Hi Jonathan, Allow me first to leave some remarks as I've wrote them down when checking out your work :
* The main content area scrolls when clicking the sidebar control icons. This seem to happen only when the page is already a bit scrolled. Is this the expected behavior ? * Clicking the search box redirects to the home page * Seems the history UI is not loading with AJAX as colibri does it. I think it would be a questionnable approach, as it increases the cost of loading a page, while the history will not be checked out by users most of the times. * Internationalization is missing. (For example the "Swipe horizontally to access menu") * Do you have any use of modernizr ? If not we should remove it. * There is no edit mode switcher when editing the page. If you update your repos you can checkout how I've done it for Lyrebird * The "profile" and "logout" links overlap the sidebar controls on Firefox. See http://i.imgur.com/LRgIc.png * Top "Add" menu "add comment to page" and "add attachment to page" have no effect * The "document index" tabs don't look too good when small screen estate. See http://imgur.com/GalCk That should be about it for now. Regarding the next items that could be addressed, here is what I have in mind : * Search. The synchronous search UI seems fine, but now it would be great to have a functional search suggest. * Ensure consistency of styles across the standard XE UI. I've seen some forms remain un-styled, for example the "Add space" and "Add page" ones. This is a work of playing hide and seek with your wiki :) * It would be good that you document your patch on the livetable macros/JS somewhere so that it's easier for us to understand what you've done and possibly to integrate it * Color themes ? Apps ? Thanks, and keep up the good work ! Jerome On Tue, Jul 17, 2012 at 8:50 PM, Jonathan Solichin <[email protected]>wrote: > Hello Friends, > > As you may or may not know, I have been working on a responsive skin for > XWiki for GSOC (http://23.21.87.183:8080/xwiki/bin/view/Main/WebHome). As > I > continue to add further details and refinements into the skin, I would like > to kindly ask for your help in doing so. In order to make sure that I did > not miss anything and the skin is as complete as possible, I would like to, > if possible, request a XAR of an existing wiki (or complex pages) so that I > may see the result of implementing the skin on more than the default wiki > data. > > If this is not a possible, I would like to still enlist your help in > testing some basic/your favorite functionality/features of xwiki. There are > several ways to do this: > > - By downloading the current skin and testing it on your XWiki: > https://github.com/jssolichin/xo5 > - By playing around with the live instance (uses default admin > user/password): http://23.21.87.183:8080/xwiki/bin/view/Main/WebHome > - By letting me know of your favorite applications (so that I may look > into implementing them) > > Anything you want to note is fine. Bug and feature request are both > welcome, as I think communal ideas are often better than one. Even if you > did not have a chance to play too much with the skin, go ahead and let me > know what you think I should check on (based on your experience) and/or > give me any suggestions that may have come up while reading this. > Technicality permitting, I will check myself. > > Helping with this process will help make the skin better, and maybe help it > to be tailored to your (/type of) wiki and the community surrounding the > platform in general. > > Thank you in advance for your time! > Jonathan Solichin > _______________________________________________ > devs mailing list > [email protected] > http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/devs > -- Jérôme Velociter Winesquare http://www.winesquare.net/ _______________________________________________ devs mailing list [email protected] http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/devs
