Hi, Dongjoon Thank you very much for your support. Here is our donation plan; please take a look.
## Summary Transfer [orc-rust](https://github.com/datafusion-contrib/orc-rust) from [datafusion-contrib](https://github.com/datafusion-contrib) to [apache](https://github.com/apache) directly, under the governance of the Apache ORC PMC. ## Contributor All active contributors have agreed to continue contributing to this project. We are all willing to collaborate on this project under the governance of the Apache ORC PMC. ## License - All active contributors have signed the ICLA and CCLA. - All submitted code is licensed under Apache 2.0. - All dependencies are compatible with Apache 2.0 and permitted by the ASF. We can double-check this part while we are building our first ASF release. ## CI orc-rust plans to use GitHub Actions as its CI system. Once accepted by the ORC PMC, all actions not approved by the ASF will be unable to run. We can address them afterward. ## Discussion orc-rust plans to use `dev@orc.apache.org` as its main channel. ## Release orc-rust plans to continue using the current version number. We will make it very clear that old releases are not approved by the ORC PMC and are informal ASF releases. Once accepted by the ORC PMC, we will alter our release process to meet the requirements. We will offer ASF release downloads and also have a `crates.io` release for user convenience. The crate `orc-rust` will be transferred to the ORC PMC for control. ## Non-blockers All code/document changes are not blockers for now. We believe they can be addressed after being accepted by the ORC PMC. Please let me know if any points are still missing. On Thu, Oct 31, 2024, at 23:03, Dongjoon Hyun wrote: > To Gang and all. > > I'd like to give +1 in the context of the proposed title, "Create > apache/orc-rust repository". > > However, I feel we need to clarify that the following is incorrect and not > a scope of this vote > because the migration PR will be reviewed and revised in the Apache ORC way > anyway. > >> Specifically, the datafusion-contrib/orc-rust repository will be moved to >> apache/orc-rust and governed by Apache ORC PMC. > > Although I understand you want to provide more transparent migration > technically, > they (BEFORE and AFTER) could be differently technically. For example, > > - We are not going to change README? > - What about the version number? > - Do we need to continue the version number with 0.5.1? or a new scheme? > - What about the CIs on a new repository? > - All github action plugins are verified by the ASF infra team? > - What about the release process and distribution channel change? (Crate + > ASF Download) > > For me, the above sentence (`Specifically, ... moved to ... ORC PMC`) is an > overclaim > (and just an aspiration) which we didn't agree with anything yet. > > So, as a member of Apache ORC PMC, I'm -1 for the specific promise of the > vote content. > > Best Regards, > Dongjoon. -- Xuanwo https://xuanwo.io/
