After thinking about this overnight, I have a new thought. I think the only trademark we need to be concerned with is Apache UIMA. When I look at the docbook for UIMA-AS, the "TM" is attached to the top of the html / pdf file, where it says "Written and maintained by the Apache UIMA (tm) Development Community". This is at the top in the html, but comes right after the title in the PDF.
Following that line of reasoning, we can use uimaFIT without any trademark symbol, if Apache UIMA is "protected" by (tm). I think the ASF requires us to tm only the main project name; other tm's are optional. What do others think? -Marshall On 8/19/2013 5:16 PM, Marshall Schor wrote: > On 8/19/2013 3:52 PM, Richard Eckart de Castilho wrote: >> Am 19.08.2013 um 21:37 schrieb Marshall Schor <[email protected]>: >>> On 8/19/2013 11:12 AM, Richard Eckart de Castilho wrote: >>>> Am 19.08.2013 um 17:03 schrieb Marshall Schor <[email protected]>: >>>> >>>>> trademark checking: >>>>> >>>>> The first use of the word UIMA in a significant document should be >>>>> written with >>>>> a preceeding "Apache" and a following ™ sign (that's the trademark sign). >>>>> Subsequent uses can just write UIMA. >>>>> >>>>> A significant doc would be things like the docbook (it's missing). >>>>> >>>>> Has anyone talked to trademarks@ to see about the term uimaFIT? >>>> Not explicitly. The IP clearance vote has been done on the incubator >>>> list per workflow: >>>> >>>> Vote: http://markmail.org/message/xz5at7asrnkx4t2e >>>> Result: http://markmail.org/thread/iarcwb7efs3mburu >>>> >>>> Are you suggesting that, possibly in the light of the renaming of Ruta, >>>> a preemptive involvement of trademarks@ would be wise? >>> nope. I'm referring to following these policies: >>> http://www.apache.org/foundation/marks/pmcs.html >>> >>> The relevant sections (written for "web pages", but I think applies to other >>> significant documentation): >>> >>> The first and most prominent reference to a project or product on each page >>> must >>> use the "Apache Foo" form of its name. Other references may use either >>> "Apache >>> Foo" or "Foo" as appropriate for the subject matter. >>> >>> At the top of each project or product homepage, and on the top banner of >>> each >>> page where the project name appears, you should include a "TM" symbol next >>> to >>> the *first* main occurrence of the "Apache Foo" project name. This >>> highlights >>> our trademark claim and emphasizes its importance to us. >>> >>> If you haven't already, please read this too: >>> http://www.apache.org/foundation/marks/responsibility.html >> Thanks for your comments. I wasn't aware this had not been sufficiently >> addressed >> in the past, but I suppose it wasn't. >> >> Just to make sure I'm not reading this with the wrong set of eyes. >> >> Is it correct that your main concern is currently the presentation of the >> brand, >> in particular its markings and mentions? >> >> Are there any objections to using the name "Apache uimaFIT"? > I think uimaFIT would need to be a top level project to have that name, but I > think it's best to run these by the trademarks@ folks. >> If so, would "Apache UIMA uimaFIT" be more appropriate? > That's quite a mouthful, but I think that's the "correct" way to say it (one > time); afterwards, I would use just uimaFIT. > > Again, I think it would be good to ask trademarks@ about using just uimaFIT > as a > trademark, itself, just to see what they say. > >> Do you think the moniker "Apache (UIMA) uimaFIT" should be discussed with >> anybody else >> at the foundation? > Other than trademarks@, no. They are the designated people to have this > discussion with. >> Are there any further concerns that I should be particularly aware of or >> mind when >> reading these pages? > Only that we're required to follow and enforce these policies as PMC members > :-). > > -Marshall >
