Hi,
>> I also see this as an error in the tagging-schema. >> We have way too many values for "amenity" so these collisions >> happen all the time. It`s not just bank+atm, it is also >> hotel+restaurant and many others. >> This way of tagging amenities simply grew without any regard >> for what was technically possible (most editors never properly supported >> multiple values for a key, thus noone was to use them as their work >> could be destroyed at any moment). >> >> Marcus > > +1 > > We could restructure most (all?) amenities to more speaking k/v-pairs, > by inventing thematic replacement-groups for amenity (and the similar > man_made): I do not thing wee need to restructure it. Here some stats taking into account Austria, Switzerland, Finnland and Belgium: amenity key has been used 40193 in nodes and 10346 in ways Amenity as key has been used with 431 different value tags. among theses 431 different values, there are 25 values with ; in them, all value (like fuel;fast_food or fuel;toilets ) being composed of values already used normally alone as amenity. This is at least 6% of key/value paar showing that the mapper thing the value belong to the same node... Actually this is more, since within the 431 entries, I saw quite a lot of entries due to misspelling. Without knowing all artificial double node (like I did) in order to map as it is "taught".. Amenity has been combined with 384 other keys... some of them like atm, shop,... I found 638 times the combination amenity = bank atm = ..... which shows that we are fare higher than 6% for the same point with different values since except manually it is not possible to know that the tag atm = yes means amenity = atm, but since this is already used for bank, I do a workaround.... here below some details of my stat. I am now improving the performance of my program and try to let it run on europe. My end goal is to be able to create a kind of automatic dictionary of which key combination are used, and with which values... As soon as it can be presented in a better way, I will do it Best regards key value numnode numway numusage amenity ? bus_station 1 0 1 amenity ARA 1 0 1 amenity Alm 1 3 4 amenity Almhütte 1 0 1 amenity Altersheim 1 1 2 amenity Altersheim Riggishof 0 1 1 amenity Bildungshaus 1 0 1 amenity Brasserie 2 0 2 amenity Bus_pit 1 0 1 amenity Buschenschank 3 0 3 amenity Business Centre 2 0 2 amenity Chalet 1 0 1 amenity Exhibition 0 1 1 amenity FKK 1 0 1 amenity Gemeindeamt 1 0 1 amenity Goggitschberg 0 2 2 amenity Government 0 1 1 amenity Grillplatz 0 1 1 amenity Hütte 1 0 1 amenity Jagdhütte 0 1 1 amenity KIRCHE 2 0 2 amenity Kaiserburgbahn 1 0 1 amenity Kela 1 0 1 amenity Lakeside Park 1 0 1 amenity Mehrzweckhalle 1 0 1 amenity Molkerei 1 0 1 amenity Musikverein Irdning 1 0 1 amenity Pharmacy 1 0 1 amenity Port of Joensuu 1 0 1 amenity Puinzbahn 0 1 1 amenity Rastbahn 0 1 1 amenity Shopping Centre 1 0 1 amenity Sonnrain 0 1 1 amenity Spielplatz 1 0 1 amenity Tax Consultant 1 0 1 amenity Tierheim 1 0 1 amenity User Defined 1 0 1 amenity Verovirasto; Ympäristökeskus 1 0 1 amenity WLAN 1178 0 1178 amenity Wegkreuz 1 0 1 amenity Zivilschutzbunker 1 0 1 amenity abbey 0 1 1 amenity abmulance 1 0 1 amenity air_fill 4 0 4 amenity alm 1 0 1 amenity alm_hut 1 0 1 amenity alp_logde 1 0 1 amenity alpine_hut 15 0 15 amenity ambulance 3 1 4 amenity ambulance_station 1 0 1 amenity arcade 5 0 5 amenity