one responder from trademarks@ thinks that Apache uimaFIT(tm) (on first use) is
fine.

I tend to agree with this, and think this is a good solution.

-Marshall

On 8/20/2013 9:35 AM, Marshall Schor wrote:
> sent a note to trademarks@ asking for their opinion.  -Marshall
> On 8/20/2013 9:27 AM, Marshall Schor wrote:
>> After thinking about this overnight, I have a new thought.
>>
>> I think the only trademark we need to be concerned with is Apache UIMA.  
>> When I
>> look at the docbook for UIMA-AS, the "TM" is attached to the top of the html 
>> /
>> pdf file, where it says "Written and maintained by the Apache UIMA (tm)
>> Development Community".  This is at the top in the html, but comes right 
>> after
>> the title in the PDF.
>>
>> Following that line of reasoning, we can use uimaFIT without any trademark
>> symbol, if Apache UIMA is "protected" by (tm). 
>>
>> I think the ASF requires us to tm only the main project name; other tm's are
>> optional.
>>
>> What do others think?
>>
>> -Marshall
>>
>> On 8/19/2013 5:16 PM, Marshall Schor wrote:
>>> On 8/19/2013 3:52 PM, Richard Eckart de Castilho wrote:
>>>> Am 19.08.2013 um 21:37 schrieb Marshall Schor <[email protected]>:
>>>>> On 8/19/2013 11:12 AM, Richard Eckart de Castilho wrote:
>>>>>> Am 19.08.2013 um 17:03 schrieb Marshall Schor <[email protected]>:
>>>>>>
>>>>>>> trademark checking:
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> The first use of the word UIMA in a significant document should be 
>>>>>>> written with
>>>>>>> a preceeding "Apache" and a following ™ sign (that's the trademark 
>>>>>>> sign). 
>>>>>>> Subsequent uses can just write UIMA.
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> A significant doc would be things like the docbook (it's missing).
>>>>>>>
>>>>>>> Has anyone talked to trademarks@ to see about the term uimaFIT?
>>>>>> Not explicitly. The IP clearance vote has been done on the incubator
>>>>>> list per workflow:
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Vote:   http://markmail.org/message/xz5at7asrnkx4t2e
>>>>>> Result: http://markmail.org/thread/iarcwb7efs3mburu
>>>>>>
>>>>>> Are you suggesting that, possibly in the light of the renaming of Ruta,
>>>>>> a preemptive involvement of trademarks@ would be wise?
>>>>> nope.  I'm referring to following these policies:
>>>>> http://www.apache.org/foundation/marks/pmcs.html
>>>>>
>>>>> The relevant sections (written for "web pages", but I think applies to 
>>>>> other
>>>>> significant documentation):
>>>>>
>>>>> The first and most prominent reference to a project or product on each 
>>>>> page must
>>>>> use the "Apache Foo" form of its name. Other references may use either 
>>>>> "Apache
>>>>> Foo" or "Foo" as appropriate for the subject matter.
>>>>>
>>>>> At the top of each project or product homepage, and on the top banner of 
>>>>> each
>>>>> page where the project name appears, you should include a "TM" symbol 
>>>>> next to
>>>>> the *first* main occurrence of the "Apache Foo" project name. This 
>>>>> highlights
>>>>> our trademark claim and emphasizes its importance to us.
>>>>>
>>>>> If you haven't already, please read this too:
>>>>> http://www.apache.org/foundation/marks/responsibility.html
>>>> Thanks for your comments. I wasn't aware this had not been sufficiently 
>>>> addressed
>>>> in the past, but I suppose it wasn't.
>>>>
>>>> Just to make sure I'm not reading this with the wrong set of eyes. 
>>>>
>>>> Is it correct that your main concern is currently the presentation of the 
>>>> brand,
>>>> in particular its markings and mentions?
>>>>
>>>> Are there any objections to using the name "Apache uimaFIT"? 
>>> I think uimaFIT would need to be a top level project to have that name, but 
>>> I
>>> think it's best to run these by the trademarks@ folks.
>>>> If so, would "Apache UIMA uimaFIT" be more appropriate?
>>> That's quite a mouthful, but I think that's the "correct" way to say it (one
>>> time); afterwards, I would use just uimaFIT.
>>>
>>> Again, I think it would be good to ask trademarks@ about using just uimaFIT 
>>> as a
>>> trademark, itself, just to see what they say.
>>>
>>>> Do you think the moniker "Apache (UIMA) uimaFIT" should be discussed with 
>>>> anybody else
>>>> at the foundation?
>>> Other than trademarks@, no. They are the designated people to have this
>>> discussion with.
>>>> Are there any further concerns that I should be particularly aware of or 
>>>> mind when
>>>> reading these pages?
>>> Only that we're required to follow and enforce these policies as PMC 
>>> members :-).
>>>
>>> -Marshall
>>>
>

Reply via email to