Hi, all
This mail has been sent to both otrs-dev and otrs-i18n.

I'm trying to use OTRS in Japanese.
I translated Language/ja.pm and succeeded to use OTRS in
Japanese using UTF-8. 

There is a big problem to use OTRS in Japanese that;
many web-based MUAs, such as Hotmail and Yahoo, and some popular
MUAs, such as Microsoft Exchange and Lotus Notes, does not
support UTF-8! 

# Attention: Hotmail's English UI and Yahoo,Inc.'s web mailer
support UTF-8...

Therefore, customers which use these MUAs cannot read mails sent
from OTRS. They can read mails encoded in ISO-2022-JP only.
My OTRS must send mails as ISO-2022-JP.

# OTRS *can* receive and parse ISO-2022-JP mail correctly.
# There is no problem in receiving mails. Only sending.


I cannot use ISO-2022-JP as OTRS UI. Because:
1. ISO-2022-JP is insecure for web applications.
   ISO-2022 series is stateful encoding and contains \x1B escape
   sequence. It's very hard to handle stateful encoding
   correctly for web applications.
2. I want to share one OTRS installation and its queues in
   multilingual project team. Non-Japanese team can or must use UTF-8.
   And, OTRS must be able to send ISO-2022-JP mail even if
   user uses English UI.

In other word, I do not want Japanized (locally patched) OTRS.


-----

My suggestion is to create "mail character encoding" to queue
settings (defaults to UTF-8, or empty meaning system default
charset). for example,

info-en queue uses 'UTF-8' or ''
info-ja queue uses 'ISO-2022-JP'

A mail composd mail in info-en queue is encoded as UTF-8.
A mail composd mail in info-ja queue is encoded as ISO-2022-JP.

This solution seems to make them happy that all users in all
languages.

RFC: Any other suggestion?

If no oppose, I will try to make patch.


-- 
Tietew <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Blog: http://www.tietew.jp/
PGP: 26CB 71BB B595 09C4 0153  81C4 773C 963A D51B 8CAA

_______________________________________________
OTRS mailing list: dev - Webpage: http://otrs.org/
Archive: http://lists.otrs.org/pipermail/dev
To unsubscribe: http://lists.otrs.org/cgi-bin/listinfo/dev

Reply via email to