Hello André,
Le 16 sept. 08 à 15:58, Andre Schnabel a écrit :
Hi Charles,
-------- Original-Nachricht --------
Von: "Charles-H.Schulz" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
For eligibility of Cathegory leads:
they are eligible, as *everey* community member is eligible.
(if this is not obvious in the current draft, feel free to change
the wording)
Thank you, but I have to say that not only this is not obvious, but I
wouldn't even know where to change the wording in the proposal. Could
you please elaborate on this? Your help would be much welcome.
http://wiki.services.openoffice.org/wiki/Community_Council/Items/Charter_Proposal
4. Council Members ...
2. Terms Of Service ...
1. Elections ....
1. Each OpenOffice.org community member is eligible for
election.
and
3. Each community member is allowed to nominate candidates
(including self-nomination).
That's some progress, but again, where do Category leads fit? "Product
Development Representative"? Can you confirm something about it?
more NLC representatives:
... To me and although it's a bit indirect on the paper NLC
does represent as well the voice of localizers; these people are
developers as well, and one could see this extended to the people in
charge of the QA... but you know all this :-)
Do you understand my concerns?
Yes - I understand, but do not share them ;)
Anyway - my voice is not the only one that counts.
The proposal (number of representatives) was mainly derived from a
suggestion
done by khirano at [EMAIL PROTECTED] (sorry, I would need to search for the
link).
We not not much answers on the topic, comments came from Sophie,
Ian Lynch
and me (afair). So we had three contributors from NLC commenting
(and the discussion open for others to comment). The composition of
seats was
considered to be "fair" at this time (and nobody argued against this).
Well, I don't really agree with that but if in general the NLC does
not see anything wrong with this I won't object...
Do you think we could perhaps discuss this on [EMAIL PROTECTED]
And - this is also no troll - no matter what group will get how many
seats - it always
will be "unfair" to some of the groups (at least many might feels
so, when
thinking about their own group).
The council would only be efficient, if all members understand that
we are one
community that needs to work together and needs to respect each
other. This
means to listen to the concerns and problems of the "other groups"
but heading
for compromises at the same time.
I totally agree and don't get me wrong, I won't be the voice for
"balkanization". My concern was aimed at balance, not at division.
Best,
Charles.
---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]