore in a situation where
NLC was a secluded area. Today you are a very example of a
"multitalent", and there are of course many others. We see them on the
QA, marketing , dba, porting, api, and documentation projects to name
just a few. I am not very worried about the yield of the NLC as such.
There is no case to be made any more on this, as this has already been
done by the contributions of our members over the past years. Yet I
would like again to outline my initial intent: the real issue here is
the one of representativity. That's not a troll, don't worry. I know
people stemming from the native-language projects are everywhere; some
even own cws. But it does not change the fact that NLC has too few
representatives *relative to what the other constituencies have*. The
outcome of this is that the interests and the voice of native-language
projects may be very well represented as it has always been but its
actual influence is diminished by the number of representatives. One
cannot open a -meaningful and important- discussion on how to reform
the representativity of the CC by only taking into account code
developers. To me and although it's a bit indirect on the paper NLC
does represent as well the voice of localizers; these people are
developers as well, and one could see this extended to the people in
charge of the QA... but you know all this :-)
Do you understand my concerns?
best,
Charles.
André
--
Ist Ihr Browser Vista-kompatibel? Jetzt die neuesten
Browser-Versionen downloaden: http://www.gmx.net/de/go/browser
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]