art_gallerie 1 0 1 amenity arts-centre 0 2 2 amenity arts_centre 44 10 54 amenity atm 600 0 600 amenity atm;post_office;post_box 1 0 1 amenity bank 1361 20 1381 amenity bar 21 1 22 amenity barbecue 1 0 1 amenity bathing 0 1 1 amenity bbq 3 0 3 amenity beauty saloon 1 0 1 amenity behinderteneinrichtung 1 0 1 amenity bench 752 1 753 amenity bicycle_parking 403 75 478 amenity bicycle_rental 77 0 77 amenity bicycle_repair 1 0 1 amenity biergarten 96 2 98 amenity bingo 1 0 1 amenity boat_rental 1 0 1 amenity bomb_shelter 3 0 3 amenity border_control 6 0 6 amenity boulangerie paticerie 1 0 1 amenity brewery 1 0 1 amenity brothel 2 0 2 amenity building_entrance 3 0 3 amenity building_management 1 0 1 amenity building_rental 1 0 1 amenity bureau_de_change 8 0 8 amenity bus_station 357 41 398 amenity bus_stop 3 0 3 amenity buschenschank 1 0 1 amenity business 1 0 1 amenity c 0 1 1 amenity cafe 1001 9 1010 amenity cafe, restaurant 1 0 1 amenity cafe;fast_food 1 0 1 amenity cafe;pub 1 0 1 amenity camera 2 0 2 amenity car 1 0 1 amenity car club 0 1 1 amenity car_approval_center 1 0 1 amenity car_cleaning 1 0 1 amenity car_inspection 1 0 1 amenity car_mechanic 1 0 1 amenity car_park 0 1 1 amenity car_parts;car_repairing 5 0 5 amenity car_registration 1 0 1 amenity car_rental 27 1 28 amenity car_service 2 0 2 amenity car_sharing 1128 1 1129 amenity car_wash 31 3 34 amenity carwash 1 0 1 amenity casino 5 1 6 amenity cemetery 0 1 1 amenity centre for parents and children 1 0 1 amenity chapel 3 0 3 amenity cheese diary 1 0 1 amenity child health center 1 0 1 amenity cinema 196 15 211 amenity city_hall 1 0 1 amenity city_square 0 1 1 amenity cleaning 1 0 1 amenity clock 1 0 1 amenity club 1 0 1 amenity coached apartments for old people 1 0 1 amenity college 40 86 126 amenity community_center 0 1 1 amenity community_centre 0 1 1 amenity company 11 0 11 amenity conference_center 0 1 1 amenity conference_centre 1 0 1 amenity congress 2 0 2 amenity congress_centre 1 0 1 amenity convention_center 1 0 1 amenity cosmetics 1 0 1 amenity courthouse 60 14 74 amenity crematorium 8 1 9 amenity cultural_center 1 0 1 amenity custom 1 0 1 amenity cutter 2 0 2 amenity dance_school 1 0 1 amenity danceschool 1 0 1 amenity dancesport_club 1 0 1 amenity dancing_school 1 0 1 amenity daycare 2 2 4 amenity dentist 18 1 19 amenity disabled 1 0 1 amenity disabled_parking 0 1 1 amenity disused_parking 0 1 1 amenity doctor 9 2 11 amenity doctor / first aid 1 0 1 amenity doctors 50 2 52 amenity dog_bin 4 0 4 amenity dog_park 0 2 2 amenity dog_toilet 3 0 3 amenity dog_trimmer 1 0 1 amenity dog_waste 12 0 12 amenity dormitory 2 0 2 amenity drinking_water 374 0 374 amenity education 1 0 1 amenity embassy 23 8 31 amenity embasy 1 0 1 amenity emergency_phone 9 0 9 amenity erikoishammasteknikko 1 0 1 amenity exhibition 1 0 1 amenity exhibition_centre 0 1 1 amenity exhibition_hall 2 5 7 amenity farmacie 1 0 1 amenity fast_food 1101 18 1119 amenity fast_food;restaurant 1 0 1 amenity ferry_terminal 20 0 20 amenity finance_office 0 1 1 amenity fire brigade 1 0 1 amenity fire_department 0 1 1 amenity fire_hydrant 49 0 49 amenity fire_place 1 0 1 amenity fire_station 445 63 508 amenity fireplace 9 0 9 amenity firm 1 0 1 amenity first_aid 2 0 2 amenity fiscal_authority 1 0 1 amenity fitness trail; vitaparcour 1 0 1 amenity flat_service 1 0 1 amenity flute manufacturing 1 0 1 amenity food 2 0 2 amenity foot_service 