It's a bit confusing for the user, that we have a language-list frame further down the left-hand side, but we also have some language-links listed in the template frame on the RHS, which is much more obvious. Do we need to remove the language-links from the RHS template?

If I had a choice, we would only use one language link- My preference is the InterWiki links (the list of languages on the lower left). If we use this style throughout the OOoWiki, it becomes "normal". It is also the standard L10N linking method used in well known Wikis such as Wikipedia, so the format should... in theory... be a known one.

I modified the Main Page to remove the redundant language links, and it would be good if the other redundant language links could also be reduced or removed... such as this case with the Extensions template (the one on the right hand side).

By the way, you can localize the Wiki page titles (while still keeping the common English URLs) with the DISPLAYTITLE syntax:

{{DISPLAYTITLE:Your L10N title}}


Yes, I'd wondered about that, because I've translated other wikipages into Vietnamese, and I have a nasty feeling that the links are in different formats, based on what other languages did for each page. I would like to clean all those up, and I agree with you that we need to talk about this on the NLC list.

As more and more people start using the OOoWiki, we really need to start thinking about adding a little structure... but without restricting the free form of a Wiki.

Using ISO codes for languages (since this wiki does not use namespaces, and it's a bit late to implement that now) is a great start... but as usual with good and bad points. I'll try to put together an initial proposal to the L10N group, with some ideas and the impact as I have observed. We can discuss it and hopefully find a solution that helps give a little sanity to the Wiki.

C.
--
Clayton Cornell       [EMAIL PROTECTED]
StarOffice - Sun Microsystems, Inc. - Hamburg, Germany

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to