Thanks for the clarification! I'd still like to see a reply (probably better in the original thread) about your motivations to remove it.
Kind regards, Daniel Den tis 24 juni 2025 kl 04:25 skrev Greg Stein <gst...@gmail.com>: > No rush. It is me saying "yeah, I'd like to rip it out RIGHT NOW", but am > waiting for people to respond. > > The answer was given: "naw, not yet". > > But people seemed like I was in a rush. No, I was avoiding a rush, and > giving people time to provide feedback. > > Cheers, > -g > > > On Mon, Jun 23, 2025 at 2:15 PM Branko Čibej <br...@apache.org> wrote: > > > On 23. 6. 25 17:50, Greg Stein wrote: > > > The concept of "72 hours" is normal for Apache communities to reach > > > decisions. It provides everybody a chance to see the > > concern/issue/question > > > and respond to it. 72 hours spans weekends, so those in the community > > that > > > only contribute weekdays can also participate. > > > > > > The 72 hour rule is a core feature of Apache governance. It is not a > > "rush" > > > to ask for 72 hours to ask for consensus, but is actually a *provision* > > of > > > time against taking unilateral immediate action. > > > > > > The 72 hour span has existed at Apache for over 25 years. I am > surprised > > > people find it concerning. It is completely normal. > > > > Greg, this is not a release vote, or any kind of vote, nor even any kind > > of situation where it would be appropriate to invoke the lazy consensus > > rule. It's a discussion about a feature in the code and how to implement > > it. These have been known to last for months if necessary. Nathan has > > already said that he needs more time to research. I'd be surprised if > > others were not in the same situation. > > > > Why the rush? It's not as if there's a critical remote root access > > exploit fix waiting to be released and we have (checks watch) 58:27 on > > the timer before it all goes kaboom. This way, it just feels like you're > > trying to pressure people into making hasty decisions. > > > > Yes, we all know what those 72 hours are. A guideline. > > > > -- Brane > > >
