+1... for me Le 21 nov. 08 à 16:39, Vincent Massol a écrit :
> > On Nov 21, 2008, at 3:51 PM, Jean-Vincent Drean wrote: > >> On Fri, Nov 21, 2008 at 2:58 PM, Vincent Massol <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> >> wrote: >>> +1 in general but some comments to address: >>> >>> * I don't understand the "Fullscreen" text and the "/ ..." element >>> next to it >> >> The link is supposed to be less visible, I've updated the mockup (and >> I think there will be a little pop-out icon at the left in the end). >> http://dev.xwiki.org/xwiki/bin/view/Design/NewWysiwygEditorInterface#HToolbars > > Yes I think an icon/image would be better than text. for me text is better : users do not understand/use fullscreen icon > > >>> * I see you've put Wiki and Wysiwyg tabs. What happens if I want a >>> text area with only wiki mode or only wysiwyg editor? >> >> "2 models of toolbars will be available : one for classic textareas >> (wiki pages, blog articles, generally speaking all large textareas) >> and one for smaller textareas (comments, short descriptions)." >> The light version of the wysiwyg editor is to be defined. > > ok so it's not part of this discussion I guess. > >>> * Where are located the other editors (objects, class, rights, >>> history, etc)? >> >> This discussion is not part of this vote imho. >> >>> * Why are there some arrow ">" in some menu items but not in others? >> >> The arrows were here to make a difference between single entry vs. >> multiple entries dropdowns but they are not relevant now, I've >> removed >> them. >> >>> * Edit image properties --> Edit image >>> * Edit macro properties --> Edit macro >> >> It reminds me a discussion about focusing on the meaning of words ;) >> Since we don't provide an online image editor + we don't offer the >> ability to edit macros from the wysiwyg I'm still +1 for keeping >> "properties". >> >>> * I don't think we can have macros listed in the menu item. We need >>> categorization + ability to search for macros to insert them so I'd >>> rather have "Insert Macro" instead with possibly below (separated >>> by a >>> ---) a list of common macros with a "More..." button too. >> >> Looks better. I've updated the mockup accordingly. >> >>> * I'm not sure I like the where the help is located in the wiki >>> editor. Also I think it might be good to have the same toolbar in >>> wiki >>> editor (this removes the need for the help there I think and we can >>> instead have a reference help somewhere else or simply a "?" button >>> that opens the help) >> >> "You can ignore the inline syntax help in wiki mode, it was just a >> thought while doing the mockup." > > I know but you're asking to vote on the general toolbar layout. What > I'm saying and which is an important decision is that we might want to > also have toolbars for the wiki editor. > >>> * I'm not sure where "Justify left" is located, couldn't find it. >> >> "Don't pay attention to the text formatting toolbar, I've used >> balsamiq >> default widget and it is not a spec for our toolbar." > > I was commenting on the following text: > > "Hovering on a menu item such as "Justify left" highlights the item > with a transparent dark background with a border" > > I wasn't sure what this was applying to? > > oh... could it be that you don't mean "menu item" but "toolbar > item"? :) > > In which case I agree. > > Thanks > -Vincent > _______________________________________________ > devs mailing list > [email protected] > http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/devs _______________________________________________ devs mailing list [email protected] http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/devs
