Submitting a response to the Pitch Black paper seems a bit premature, given that in the real world we probably have network distribution problems even without an active adversary.
I continue to think that the biggest thing preventing routing layer improvements is a fairly deep lack of understanding of what is actually happening on the network. And, if you're looking for papers, I think several interesting ones could be written on that subject :) Evan Daniel On Sun, Jan 15, 2012 at 6:46 PM, Ian Clarke <ian at locut.us> wrote: > Will you submit? ?These guys have rejected our papers in the past > specifically because we haven't yet formally responded to the Pitch Black > paper, so submitting a response to it would be a pretty good thing IMHO. > > Have you had any contact with Theodore Hong? ?If you ask him very nicely he > may be willing to provide feedback on your paper. ?Of course I will too, but > Theo has a lot more experience with academic papers than I do. > > Ian. > > > On Wed, Jan 11, 2012 at 9:29 PM, Michael Grube <michael.grube at gmail.com> > wrote: >> >> Thanks for the info! >> >> On Wed, Jan 11, 2012 at 10:12 PM, Ian Clarke <ian at freenetproject.org> >> wrote: >>> >>> fyi >>> >>> ---------- Forwarded message ---------- >>> From: David Hausheer <hausheer at kom.tu-darmstadt.de> >>> Date: Wed, Jan 11, 2012 at 5:27 PM >>> Subject: Call for Papers: IEEE P2P 2012 >>> To: David Hausheer <hausheer at kom.tu-darmstadt.de> >>> >>> >>> ##################################################################### >>> ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?IEEE P2P 2012 >>> ?12th International Conference in Peer-to-Peer Computing >>> ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? CALL FOR PAPERS >>> ##################################################################### >>> >>> September 3-5 2012, Tarragona (Spain) >>> http://www.ieee-p2p.org >>> >>> ###################################################################### >>> # Papers Due: *** April, 13 2012 *** >>> # Accepted papers will be published in the conference proceedings >>> # by the IEEE Computer Society Press, which are indexed by EI. >>> ###################################################################### >>> >>> The P2P'12 conference solicits papers on all aspects of large-scale >>> distributed computing. Of particular interest is research that >>> furthers the state-of-the-art in the design and analysis of >>> large-scale distributed applications and systems, or that investigates >>> real, deployed, applications or systems. We seek high-quality and >>> original contributions on this general theme along a range of topics >>> including: >>> >>> ? ?* Information retrieval and query support >>> ? ?* P2P for cloud computing >>> ? ?* Large-scale infrastructure technology >>> ? ?* Semantic overlay networks and semantic query routing >>> ? ?* P2P for grids, clouds, and datacenters >>> ? ?* Deployed (commercial) applications and systems >>> ? ?* Security, trust, and reputation >>> ? ?* Cooperation, incentives, and fairness >>> ? ?* P2P economics >>> ? ?* Social networks >>> ? ?* Overlay architectures and topologies >>> ? ?* Overlay interaction with underlying infrastructure >>> ? ?* Overlay monitoring and management >>> ? ?* Self-organization >>> ? ?* P2P applications and systems over mobile networks >>> ? ?* Measurements and modeling of P2P and cloud systems >>> ? ?* Performance, robustness, and scalability >>> >>> >>> >>> ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ >>> Paper submission guidelines >>> ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ >>> >>> Papers can be submitted either as full papers or as short papers >>> (following the IEEE single-spaced two-column format and a 10-point >>> font size). Full papers should not exceed 10 pages and short papers >>> should not exceed 5 pages. Short papers are expected to present work >>> that is less mature but holds promise, articulate a high-level vision, >>> describe challenging future directions or offer results that do not >>> merit a full submission. Please note that short papers also need >>> evaluation results or analysis to corroborate the claims of the paper >>> and that a paper longer than 5 pages is treated as a full paper. >>> >>> Papers must be submitted electronically in PDF format through the EDAS >>> paper-submission website linked from the conference website. IEEE >>> templates for LaTeX and Microsoft Word, as well as related >>> information, can be found at the IEEE Digital Toolbox webpage. The >>> conference proceedings will be published by the IEEE Communications >>> Society. >>> >>> All submissions will be evaluated using a double-blind review >>> process. To ensure blind reviewing, papers should be anonymized by >>> removing author names and affiliations, as well as by masking any >>> information about projects and bibliographic references, etc. that >>> might reveal the authors' identities. Papers that are not properly >>> anonymized will be rejected without review. Submitted papers should >>> describe original and previously unpublished research and are not >>> allowed to be simultaneously submitted or under review elsewhere. >>> >>> *Note:* P2P 2012 will experiment with two changes to the traditional >>> reviewing process: two-phase reviewing and "open reviews". These >>> changes are an effort to provide additional feedback to authors of >>> submitted papers and make the overall reviewing process more >>> transparent. Specifically, all paper submissions will receive between >>> 3 and 5 reviews each; while all papers will receive at least 3 >>> reviews, papers of sufficient quality will undergo a second reviewing >>> phase. In addition, the camera-ready version of each accepted paper >>> will be accompanied by a 1-page summary that consists of the >>> significant portions of the (anonymized) reviews that the paper >>> received during the reviewing process and a 1-paragraph summary by the >>> authors detailing how they addressed the reviewers' comments. The >>> conference proceedings as well as the conference website will include >>> the camera-ready version of each accepted paper together with the >>> corresponding 1-page summary review. >>> >>> In addition to the main conference, IEEE P2P 2012 will have a poster >>> and demo session, and a conference best paper award. ?Thanks to the >>> supporting organizations, P2P 2012 also plans to offer a small number >>> of travel grants . Application Information for these grants will be >>> published in the P2P'12 web site. >>> >>> ++++++++++++++++++ >>> Important Dates >>> ++++++++++++++++++ >>> >>> ?* Abstract Submission: April 6, 2012 >>> ?* Submission Deadline: April 13, 2012 >>> ?* Notification: July 9, 2012 >>> ?* Author Registration Deadline: July 20, 2012 >>> ?* Camera-ready: July 29, 2012 >>> ?* Conference dates: September 3-5, 2012 >>> >>> +++++++++++++++++++++ >>> Contact Information >>> +++++++++++++++++++++ >>> >>> Fabian Bustamante and John Douceur (TPC Chairs) >>> Email: p2p12-chairs at comsoc.org >>> >>> >>> Pedro Garcia Lopez (General Chair) >>> Email: p2p12 at comsoc.org >>> >>> >>> >>> -- >>> Ian Clarke >>> Founder, The Freenet Project >>> Email: ian at freenetproject.org >>> >>> _______________________________________________ >>> Devl mailing list >>> Devl at freenetproject.org >>> http://freenetproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/devl >> >> >> >> _______________________________________________ >> Devl mailing list >> Devl at freenetproject.org >> http://freenetproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/devl > > > > > -- > Ian Clarke > Personal blog: http://blog.locut.us/ > > _______________________________________________ > Devl mailing list > Devl at freenetproject.org > http://freenetproject.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/devl