1 0 1 amenity footbeauty 1 0 1 amenity foreign agency 1 0 1 amenity foresthouse 5 0 5 amenity former_post_office 3 0 3 amenity fountain 383 31 414 amenity fuel 3251 51 3302 amenity fuel;cafe;fast_food 1 0 1 amenity fuel;fast_food 1 0 1 amenity fuel;fastfood 1 0 1 amenity fuel;toilets 1 0 1 amenity gambling 4 0 4 amenity garage 0 1 1 amenity garbage 1 0 1 amenity geocache 1 0 1 amenity government 2 2 4 amenity gratuite 1 0 1 amenity grave_yard 65 108 173 amenity graveyard 1 0 1 amenity grill 3 0 3 amenity grit_bin 6 0 6 amenity gym 1 0 1 amenity hairdresser 1 0 1 amenity hall 2 0 2 amenity health_center 1 2 3 amenity helipad 1 0 1 amenity help 1 0 1 amenity heurigen 1 0 1 amenity heuriger 17 0 17 amenity home for the aged 0 2 2 amenity horse_racing_track 1 0 1 amenity hospice 1 0 1 amenity hospital 403 169 572 amenity hospital UKBB 0 1 1 amenity hunting_blind 6 0 6 amenity hunting_stand 3 0 3 amenity hut 2 0 2 amenity hydrant 1 0 1 amenity ice_cream 4 0 4 amenity icerink 1 0 1 amenity illegal_parking 0 1 1 amenity industry 2 0 2 amenity institute 1 0 1 amenity insurance 1 0 1 amenity insurance_agency 1 0 1 amenity internet 1 0 1 amenity job center 0 1 1 amenity kampaamo 4 0 4 amenity kauneshoitola 1 0 1 amenity kauneushoitola 2 0 2 amenity kindergarten 233 66 299 amenity kindergaten 1 2 3 amenity kiosk 1 0 1 amenity konevuokraamo 1 0 1 amenity lantasäiliö 0 1 1 amenity laundry 1 0 1 amenity lawyer 1 0 1 amenity leikkipuisto 0 1 1 amenity library 212 30 242 amenity library; public_building 0 1 1 amenity library_bus 1 0 1 amenity litter_bin 4 0 4 amenity location 1 0 1 amenity lottery 1 0 1 amenity market 0 1 1 amenity marketplace 0 3 3 amenity massage 1 0 1 amenity mast 1 0 1 amenity media_agency 1 0 1 amenity mini_roundabout 1 0 1 amenity mobile_phone_service 1 0 1 amenity monastery 2 0 2 amenity mountain_hut 5 0 5 amenity mountain_refuge 1 0 1 amenity museum 0 1 1 amenity nail_service 2 0 2 amenity nail_studio 3 0 3 amenity neuvola 1 0 1 amenity nightclub 160 4 164 amenity nightclub;pub 2 0 2 amenity nursery 5 5 10 amenity nursery_home 3 0 3 amenity nursing 1 0 1 amenity nursing-home 0 1 1 amenity nursing_home 4 5 9 amenity observatory 3 0 3 amenity office 5 0 5 amenity optometrist 2 0 2 amenity other 35 1 36 amenity park 1 1 2 amenity parking 5129 6947 12076 amenity parking;fuel 4 0 4 amenity parking=underground 1 0 1 amenity parting 1 0 1 amenity parturi 2 0 2 amenity parturi-kampaamo 6 0 6 amenity party 1 0 1 amenity pelihalli 1 0 1 amenity pesula 1 0 1 amenity pet_doctor 1 0 1 amenity pet_supplies 1 0 1 amenity pharmacie 0 1 1 amenity pharmacy 940 11 951 amenity pharmacy and medic 1 0 1 amenity pitch 0 1 1 amenity place of workship 0 3 3 amenity place_of_workship 0 7 7 amenity place_of_worship 2925 353 3278 amenity playce_of_worship 0 1 1 amenity playground 5 3 8 amenity plaza 0 39 39 amenity plumber 5 0 5 amenity police 387 31 418 amenity politics 1 0 1 amenity polttopuita 1 0 1 amenity post-office 1 0 1 amenity post_box 1645 3 1648 amenity post_office 2412 24 2436 amenity post_office;post_box;atm 1 0 1 amenity pottery 1 0 1 amenity preschool 33 6 39 amenity prison 24 16 40 amenity private_doctor's_appointment 1 0 1 amenity private_living_area 0 2 2 amenity psychiatry 1 0 1 amenity pub 1336 4 1340 amenity pub nightclub 1 0 1 amenity pub; restaurant 1 0 1 amenity public beach 1 0 1 amenity public_building 173 272 445 amenity pupil_help 2 