Hi Justin, 2018-01-06 13:11 GMT+01:00 Justin Mclean <[email protected]>:
> Hi, > > You might want to run it pass trademarks first, but I guess that could be > done after it released. There is a checklist here [3] > > We did this already when we discussed with legal and trademark about the initial preview site. So I think that step is done and with green light. Right not we only fill with the right content for all the pages that is similar to the rest of apache sites out there. > From a quick look I notice a few minor things: > - royalesdk.org is still not resolving to royale.apache.org for instance > I think the domain needs to be "royale.apache.org" from the same discussion with trademarks and legal. But I think as well that a domain pointing to the main "royale.apache.org" that will not do any cloaking is not harmless at all... > - I believe trademarks asked for a disclaimer about using a commercial > theme for the site > Finaly legal said that was not necessary. I must to revise the ticket to see if that is how it was left there. > - copyright year needs to be updated > Ok, I setup to : Copyright © 2017-2018... right? I think we should put the initial year and change the later to the current one, what do you think? > - missing security link [1] > Added security link to Apache menu. > - I don’t think the disclaimer here [2] goes far enough and could been see > as encouraging user to use nightly builds > I don't think so... but anyway, you could suggest the text to use and I will change to that. Let me know. - some of the more important links are mostly hidden at the bottom of the > page (get involved and source code for instance). The github link should > possibly be less noticeable than the source link. > This is for me something subjective to be as is by design. We are complying with general rules while trying to create a modern site that compites with the rest of other technologies out there. The moto in the site is to be direct and quick as possible without miss any important link or rule at Apache. People wanting to now most needed things in the project must have all required in top menus. Other important but less used links should be layout bottom like many other great sites out there. I don't think nothing is hidden, and anyone visiting us that use the site a bit and want to search something will have few time since all is minimal but well organized. There's no submenus at all in all the site and all links are available to simple look at the page (top or bottom). Many other Apache sites does not have such design and use submenus that hide those links, that although are in the top part of the page, are less visible than us. > - the team page description is still in fake latin and a there is a number > of fake pages that show up in the search results. > This part I don't understand right, could you explain a bit? I revise in admin about "latin", but WP is installed in English and there's no Spanish or something like that involved. And I think if Team has a problem with that the rest of pages should have too, right? Don't know exactly how can this be revised or solved. Maybe more info here would help me. Thanks Justin! > > Thanks, > Justin > > 1. https://www.apache.org/foundation/marks/pmcs#navigation > 2. http://royale.codeoscopic.com/download/ > 3. https://www.apache.org/foundation/marks/pmcs#checklist > > -- Carlos Rovira http://about.me/carlosrovira
