> Why does it do that ? The way I understand it, OK means OK - got it, > thank you, you can go home now :-) does the manual document it ? Actually it doesn't. I spoke with a guy from Siemens who said this. I found out because I was loosing some outgoing messages.
> What do you think we should do about it - I see several options : > * Treat OK as an error (retry again immidietly until the "retry limit" > and then discard the message). > * treat it as a special error, forcing a delay. > * treat it as a temporary failure, bouncing it to the top of the local > outgoing_queue > * treat it as a temporary failure, sending it back to bearerbox with a > FAILED_TEMPORARY status. > > I think the last two are the easiest to implement and offer the more > "correct" way of handling such stuff. I think you are right. Maybe a short delay (1-5 s) would be a good idea as well? Best regards, Jacob Vennervald > -----Original Message----- > From: Oded Arbel [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] > Sent: 1. maj 2002 13:45 > To: Jacob Vennervald Madsen; [EMAIL PROTECTED] > Subject: RE: bug in siemens tc53 at2 > > > Why does it do that ? The way I understand it, OK means OK - got it, > thank you, you can go home now :-) does the manual document it ? > What do you think we should do about it - I see several options : > * Treat OK as an error (retry again immidietly until the "retry limit" > and then discard the message). > * treat it as a special error, forcing a delay. > * treat it as a temporary failure, bouncing it to the top of the local > outgoing_queue > * treat it as a temporary failure, sending it back to bearerbox with a > FAILED_TEMPORARY status. > > I think the last two are the easiest to implement and offer the more > "correct" way of handling such stuff. > > -- > Oded Arbel > m-Wise Inc. > [EMAIL PROTECTED] > (972)-67-340014 > (972)-9-9581711 (ext: 116) > > ::.. > /real/ kernel hackers > dd if=/dev/urandom of=/vmlinuz > and influence the Universal Randomosity Field. > -- Gaal Yahas > > > > -----Original Message----- > > From: Jacob Vennervald Madsen [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] > > Sent: Wednesday, May 01, 2002 10:49 AM > > To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > > Subject: bug in siemens tc53 at2 > > > > > > Hi List > > > > I think there is a bug in the Siemens TC35 AT2 code. > > When a message is sent through a Siemens TC35 in PDU mode > it can send > > three different responses: > > > > +CMGS:<mr>OK > > This means that the message was successfully sent. > > > > OK > > This means that the modem understood the command but it > could not send > > the message. > > > > +CMS ERROR:<err> > > This means that the modem didn't understand the command. > > > > If I send a lot of messages back and forth on a Siemens modem some > > messages doesn't get sent because kannel takes the OK message as > > successful sending when it really should try sending again. > > > > Jacob Vennervald > > > > >
