Hi,
> First off there's no need to list completed items under the important issues > section. The board what still needs to be done to graduate. I think the > continued use of external GitHub repos should be listed here. Also given the > large amount of activity it’s possible that potential committers are not > voted in quickly enough? (Anyone else have thoughts on this?) This is also I worried about, as i listed in the podling report, we have transferred the first Hackathon mature projects into Apache repository. The last project Apache RocketMQ - Apache Storm integration will transfer to the Apache repository once the new PR[1] has merged into Storm community. We have noticed the fact that the slow steps have occured since these projects came into apache repository. As justin said, the potential committers has not enough permission to commit code. Also the result is potential committers are not voted in quickly enough. > Under community development you mention that external projects have finished > been move to Apache, but it looks to me like more external repos have been > added. I have removed the new repos. As our second Hackathon said, new projects will merged through PR. But, I am not sure it can influence the community projects contribution. This is mime are most concerned about in this Hackathon. > Under "When were the last committers or PPMC members elected?” please note > they were committers not PPMC members and that no PPMC member have been > elected yet. (That’s the case right?) All right, just committers. I have made clarification in the podling report :-) [1] https://github.com/apache/storm/pull/2024#pullrequestreview-30404825 <https://github.com/apache/storm/pull/2024#pullrequestreview-30404825> > 在 2017年4月2日，10:56，Justin Mclean <[email protected]> 写道： > > Hi, > >> I have finished the necessary content for the april podling report. > > Thanks for putting that together, it's looks good. > > I’d suggest some minor adjustments. > > First off there's no need to list completed items under the important issues > section. The board what still needs to be done to graduate. I think the > continued use of external GitHub repos should be listed here. Also given the > large amount of activity it’s possible that potential committers are not > voted in quickly enough? (Anyone else have thoughts on this?) > > Under community development you mention that external projects have finished > been move to Apache, but it looks to me like more external repos have been > added. > > Under "When were the last committers or PPMC members elected?” please note > they were committers not PPMC members and that no PPMC member have been > elected yet. (That’s the case right?) > > Thanks, > Justin
