Hi Thibaut, So, what is freigntening me is that the number of elements and the > altenances field-name/field-content may make it diffcult to scan the list. > Since users generally start looking for informations in scan mode it can be > a limitation. >
I thing there is separation for the profile, so the scan mode is not that limited. You have: - subcategories (Personal, Contact Informations) - left-right + change in background color between the information a user can edit and the ones he cannot (Rights+Recent Activity) - also we have space between pairs of field-name/field-content > By removing the "first name" and "last name" fieds (*since this information > is already at the top*) we can limit this. > The main reason I don't want to remove this fields is the compatibility - symmetry for the profile in view/edit mode. View mode: http://incubator.myxwiki.org/xwiki/bin/download/Improvements/UserProfileProposal/generalProfilesSimple.png Edit mode: http://incubator.myxwiki.org/xwiki/bin/download/Improvements/UserProfileProposal/defaultFields2Edit.png In edit mode, the fields are in the same position like in the view. If I enter a value in Edit mode, I can clearly see the modification in View mode. Imagine a user entering his First and Last Name. He hits save, but he can't find this fields anywhere in the profile page. How you will explain him that he need to look in the page title? Usually in a form, the user expects the same structure of the form after save. I would like to check the relevance ot this, is the code available somewhere > ? (I'm sorry I'm not a dev so I'm a bit lost in using svn) > The code is not available on svn. This are just mockups, ideas. They will go into the SVN when they will be implemented. Thibaut, you should try to make a quick mockup in an graphical editor or even on a piece of paper and scan it. Sometimes I don't fully understand an idea and the best solution is to represent it in a picture. Thanks, Caty _______________________________________________ devs mailing list [email protected] http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/devs