0 2 amenity pyöräkorjaamo 1 0 1 amenity recycling 1332 31 1363 amenity recycling_centre 0 1 1 amenity red_cross 2 1 3 amenity redcross 0 1 1 amenity refuge 1 1 2 amenity repair 3 0 3 amenity rescue 3 0 3 amenity research 1 0 1 amenity residential 0 1 1 amenity restauran 1 0 1 amenity restaurant 5085 124 5209 amenity restaurant; pub 0 1 1 amenity restaurant;bar 1 0 1 amenity restaurant;hotel;nightclub 1 0 1 amenity restaurant;nightclub 1 0 1 amenity restaurant;pub 2 0 2 amenity restaurant_closed 1 0 1 amenity retail 5 2 7 amenity retaurant 0 1 1 amenity retirement_home 3 2 5 amenity rettung 1 0 1 amenity rotes_kreuz 1 0 1 amenity salon 1 0 1 amenity sauna 3 0 3 amenity school 1591 1050 2641 amenity school;library 0 1 1 amenity science_park 1 8 9 amenity scissors 1 0 1 amenity scout_centre 2 0 2 amenity scout_house 0 2 2 amenity sh 0 1 1 amenity shelter 81 5 86 amenity shop 24 3 27 amenity shop;car_parts 2 0 2 amenity shopping 6 0 6 amenity signpost 160 0 160 amenity ski area, hornspitz 1 0 1 amenity ski_resort 1 0 1 amenity ski_school 8 0 8 amenity small shop 1 0 1 amenity snack 0 1 1 amenity social service 1 0 1 amenity solarium 1 0 1 amenity speed_camera 12 0 12 amenity speed_tramp 2 0 2 amenity speed_trap 3 0 3 amenity sport 0 1 1 amenity sporthall 1 0 1 amenity sporting_bids 2 0 2 amenity sportpanlage 1 0 1 amenity square 5 11 16 amenity stance 1 0 1 amenity statue 1 0 1 amenity studio 3 2 5 amenity sun studio 1 0 1 amenity suntan 1 0 1 amenity supermarket 0 1 1 amenity swimming_pool 1 0 1 amenity table 2 0 2 amenity tailor 1 0 1 amenity talopiirtopalvelu 1 0 1 amenity tax_service 1 0 1 amenity taxi 170 4 174 amenity telephone 600 0 600 amenity television network 1 0 1 amenity test drive track 1 0 1 amenity thai-massage 1 0 1 amenity theatre 148 39 187 amenity ticket_office 1 0 1 amenity tickets 1 0 1 amenity toilets 473 4 477 amenity toilets; 1 0 1 amenity toilets;telephone;drinking_water 1 0 1 amenity toilett 1 0 1 amenity tourist information 1 0 1 amenity town_hall 5 2 7 amenity townhall 259 61 320 amenity tram_station 1 0 1 amenity transportation 1 0 1 amenity trash_bin 1 0 1 amenity travel_agency 1 0 1 amenity tree 0 1 1 amenity tree_nursery 1 0 1 amenity tulli 1 0 1 amenity undefined 3 0 3 amenity underground parking 1 0 1 amenity undertakers 1 0 1 amenity university 87 341 428 amenity vacuumcleaner 1 0 1 amenity vakuutusyhtiö 1 0 1 amenity vanhainkoti 1 0 1 amenity vehicle_inspection 1 0 1 amenity vehicle_inspection_centre 0 1 1 amenity vending machine 9 0 9 amenity vending_machine 36 1 37 amenity verfallen 1 0 1 amenity verhoomo 1 0 1 amenity veterenarian 1 0 1 amenity veterinary 30 1 31 amenity via ferrata 0 1 1 amenity video shop 1 0 1 amenity video_rental 1 0 1 amenity vineyard 1 0 1 amenity vineyard sales outlet and bar 1 0 1 amenity waste disposal 1 0 1 amenity waste transfer station 1 0 1 amenity waste_basket 91 0 91 amenity waste_bin 11 0 11 amenity waste_disposal 207 5 212 amenity waste_incineration_plant 0 1 1 amenity watches_service 1 0 1 amenity water 2 0 2 amenity water_point 10 0 10 amenity water_tower 1 0 1 amenity waterfall 1 0 1 amenity webcam 1 0 1 amenity whorehouse 1 0 1 amenity wifi 1 0 1 amenity window prostitution 2 0 2 amenity winery 4 0 4 amenity wireless 1 0 1 amenity yes 1 0 1 amenity youth_club 1 0 1 _______________________________________________ dev mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/dev
