Hi all,

We currently have two versions of Traffic Monitor: Java and golang.
When we build all components, as far as I know, it results in a race
condition between the two, as the resulting RPMs have the same
filename. A PR[1] was opened to address the issue and the approach was
to add `_go` to the version string used for the golang version's RPM.

Rob and I both think we (Comcast) have enough experience running the
golang version that we have identified and corrected any major issues
and that it is stable enough to be the preferred Traffic Monitor hence
forth.

Therefore, I propose that within the project's directory structure, we:
  1) rename traffic_monitor to traffic_monitor_legacy
  2) rename traffic_monitor_golang to traffic_monitor

..then work with the person that submitted the PR to take the same
approach, except change the Java version's RPM name to contain
`_legacy`.

I realize that this is a fairly significant change, the type that we
typically reserve for major releases. The next major release, 3.0.0,
is likely to be some time out in the future, and I don't know that we
need to wait for it in order to make this change.

How does the group feel about the above proposal, and executing on it
prior to the 3.0.0 release (i.e.: for 2.1.0)? Then, when we do
actually prepare the 3.0.0 release, we can remove the Java version
from the codebase entirely. Obviously this could impact anyone that
has automated CI systems building components, in addition to the
Apache CI we use ourselves.

Thoughts?

[1] https://github.com/apache/incubator-trafficcontrol/pull/731
--
Thanks,
Jeff

Reply via email to